Nepal | July 09, 2020

Poverty reduction efforts Are they going in the right direction?

Poverty reduction efforts Are they going in the right direction?
Share Now:

Devendra Pratap Shah

Development efforts in countries like Nepal become meaningful only when they benefit poor people. Nepal has been pursuing planned development for nearly five decades, but the country’s poverty ratio still remains one of the highest in the world. Nepal is characterised by great disparities in sex, caste, ethnic groups and regions. Nepal’s current Tenth Plan, declared as country’s poverty reduction strategy paper (PRSP), aims at reducing poverty ratio to 30 from 38 per cent in normal case scenario.

Donors led by the World Bank (WB) have commitments to support Nepal’s development efforts based on PRSP. At its 1999 annual meetings, WB revealed that “country-owned” poverty reduction (PR) strategies should form the basis for all WB concessional lending to developing countries. These strategies would take the form of papers called PRSP. In recently concluded Nepal Development Forum (NDF) meetings, this was made clear. Reducing poverty is not simply a matter of raising investment and growth rates. Over past few decades, Nepal achieved good rates of growth and investment, with macroeconomic stability. However, inequalities appear to have increased and most people living in rural areas have not seen improvements in their incomes or living standards. Women and those living in remote areas have fared particularly badly.

Inefficiencies in Nepal’s public institutions and financial markets have been hindering growth, but at the same time, structural problems are also significant. They include uneven development, failures of governance, discrimination and conflict, major obstacles for PR. In NDF meetings, donors expressed Nepal was at a critical juncture in its history and there was a risk that it could become a “failed state.” Their support to Nepal’s PRSP is to avoid this.

In order to address Nepal’s complex poverty problem, the Tenth Plan has indicated several targeted programmes. One of them is creation of Poverty Alleviation Fund (PAF) as an umbrella organisation in order to strengthen targeted programmes. Perhaps it would be relevant at this stage to remember that it was Agricultural Development Bank (ADBN) which started for the first time in Nepal a targeted PR programme called Small Farmers Development programme (SFDP) during mid 1970s. Many donors including Asian Development Bank (ADB) supported SFDP, considered as most successful programme for years. SFDP innovated that group savings, training, credit and later, poor people’s own institution are required for any targeted programme to succeed.

However, on the ground of viability and outreach, SFDP later in its original shape was to have failed to deliver. But ADBN continued and upgraded it to Small Farmers Cooperative Limited (SFCLs) and made further innovations to change life of rural poor, latest being establishment of Small Farmers Development Bank. The new bank is supposed to provide wholesale credit to SFCLs, VDC level financial institutions owned by poor. More than 150 SFCLs have been making tremendous impact in rural Nepal in terms of income level, empowerment, skill and even cost-effectiveness in running anti-poverty programmes. Most targeted programmes are centrally conceived, designed and implemented whereas SFCLs members themselves design, decide and implement programmes. But it is unfortunate that the country’s policymakers are little aware of it. SFCLs are involved in social and financial intermediary functions with the technical support of GTZ. Financial intermediary function is expensive in micro credit. That is why the lending rates of Grameen Banks and other microfinance institutions are high to cover their high operating costs ranging from 10 to 20 per cent of their portfolios. However, SFCLs at the same time are surprisingly running at 2 to 3 per cent.

Donors advocate cost covering lending rates, but give less emphasis to reduction of transaction costs. The Grameen model could not be successful in hills and mountains because it demands big clusters of inhabitants, and at least small trade centres where people buy and sell products for profit. But SFCLs have shown they are appropriate and can sustain even in the hills and mountains. So innovation of SFCLs is important and could be multiplied to all over the country provided that the government understands and supports it. Newly established PAF is expected to support SFCL type of organisations in terms of institutional strengthening and pushing micro social activities including education and health. It is being heard that it has already started to function and implement programmes in six districts by itself. By doing so, it would be hindering multiplication of on going effective programmes and thereby inhibiting outreach. As there is a lack of an apex organisation for monitoring and assessing the performances of targeted programmes, PAF can fill up the vacuum. It is expected to develop, encourage and support institutions dealing with PR activities effectively. It also should have its own training centres for producing skilled and committed manpower. Other functions may include regulation of micro finance institutions, study and research of effectiveness of PR programmes, on the basis of which PAF provides grants and other supports to implementing institutions. Shah is ex-chairman and general manager of ADBN

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Silva shines as Man City thrash Newcastle 5-0

MANCHESTER: David Silva scored one goal and made two more as Manchester City put on a passing masterclass to overwhelm Newcastle United with a 5-0 Premier League victory on Wednesday. Having announced that he will leave the club at the end of this season after a 10-year spell, the 34- Read More...

Salah double keeps Liverpool on track for points record

BRIGHTON: Mohamed Salah scored twice as champions Liverpool moved on to 92 points with a 3-1 win at Brighton and Hove Albion in the Premier League on Wednesday. The victory kept Liverpool on target to secure a record Premier League points tally, with Juergen Klopp's side needing nine from Read More...

Adequate social security key to minimise impact of COVID-19, says PM Oli

KATHMANDU, JULY 8 Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli said protection of the most vulnerable, including migrant workers and those in informal sectors, and provision of adequate social security and health care was the key to minimise the impact of COVID-19. Addressing virtual ‘Global Summit on COVID Read More...

Suarez scores as Barca condemn Espanyol to relegation

Barca beat Espanyol 1-0 in city derby Suarez won the match with his 195th goal for the club Espanyol were relegated after 26 years in La Liga  BARCELONA: Barcelona kept up their pursuit of leaders Real Madrid in the La Liga title race by beating city rivals Espanyol 1-0 at home Read More...

Coronavirus pandemic affects Nepal’s sovereign credit rating process

KATHMANDU, JULY 8 The country’s sovereign rating assessment is likely to be delayed due to the coronavirus pandemic. Though the government had awarded Fitch Ratings, a United States-based international credit rating agency, to study and confirm Nepal’s sovereign credit rating in December l Read More...

Human rights awareness, Human rights education

‘Respect rights of vulnerable people’

KATHMANDU, JULY 8 International partners, civil society and humanitarian organisations have been working together to support the Government of Nepal’s response to the COVID-19 crisis, read a joint press statement issued by United Nations, various embassies and international agencies in Nepal to Read More...

SP-N notifies EC of Giri’s expulsion

KATHMANDU, JULY 8 Samajwadi Party-Nepal today wrote a letter to the Parliament Secretariat stating that it had expelled lawmaker Sarita Giri from the House of Representatives. Assistant Spokesperson for the Parliament Secretariat Dasharath Dahamala said his office would inform Speaker Agni Pra Read More...

Man held for swindling job aspirants of hefty amount

Swindler allegedly offered ‘fake offer letters’ to victims  KATHMANDU, JULY 8 Police have arrested Bijay Pandey, 34, on charge of swindling lakhs of rupees from at least seven persons on the pretext of securing them employment at World Health Organisation’s Nepal office. Pandey, who ha Read More...