Nepal | July 08, 2020

‘Procedure for appointing CIAA officials biased’

Ram Kumar Kamat
Share Now:

Kathmandu, November 28

Mandatory provision of 20 years of experience in accounting, revenue, engineering, law, development, or research for appointment to the Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority has been serving the interest of former bureaucrats. Owing to the provision, mostly former bureaucrats have been appointed as office bearers of the anti-graft body.

Article 238 (6) of the constitution stipulates that to be eligible for office bearer of the CIAA, one needs to have at least 20 years of experiences in the field of either accounting, revenue, engineering, law, development or research. Apart from meeting these qualifications one should be a distinguished personality.

The constitution stipulates 20 years of experience for one to be appointed in the National Human Rights Commission, CIAA, Auditor General’s Office, Natural Resource and Fiscal Commission. However, no such requirement exists for appointment in the Election Commission.

According to the constitution, a person who has made outstanding contribution, for at least ten years in the field of rights and interests of women or gender justice or women development or human rights and law qualifies to be appointed in the National Women Rights Commission.

However, one needs to have only 10 years of such experience for appointment in the Dalit Commission, the National Inclusion Commission, the Tharu Commission, the Madhesi Commission, the Indigenous Nationalities Commission and the Muslim Commission.

Senior Advocate Surendra Kumar Mahto and Advocate Sunil Ranjan Singh said the requirement of 20 years of experience was irrelevant as people could acquire enough experience in one  field in five to 10 years.

They said the bureaucrats intentionally included the 20-year-experience clause in the constitution to serve their vested interests. “If we look at the history of the CIAA appointment, most of the office bearers including its chairperson are former bureaucrats and professors. Appointment of freelancers in the CIAA is almost nil,” Mahto added. He said the constitution and laws had contradictory provisions regarding experience. “Why is there 20 years of experience clause for the CIAA and 10 years of experience clause for other commissions? Does this mean that other commissions where only 10 years of experience is required, are inferior?” Mahto wondered.

He said the eligibility criteria must be revised to do away with the 20 years of experience requirement in the CIAA and some other commissions.

Singh argued that a candidate who has obtained multiple masters degree and even PhD degree at the age of 30 or 35 years should be allowed to serve as an office bearer of the CIAA if he/she meets other qualifications.

Senior Advocate Surendra Bhandari said even if the 20 years of experience clause remained unchanged, the government must not appoint former bureaucrats in the CIAA to ensure its impartiality. “We see cases of former secretaries being indicted in corruption cases, so the government should not appoint former bureaucrats in the CIAA to ensure that the anti-graft body acts independently and impartially,” he said.


A version of this article appears in print on November 29, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Transport entrepreneurs deposit vehicle keys at banks in Pokhara

POKHARA: After failing to deposit the loan installment in the wake of extended lockdown, transport entrepreneurs handed-over vehicle keys to bank officials in Pokhara, on Monday. As many as ninety entrepreneurs associated with Prithvi Highway Bus Association handed over the keys to officials Read More...

175 suicide deaths in Sudurpaschim during lockdown

DADELDHURA, JULY 6 As many as 175 people have died by suicide during the nationwide lockdown in Sudurpaschim Province. Police said that suicide deaths have been reported from all nine districts of the province from March 24 till date. Police said suicide deaths were more common among males com Read More...

Triyuga Municipality, Gaghat

Lawyer arrested for allegedly assaulting 7 yo

GAIGHAT: A lawyer has been arrested for allegedly assaulting a seven-year-old boy at Triyuga Municipality-12 in Udaypur district. Police have arrested Indra Tamang, a lawyer, for beating Ian Limbu, a resident of Bikram Marg in the Municipality, on Monday night. Sanjana Limbu, the victim's mot Read More...

Nepal’s COVID-19 tally crosses 16,000 with 204 new cases recorded on Tuesday

KATHMANDU: With the confirmation of 204 new cases, Nepal’s coronavirus infection tally has crossed the 16,000-mark and stands at 16,168 on Tuesday. In the last 24 hours, 688 people have been discharged from health facilities across the country after recovery from COVID-19, stated Ministry of He Read More...

COVID-19 Highlights: 204 new cases, 688 recoveries reported Tuesday

KATHMANDU: Nepal’s Health Ministry, in its regular press briefing, shared the latest updates on coronavirus contagion from across the country, and government’s response to the health crisis. As of today, 261,861 tests through Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) method and 312,402 Rapid Diagn Read More...

India's coronavirus death toll hits 20,000 as infections surge

India's death toll from the coronavirus pandemic surpassed 20,000 on Tuesday and case numbers surged as the south Asian nation pushed ahead with relaxations to its almost two-month lockdown amid grim economic forecasts. The rate of both new COVID-19 infections and deaths are rising at the fastest Read More...

London

Have you considered UK for future studies? You might, with the new Graduate Route provision

KATHMANDU: The United Kingdom government has announced -- a good news for international students -- that those willing to work in the UK post their graduation will be able to do so under the new graduate programme. The UK-based international students who hold a valid Tier 4 visa will be able to b Read More...

American singer Charlie Puth asks BTS ARMYs, other fandoms to end 'toxic screaming match', implores all to be nicer to each other

KATHMANDU: American musician Charlie Puth has called out the toxic K-pop fandoms, especially BTS ARMY, to put an end to the dangerous stan culture. Allkpop reports that on July 6, the See You Again singer took to Twitter pleading with ARMYs and other K-pop fandoms to end the "dangerous, toxic, Read More...