Just a week after moderate Mahmoud Abbas easily won an election to replace Yasser Arafat, much of the optimism that accompanied his victory has given way to a familiar sense of intractability in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. While Israelis in the town of Sderot, near the Gaza border, protested Monday after a Hamas rocket attack on Saturday critically wounded a 15-year-old Israeli girl, Palestinians in the Gaza town of Khan Yunis mourned after an Israeli tank shell killed two civilians. And in a reminder of the era of Arafat, leaders of the two sides now have no dialogue after Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon ruled out contact until Abbas cracks down on militant factions.
Beyond that major dispute, analysts say, are fundamentally different visions of the near future. Abbasâ€™s push for a return to the international peace blueprint known as the road map, which calls for a viable Palestinian state alongside a secure Israel, is at loggerheads with Sharonâ€™s focus on unilateral withdrawal from the Gaza Strip. Sharon remains intent on keeping as much of the West Bank as possible and is reluctant, at least for now, to move toward a resumption of negotiations according to the road map, the analysts say. The road map calls on the Palestinian Authority to dismantle â€œterrorist capability and infrastructureâ€ and on Israel to freeze settlement construction.
Sharonâ€™s decision to suspend talks until Abbas moves against the militias, and a subsequent threat of new Army operations, came after a Palestinian attack on the Karni cargo crossing into Gaza left six Israeli civilians dead. Sixteen Palestinians have been killed, including seven civilians, since the Karni attack on Thursday. Sharon envisions two scenarios for the Gaza withdrawal, which faces fierce opposition from Israeli hard-liners, and according to each of them, Israel will not be leaving under assaults such as the Karni attack, says Raanan Gissin, his spokesman. Under the first scenario, Abbas moves against the militant groups and Israel coordinates aspects of the withdrawal with the Palestinian Authority, Gissin says. In the second, under which Israel faces continued attacks, it unleashes the army with unprecedented ferocity. But Palestinian analyst Khader Abu Abarra says that Abbas is in a weak position vis-Ã -vis the militant groups precisely because there is no guarantee of tangible political concessions by Sharon. In the view of Ephraim Inbar, director of the BESA Center for Strategic Studies at Bar Ilan University near Tel Aviv, Sharon does not believe that Abbas will dismantle the armed groups. â€œSharon will have to pay lip service to the road map because Bush pays lip service to it,â€ he says.
In the view of Akiva Eldar, coauthor of â€œLords of the Land,â€ a history of the settlement movement, Sharon has not changed his intention of annexing at least half of the West Bank ever since he outlined it during a cabinet meeting in 1977. By suspending contacts with the Palestinian Authority, Sharon is seeking to undermine Abbasâ€™s standing as a peace partner in the eyes of the world, Eldar says. â€œSharon does not want a partner because he knows what a partner means: giving up the West Bank.â€ â€” The Christian Science Monitor