Nepal | August 05, 2020

Is Facebook really changing? Or just trimming its data haul?

Share Now:

FILE – In this March 26, 2018, file photo, a man poses for photos in front of a computer showing Facebook ad preferences pages in San Francisco. Photo: AP

Lost amid a flurry of Facebook announcements about privacy settings and data access is a much more fundamental question: Is Facebook really changing its relationship with users, or just tinkering around the edges of a deeper problem — its insatiable appetite for the data it uses to sell ads?

CEO Mark Zuckerberg, who is scheduled to testify to Congress on Tuesday and Wednesday, long defined the company’s mission as making the world more open and connected. He’s now tweaking that high-minded goal to emphasise positive community-building, not just connectivity. But it’s not at all clear how much Facebook can shift without undermining what makes it one of the world’s most profitable companies.

“Why is connectivity a good thing? Once you begin to challenge that, you begin to question the business model, which is about mining our data,” said Richard John, a Columbia University professor of business history. Facebook is “extraordinarily reliant on the goodwill of users” who allow it to harvest what they share about themselves, he said — much more so than other tech companies.

Wall Street analysts are already counting on Facebook to survive a user revolt. Based on recent polling, GBH Insights analyst Daniel Ives expects roughly 15 percent of users to disengage somewhat from the social network following revelations that the political data-mining firm Cambridge Analytica improperly obtained personal information from 87 million users to try to influence elections. In a worst-case scenario, decreased engagement and what Ives terms a “negligible” number of deleted accounts could cost the company up to $2 billion in annual advertising, Ives said.

Facebook could likely survive a $2 billion cut in its bottom line. Its shares have rebounded after hitting their lowest price in nine months in late March. Since then, the stock has climbed about 4 percent to $158.61 at midday Monday.

Less clear is how Facebook will handle the threat of increased regulation if Zuckerberg does not adequately resolve lawmakers’ concerns this week.

“Could Facebook still exist even though you have greater privacy protections? That’s the billion-dollar question,” said University of Tennessee law professor Maurice Stucke, who has argued against allowing a handful of tech companies to monopolise everyone’s personal data.

In the days leading up to Zuckerberg’s testimony, Facebook has implemented a series of changes. It took yet another stab at explaining what happens to user data on its service and rejiggered its confusing privacy controls for the seventh time in a decade.

The company also planned to alert users affected by the Cambridge Analytica breach on Monday, although those efforts were delayed, and announced an independent commission that will have access to Facebook data to study the effects of social media on elections and democracy. Last week, it announced new transparency and verification rules for advertisers and page administrators.

Facebook is also restricting the access that outside parties have to data from Facebook users and groups, and it removed an option to search for users by entering a phone number or an email address that it said “malicious actors” had abused to scrape information from nearly all Facebook users.

Researchers generally consider such steps positive, if insufficient. Stucke, for instance, said a much stronger move would be for Facebook to fold US users into the more stringent data protections the European Union will impose on internet companies starting May 25.

Zuckerberg has been unclear about whether Facebook would extend the European protections to the US and elsewhere. He said recently the company will make its “controls and settings the same everywhere, not just in Europe,” although it wasn’t clear exactly what he meant, nor how that would affect data collection and privacy.

Privacy advocates are calling for Facebook to embrace the European rules globally. In an open letter sent Monday to Zuckerberg and lawmakers on both sides of the Atlantic, a group called the Trans Atlantic Consumer Dialogue said the law will offer “protections that all users should be entitled to no matter where they are located.”

Researchers such as Stucke worry that Facebook might be able to wait out the pressure. “There’s a big commotion,” he said. “You hire a lot of lobbyists. You pressure the agencies not to do anything and just ride it out until the next scandal.”

But Jeffrey Chester, executive director for the Centre for Digital Democracy, said it would be a mistake to view Facebook’s current turmoil as a “one-time event.” Thanks to the European rules, he said, “there’s a noose that’s tightening around the necks of the Googles and the Facebooks” that will eventually force changes in their business models.”

Some who favor stricter regulations want Facebook users to be treated like the advertising products that they are and to be paid for what they contribute to the social network. A few scholars say Facebook has so much influence over media and society that the US government should consider taming its dominance by forcing it to spin off Instagram, WhatsApp or other businesses.

“We’re in totally unprecedented waters,” said Lina Khan, a Yale law professor and director of legal policy with the Open Markets Institute. “I wouldn’t be too conservative about what’s realistic.”

Others who find the European model too onerous say most US consumers don’t care if Facebook analyses them and their friends in a way that keeps what they share anonymous.

Such data collection “doesn’t create a lot of harm and can create some significant benefits,” said Joe Kennedy, a fellow at the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, which is backed by the technology industry.

He cited targeted ads as a boon to consumers and said the data behind them can boost artificial intelligence systems, which use vast quantities of data to “learn” human-like behavior.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Nepal COVID-19 Update: 259 new cases, 65 recoveries, one fatality recorded today

KATHMANDU: Nepal’s Health Ministry, in its regular press briefing, shared the latest updates on coronavirus contagion from across the country, and government’s response to the health crisis. As of today, 406,494 tests through Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) method have been carried out, w Read More...

Chief of Butwal's Revenue Investigation Office caught red-handed with bribe money

BHAIRAHAWA: A team deployed from the Commission for Investigation of Abuse of Authority (CIAA) arrested Chief of Revenue Investigation Office, Vijaya Rana red-handed while taking bribe from a service seeker in Butwal, on Tuesday. According to Butwal CIAA Office's Communication Officer Suresh Bhus Read More...

India Coronavirus

Worldwide coronavirus cases cross 18.35 million, death toll at 693,958

LONDON: More than 18.35 million people have been reported to be infected by the novel coronavirus globally and 693,958​ have died, according to a Reuters tally. Infections have been reported in more than 210 countries and territories since the first cases were identified in China in December 20 Read More...

Bihar Chief Minister recommends CBI probe into Sushant Singh Rajput's death

KATHMANDU: The Bihar government has decided to recommend a CBI inquiry into the death of Bollywood star Sushant Singh Rajput, on request from his father KK Singh. According to PTI, Chief Minister Nitish Kumar said that he was informed by the Bihar Director General of Police Gupteshwar Pandey abo Read More...

Sunsari local level to reimpose lockdown following traces of community transmission of COVID-19

DHARAN: Following detection of community transmission of coronavirus-infection, local levels in Sunsari have reimposed lockdown restrictions in a bid to control further spread of the pandemic. District headquarters Inaruwa, Duhabi, Ramdhuni and Itahari Municipalities have taken a decision to this Read More...

Large blast in Beirut port area rocks Lebanon's capital, many people hurt

BEIRUT, Aug 4 (Reuters) - A large explosion rocked Beirut on Tuesday, injuring many people as glass shattered and balconies collapsed from the impact, Reuters witnesses said. Lebanon's state news agency NNA and two security sources said the blast had occurred in the port area where there are wa Read More...

After Nepal, Pakistan unveils new political map; Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh claimed, India retorts

KATHMANDU: On Tuesday, Prime Minister of Pakistan Imran Khan unveiled a new political map of the country including the territories of Jammu & Kashmir and parts of Ladakh. The 'event' unfolded a day ahead of the first anniversary of Indian government's decision to revoke article 370, which gua Read More...