Nepal | July 14, 2020

Victims’ woes unaddressed


Roshan S Nepal
Share Now:
  • Families of those who disappeared during the Maoist insurgency that lasted from 1996 to 2006 still continue their fight to know the whereabouts of their loved ones and grapple with various vulnerabilities and social stigma.

Kathmandu, August 29

The Supreme Court’s landmark verdict in June 2007 directing the government to take measures to address their grievances continues to delude victims of conflict-era disappearances.

The SC had directed the government to ensure accountability for disappearances, establish a commission of inquiry consistent with international standards, criminalise enforced disappearances, investigate and prosecute persons responsible for disappearances and provide adequate compensation and relief to victims and their families.

Similarly, international organisations had also urged the government to investigate cases of enforced disappearances, provide adequate compensation to victims and their families and enact laws in line with international standards and Supreme Court verdicts.

However, the government has neither implemented Supreme Court verdicts nor has it bothered to heed international organisations.

The government set up the Commission of Investigation on Enforced Disappeared Persons in 2015. The commission collected 3,212 complaints of conflict-era enforced disappearances. However, it failed to investigate even a single case, thanks to lack of legislation, the state’s financial control over CIEDP and the commissioners’ loyalty to political parties.

As the world marks International Day of the Disappeared tomorrow, families of those who disappeared during the Maoist insurgency that lasted from 1996 to 2006 still continue their fight to know the whereabouts of their loved ones and grapple with various vulnerabilities and social stigma.

That fight has now shifted to the second generation in some cases. Nagma Mali of Thecho, Lalitpur, is a case in point. Nagma was seven years old when security forces picked up her father Nanda Gopal from Tahachal area in April 2004. Nagma and her younger sister, who had lost their mother at a very young age, also lost their grandfather Sanu to cancer a year after their father’s disappearance.

The two sisters were then raised by their grandmother Mishree, who also lost her life in January this year.“My grandmother fought for her entire life to know the whereabouts of her disappeared son,” said Nagma, now 22. “Now, I have taken up the baton.”

However, this is not the only front Nagma is fighting on. She is also fighting a court battle against her father’s cousins who tried to grab her grandfather’s property after his death although her father was the only son of his parents and he should have inherited Sanu’s property.

After Nanda Gopal disappeared, the property should have ideally been transferred to Nagma and her sister. But as per the law, Nagma needed to produce their father’s death certificate.

Although, the kin can acquire death certificate 12 years after the disappearance, Nagma does not want to do so.“How can I acquire death certificate of my father when the state has not said he is dead?” Sanu asked. “So my father’s cousins are trying to exploit my compulsion and grab our property.”

This is a common problem faced by the victims as male heads of family who control family property have been disappeared in majority of cases. This has also led to the family losing guardianship and struggling financially.

“There’s not a single day when I do not miss my father,” said Nagma. “But I miss him the most when I am not able to pursue things I like in the absence of a guardian who could have supported me morally and financially.”

Nagma represents victims based in urban areas who have somewhat better access, but things are worse when it comes to those who are based in remote areas. Such victims, who make up more than 45 per cent, have not even received government relief and do not know whether an inquiry commission has been established, according to Bishnu Pathak, former member of CIEDP that conducted preliminary investigation into complaints in around 60 districts.

“They are so naive they just want to know the truth and conduct the final rites of their loved ones,” said Pathak. “Women are the most affected in rural areas because of the associated social stigma,” he said.

Pathak said the problem could not be solved without strong political will. Victims’ families also say the issue could be resolved only if the state implemented the Supreme Court’s verdicts, fulfilled social, political and economic needs of the victims, told victims the truth and guaranteed non-repetition of conflict.

“The solution lies at the local level,” said Ram Kumar Bhandari, founder of National Network of Families of Disappeared and Missing Nepal. “But strong political will is needed.”

A version of this article appears in print on August 30, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Salyan village at risk of landslide for last 30 years

SALYAN, JULY 12 A settlement of 100 plus families in Kapurkot Rural Municipality, Salyan, has been at risk of landslide for the past three decades. Their fear of being swept away doubles when it rains. This monsoon, six metres land in the area have caved in. However, the government and auth Read More...

Man kills uncle in Kaski

POKHARA, JULY 12 A man killed his uncle in Madi Rural Municipality, Kaski, last night. Police said Nawaraj Sapkota killed his uncle Pitamber Sapkota, 78, by attacking him with a khukuri over a minor domestic dispute. Ward Chairman Satyaraj Sapkota said Pitamber died on the spot. He said tha Read More...

First phase of repatriation flights ends, second to begin from Wednesday

KATHMANDU, JULY 12 The first phase of repatriating Nepalis stranded in different countries due to the COVID-19 has concluded today. According to the COV- ID-19 Crisis Management Centre (CCMC), a total of 26,396 Nepalis were evacuated from 24 countries in the last one month. The repatriation fligh Read More...

Two held with banned pharmaceutical drugs in Siraha

SIRAHA: Police in Siraha district on Sunday arrested two persons in possession of banned pharmaceutical drugs at two different places. A team of police in civvies deployed from Bariyarpatti Police Post arrested Chandan Kumar Yadav (20) of Shreepur in Bariyarpatti Rural Municipality-2 in possessio Read More...

Man Utd's De Gea needs more trophies, says Solskjaer

Goalkeeper David de Gea will not be content with personal accolades and needs to win more major trophies at Manchester United, manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has said. De Gea, 29, has won United's Player of the Year award four times since arriving from Atletico Madrid in 2011 but the club have Read More...

Poland's Duda seen winning presidential vote-majority results

WARSAW: Poland's incumbent candidate Andrzej Duda has won a presidential election, results from 99.97% of polling stations showed early on Monday, a narrow victory that would allow the ruling nationalists to deepen their conservative reforms. Duda, an ally of the ruling conservative Law and Read More...

Zindziswa, daughter of Nelson Mandela, dies at 59

KATHMANDU: Zindziswa Mandela, daughter of former South African president Nelson Mandela and Winnie Madikizela-Mandela, has died. She was 59. State television South African Broadcasting Corporation has reported that Mandela died at a Johannesburg hospital early Monday morning Zindziswa, dau Read More...

Kelly Preston, actress and wife of John Travolta, dies at 57

LOS ANGELES: Actress Kelly Preston, whose credits included the films "Twins" and "Jerry Maguire," died Sunday, her husband John Travolta said. She was 57. Travolta confirmed his wife's death in an Instagram post late Sunday. He said she died after a two-year battle with breast cancer. "It Read More...