Nepal | August 08, 2020

Rights activists say new anti-torture law should have retroactive effect

Himalayan News Service
Share Now:

Kathmandu, September 1

Human rights activists and torture victims have highlighted the need for amendments to the new anti-torture bill, especially the provisions relating to the definition of torture, punishment for the perpetrators and compensation for the victims.

They also said that the new torture law should have retroactive effect in order to enable the state to punish the conflict-era perpetrators of torture.

Addressing an interaction organised by Accountability Watch Committee and Democratic Freedom and Human Rights Institute here today, human rights lawyer Govinda Bandi said the current bill’s definition of torture did not match the definition contained in the United Nations Convention against Torture to which Nepal is a party.

“Torture has already been defined in international law and hence it should not be defined locally,” he said, adding that if the definition of torture did not match its definition in international law, Nepal would continue to draw flak at UN forums. “Under international law, he argued, there is no statute of limitations for cases of torture, but the current bill proposes statute of limitations of 90 days,” he added.

Bandi said the bill criminalised torture by public officials in custody but that definition should expand to any place. He said the National Human Rights Commission or the Office of the Attorney General should be given the power to investigate cases of torture.

Presenting a paper on the bill, Advocate Om Prakash Aryal said torture was a serious crime under international law and there must be jail term for the offence but the bill envisages the provision of ‘jail term or fine’ which was wrong.

“The bill proposes five-year imprisonment or a fine of Rs 50,000. How can a perpetrator of such a serious crime be let off with just fine?” he wondered. Aryal said the bill did not fully incorporate the legal doctrine of universal jurisdiction. Four-year jail term for those who gave shelter to the perpetrator or assisted the perpetrator was too high, he argued.

Aryal said the bill did not cover the crimes of torture committed during Maoist insurgency.

He also said that basic compensation should be provided to victims by the state. Proposing fine for making false accusation would discourage the real victims from filing complaints, he argued.

Madhabi Bhatta, member of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, said the transitional justice mechanism also had to investigate cases of torture but it would not be able to carry out its assigned duties unless the required amendments were made.

Attorney General Raman Kumar Shrestha said lawmakers needed to file amendment proposal in the Parliament to make the bill compatible with universal standards.

“If the new law fails to meet international standards then we all know what will happen,” he said in an oblique reference to the application of universal jurisdiction.

Janak Bahadur Raut, who identified himself as a torture victim, said the bill did not criminalise torture that could take place after the arrest of somebody and before s/he was put into a detention centre. He also said that non-state actors could also subject somebody to torture but the bill did not criminalise such acts.

Dev Bahadur Maharjan, who identified himself as a torture victim, said the bill did not propose enough protection for torture victims who could be victimised by their perpetrators after lodging complaints.


A version of this article appears in print on September 02, 2016 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Worldwide coronavirus cases cross 19.16 million, death toll over 714,000

At least 19,166,379 people have been reported to be infected by the novel coronavirus globally and 714,246 people have died, a Reuters tally showed. Infections have been reported in more than 210 countries and territories since the first cases were identified in China in December 2019. Th Read More...

District administration offices agree on 16-day restrictions in valley

KATHMANDU, AUGUST 7 All three district administration offices of Kathmandu valley have decided to allow only emergency services for 16 days — August 9 to August 24 — and suspend the rest to break the chain of COVID transmission, as people had been venturing out of their homes in droves of lat Read More...

Locals of Nayagaun face double insecurity at Nepal-India border

RANJHA: People in Nayagaun in Raptisonari Rural Municipality-4 of Banke district have been compelled to live with double insecurity due to border encroachment by the Indian side and because of timber and river-based aggregates smugglers. Locals complained about their problems as they interacted w Read More...

Two persons succumb to COVID-19 at Patan Hospital

KATHMANDU: Two COVID-19 patients undergoing treatment at Patan Hospital have succumbed to the contagion on Friday morning. A 45-year-old man from Sarlahi died at around 9:00 am today during the course of treatment for coronavirus infection at the isolation ward, Patan Hospital's Director Bishnu P Read More...

Nepal COVID-19 Update: 464 new cases, 425 recoveries, five deaths recorded today

KATHMANDU: Nepal’s Health Ministry, in its regular press briefing, shared the latest updates on coronavirus contagion from across the country, and government’s response to the health crisis. As of today, 427,501 tests through Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) method have been carried out, w Read More...

Five days after ward chair's demise, four of his family members test COVID-19 positive

RAUTAHAT: Four family members of ward chair of Ishanath Municipality-5 in Rautahat district have tested positive for the coronavirus infection. Ward chair Devendra Thakur, who died at the age of 55 on Monday, had asthma, diabetes and high blood pressure. After having respiratory problems, he was Read More...

Nationwide COVID-19 tally crosses 22k with 464 new cases detected on Friday

KATHMANDU: The Ministry of Health and Population has recorded 464 new cases of the coronavirus infection on Friday, taking the nationwide count to 22,214. The new infections were confirmed after testing 7,926 specimens through PCR method across the nation in the last 24 hours. Among the new ca Read More...

PM Oli extends best wishes to his Sri Lankan counterpart

KATHMANDU: Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli congratulated Sri Lankan Prime Minister Mahinda Rajapaksa, on his landslide victory in the Sri Lankan People's Party parliamentary election and conveyed best wishes for his successful tenure of office. The press release published by the Ministry of Foreign Read More...