Nepal | July 09, 2020

Tendering versus conservation

Local community members have already raised their voices to stop the construction through tendering

Kai Weise
Share Now:

Hanuman Dhoka damaged by earthquakeKathmandu

The Public Procurement Act says, “Thou shalt tender all projects” and therefore all projects are put to tender. The estimates are calculated by rule of the thumb; are they worthy of five or rather 10 million rupees? In the hallowed halls of the government funds are allocated in random selection. This is said to have strictly followed the Post Disaster Needs
Assessment (PDNA), the omnipresent PDNA. The government rituals are performed ensuring that the rules are followed to the dot. The lowest bidder will get the work.

The contractors throng the office of Department of Archaeology (DoA) as the tenders are collected, jostling around making deals to secure their pick. Considering that not even the policy let alone the conservation guidelines have been finalised, how were tender documents prepared? There is a proud announcement that 27 tenders for heritage structures have already been finalised.

There are fortunately several reasons why this system will not work. The most obvious is the total disconnect between those preparing the tender documents and the reality on the site. Drawings are made of the possible original state of the historic buildings with little understanding of its traditional system or the state of damage. This means that tenders are based on a totally unsuitable technical language and rehabilitation process that completely neglects traditional practice and local community. There are no indications for the need for traditional artisans who would be the only ones able to reconstruct or restore historic monuments.

The tender documents have been prepared without any understanding of conservation principle and procedures. The assumption is that the entire structure will be rebuilt using new materials with some sort of added strengthening such as concrete or steel tie beams. As soon as the guidelines are adopted these projects will have to undergo an entirely new cycle of assessments, in most cases probably nullifying the tender. The reuse of salvaged materials has also not been considered, especially since the identification of such elements is still on-going and in many cases has not even begun.

There is constant reference to the on-going tendering being done based on PDNA that was prepared as per the report ‘in just over three weeks, a tight timeline, given the scale and magnitude of the disaster’. The PDNA was a wonderful means of obtaining pledges at International Conference on Nepal’s Reconstruction (ICNR) on June 25. The amount that was calculated under the section for cultural heritage was USD 215 million but could have been a 100 million more or less. Clearly this is too blunt tool to be used for implementation. The tenders indicate how much money needs to be spent on each monument and not how much is needed to ensure its correct reconstruction.

There are many examples of tenders that have been floated for the reconstruction or restoration of monuments without the local community, priests and maintenance committees being aware of it. One such case is the Vishnu temple of ten avatars at Hanuman Dhoka next to the Kumari House which totally collapsed. The local community members have
already raised their voices to stop the construction through tendering. Other examples include the tantric temples around Swayambhu where only the initiated priests are allowed to enter. The consolidation of the partially damaged Pratappur and the reconstruction of the mostly collapsed Anantapur by random contractors will be a contentious issue.

UNESCO has shown concern that the tendering procedure would lead to detrimental work being carried out on the monuments. It was discussed with the DoA and the National Reconstruction Authority that a more appropriate system would be established. In the meantime all tenders must be stopped.

(The author is an architect and can be contacted through paharnepal@hotmail.com)


A version of this article appears in print on February 20, 2016 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Over 90pc COVID-19 recovery reported in Rautahat

RAUTAHAT: Rautahat district, which has been hard-hit by the pandemic, has shown a promising rate of COVID-19 recovery. The district with about 92 percent of patients being discharged from health facilities has bagged much appreciation for the efforts of the concerned authorities. According to Read More...

India's COVID-19 challenges continue; 22,752 fresh cases detected on Wednesday

KATHMANDU: India's challenges with the ongoing coronavirus crisis continues with the confirmation of more than 22,000 cases on Wednesday. According to the Union Health Ministry of India, in the last 24 hours, as many as 22,752 positive cases of the respiratory infection have been detected country Read More...

95 discharged after recovering from COVID-19 in Tanahun

DAMAULI: As many as 95 persons have been discharged upon recovery from coronavirus infection in Tanahun district, on Wednesday. According to Tanahun District Health Office (DHO), the patients were released after two of their consecutive specimens drawn within 24 hours tested negative for the Read More...

Seven killed in oil platform ladder installation blast in southern Nigeria

ABUJA: Seven people were killed in an explosion at the Gbetiokun oil field in southern Nigeria’s Niger Delta region during the installation of a ladder on a platform, the state oil company said on Wednesday. Accidents and pipeline attacks in the Niger Delta are common in Nigeria, cutting into t Read More...

England 35-1 at tea as rain hits first test

SOUTHAMPTON: After a 117-day absence, international cricket returned in familiar fashion on Wednesday as rain delayed the first test between England and West Indies before the hosts lost Dom Sibley for 0 then reached 35-1 as bad light brought an early tea. Much else about the occasion felt Read More...

Silva shines as Man City thrash Newcastle 5-0

MANCHESTER: David Silva scored one goal and made two more as Manchester City put on a passing masterclass to overwhelm Newcastle United with a 5-0 Premier League victory on Wednesday. Having announced that he will leave the club at the end of this season after a 10-year spell, the 34- Read More...

Salah double keeps Liverpool on track for points record

BRIGHTON: Mohamed Salah scored twice as champions Liverpool moved on to 92 points with a 3-1 win at Brighton and Hove Albion in the Premier League on Wednesday. The victory kept Liverpool on target to secure a record Premier League points tally, with Juergen Klopp's side needing nine from Read More...

Adequate social security key to minimise impact of COVID-19, says PM Oli

KATHMANDU, JULY 8 Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli said protection of the most vulnerable, including migrant workers and those in informal sectors, and provision of adequate social security and health care was the key to minimise the impact of COVID-19. Addressing virtual ‘Global Summit on COVID Read More...