Nepal | August 12, 2020

Commuting of Ranjan Koirala’s sentence likely to be reviewed

Share Now:

KATHMANDU: The Supreme Court today granted leave to the Office of the Attorney General to file a review petition against its division bench’s verdict that commuted the life sentence of murder convict former deputy inspector general of Armed Police Force Ranjan Koirala.

Koirala, who was sentenced to life imprisonment for murdering his wife Geeta Dhakal, walked out of jail on July 23 after serving only eight and-a- half years, as a division bench of Chief Justice Cholendra Sumsher JB Rana and Justice Tej Bahadur KC commuted his sentence on June 29, invoking Section 188 of Court Management of erstwhile Country Code (Muluki Ain) and Section 17 (a) of Criminal Offence (Determination of Punishment and Implementation) Act, 2017.

The verdict caused public outcry and former prime minister Baburam Bhattarai demanded that the justices who delivered the verdict be impeached. People protested at Maitighar Mandala, demanding impeachment of the chief justice.

Normally an SC verdict is final, but in rare cases where the apex court’s verdict goes against its own precedent and when new evidence emerges, then the apex court grants leave for judicial review.

Leave for judicial review was granted by a full bench of justices Bam Kumar Shrestha, Prakash Kumar Dhungana and Kumar Regmi.

Office of the Attorney General had filed a judicial review petition at the apex court on Friday, arguing that the decision to commute the life sentence of Koirala by a division bench of Chief Justice Cholendra Shumsher JB Rana and Justice Tej Bahadur KC was erroneous, as it wrongly invoked Section 188 of the Court Management Chapter of the erstwhile Country Code (Muluki Ain) and Criminal Offence (Determination of Punishment and Implementation) Act.

The Supreme Court observed that Koirala’s attempt to dump the body of his wife and destroy evidence did not make it look like ordinary incident or accidental incident.

The court said it was granting leave for judicial review as the division bench’s verdict violated the precedent set in Shanti BK versus Government of Nepal, Government of Nepal versus Jugat Sada, Government of Nepal versus Sher Bahadur Basnet and Kedar Majhi versus Government of Nepal with regard to the invoking of Section 188 of the Court Management Chapter of erstwhile Country Code.

Spokesperson for the OAG Sanjeeb Raj Regmi said the SC agreed with almost all the arguments furnished by his office in the review petition and the full bench of the SC would have to settle all the questions raised in today’s order.

The OAG stated in its review petition that the SC’s decision to invoke Section 188 of the Court Management Chapter of the Country Code was wrong as it was a procedural law and it had already been repealed.

The court cannot invoke the provision of the act that has been repealed, OAG Spokesperson Regmi said.

According to Regmi, the Supreme Court had set a precedent about the invoking of Section 188 of the Court Management Chapter of the Country Code, saying that the defendant’s act must appear like an accident and homicide should not appear like a premeditated act, but in this case, both elements were missing, Regmi argued.

“Case file shows that Koirala intentionally killed his wife and went to Makawanpur to dump her body.

Even the division bench of the SC that commuted Koirala’s sentence has accepted that Koirala intentionally killed his wife,” he added.

He said the apex court’s decision to invoke Section 17 (a) of Criminal Offence (Determination of Punishment and Implementation) was also wrong. “In order for 17 (a) to apply, the defendant(s) must confess to their crime and other evidence should corroborate their confession. But in this case, Koirala had pleaded not guilty before the court,” Regmi argued.

Koirala had been serving the sentence since 22 January 2012, the day he was arrested on the charge of murdering his wife. Koirala had killed her at their Budhanilkantha residence.

Koirala later took his wife’s body to Tistung in Makawanpur district and burnt it to destroy evidence.

Kathmandu District Court heard the case for two-and-a-half years and held Koirala guilty of murdering his wife, condemning him to life imprisonment with confiscation of his entire property.

Life imprisonment in the case of Koirala counts to a 20-year jail sentence as per the old Country Code that was in effect then. The Appellate Court later upheld the district court’s verdict.

The SC commuted his sentence, with the division bench observing that he should be released to take care of his children, stating, “The punishment is too much for him.”

Recently, the SC overturned its own decision through review petition in cases involving former princess Prerana Rajya Laxmi Devi Singh and former chief of Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority Lok Man Singh Karki.

The apex court barred Singh from inheriting 15 ropani and one ana land in Chhauni area and nullified Karki’s appointment to the CIAA.

CJ Rana, justices Tej Bahadur KC, Bam Kumar Shrestha, Prakash Kumar Dhungana, Kumar Regmi, Sapana Pradhan Malla and Ananda Mohan Shrestha will have to recuse themselves from the case involving Koirala.

Koirala was released from prison on July 23. 



Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

849 passengers arrive on last day of fourth phase of repatriation

KATHMANDU, AUGUST 10 A total of 849 Nepalis were evacuated today via five flights. According to Tribhuvan International Airport (TIA), Nepal Airlines Corporation (NAC) evacuated 151 passengers and Himalaya Airlines repatriated 149 passengers from Doha in Qatar. Himalaya Airlines also brought h Read More...

Lebanese government resigns after Beirut blast, public anger

BEIRUT: Lebanon’s prime minister stepped down from his job Monday in the wake of the catastrophic explosion in Beirut that has triggered public outrage, saying he has come to the conclusion that corruption in the country is “bigger than the state.” The move risks opening the way to dragged- Read More...

Ramechhap farmers perform puja for rain

Ramechhap, August 10 At a time when continuous rainfall and attendant disasters have been causing loss of life and property in most parts of the country, farmers of Manthali, Ramechhap, are offering puja to god for rainfall so that they can cultivate paddy. As rainfall hasn’t occurred here t Read More...

Coronavirus infections stabilise in Australia's Victoria state

Victoria reports 331 new COVID-19 cases, 19 deaths NSW reports biggest one-day rise in cases since April SYDNEY: Australia's second-most populous state reported only a small rise in new COVID-19 infections on Tuesday, boosting hopes that case numbers are stabilising after a second wave f Read More...


Don’t let COVID-19 overshadow the risk of dengue

The human race is currently going through a scourge of the COVID-19 pandemic, caused by a newly discovered coronavirus, SARS-CoV-2, which originated in Wuhan, China in December 2019. Since then, more than 200 countries have fallen victim to this virus. There are more than 4 million active cases acro Read More...

Antonio Banderas says he's tested positive for coronavirus

NEW YORK: Antonio Banderas says he's tested positive for COVID-19 and is celebrating his 60th birthday in quarantine. The Spanish actor announced his positive test in a post Monday on Instagram. Banderas said he would spend his time in isolation reading, writing and “making plans to begin to g Read More...

Ganges River flows with history and prophecy for India

ALONG THE GANGES: More than 2,000 years ago, a powerful king built a fort on the banks of India’s holiest river, on the fringes of what is now a vast industrial city. Today, little of the ancient construction remains, except for mounds of rubble that tannery workers pick through for bricks to b Read More...

Trump abruptly escorted from briefing after shooting near WH

WASHINGTON: President Donald Trump was abruptly escorted by a US Secret Service agent out of the White House briefing room as he was beginning a coronavirus briefing Monday afternoon. He returned minutes later, saying there had been a “shooting” outside the White House that was “under control. Read More...