Nepal

A test of statesmanship: Can PM Shah turn a new page in Indo-Nepal relations?

By Col Guru Saday Batabyal (Retd)

Prime Minister Balendra Shah's visit to India on November 22 and 23 comes at a pivotal moment in Nepal's foreign policy. As his first bilateral visit abroad since assuming office, it offers more than diplomatic symbolism. It presents an opportunity to define the strategic direction of a new government and recalibrate Nepal's most consequential external relationship. For decades, occasional exceptions notwithstanding, India has been the traditional first destination of newly-elected Nepali prime ministers, reflecting ties forged by geography, economics and history. The significance of this visit lies not in protocol but in whether a new generation of leaders can move beyond recurring irritants and focus on a shared future. Few relationships in South Asia are as deeply intertwined as that between Nepal and India. Open borders, economic interdependence, cultural affinity and close people-to-people contacts have created a partnership unlike any other in the region. Yet these very strengths have often magnified disagreements. Border disputes, political mistrust and periodic waves of nationalism have too often overshadowed the larger reality that both countries stand to gain far more from cooperation than confrontation. The challenge, thus, is not to rediscover the importance of the relationship but to identify practical areas where mutual interests can be advanced. India moved swiftly to engage Nepal's new government, dispatching Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri to Kathmandu to prepare the ground for Shah's visit. Yet despite its abundant natural resources, Nepal has too often allowed short-term political considerations to eclipse long-term development. The proposed 'Samriddha Nepal, Samunnat Bharat' (Prosperous Nepal, Developed India) vision offers an opportunity to place bilateral ties on a firmer economic foundation. Several agreements and project announcements are expected to feature prominently during the visit. Initiatives in information technology, energy infrastructure and connectivity, including the proposed Amlekhgunj-Chitwan fuel pipeline, may not command dramatic headlines, but they are precisely the kind of projects that generate growth and create shared stakes in stability. Kathmandu is expected to seek over $2 billion in grants and concessional loans from India. Regardless of the eventual scale of support, meaningful assistance could help narrow a reconstruction financing gap estimated at nearly $4.8 billion. For PM Shah, the challenge is to convert this diplomatic momentum into sustained growth and shared prosperity. From earthquakes to floods, India has repeatedly emerged as Nepal's first responder. Geography makes such cooperation inevitable; decades of experience have made it effective. Among the issues likely to dominate Shah's visit, airspace cooperation stands out as it combines economic opportunity with strategic sensitivity. Nepal has long sought expanded access to Indian airspace to improve international operations from Kathmandu and Pokhara airports. Additional entry routes through Mahendranagar, Bhairahawa and Janakpur would reduce operating costs, improve efficiency and strengthen tourism connectivity. For Nepal, this is not merely an aviation issue but an economic necessity tied to growth and competitiveness. India, however, views matter through a broader security lens. Certain proposed flight corridors lie close to sensitive military infrastructure, particularly around the Gorakhpur Air Force base. Such concerns cannot be dismissed lightly. A sustainable solution must balance Nepal's economic requirements with India's security imperatives. Encouragingly, both sides appear willing to search for that balance. India is examining greater flexibility through Bhairahawa route while exploring arrangements involving eastern Nepali airspace and approaches into Bagdogra. If realised, such measures would demonstrate how difficult issues can be managed through accommodation rather than confrontation. The same principle extends beyond aviation. Enduring partnerships are built on reciprocity, trust and recognition of each other's legitimate concerns. Nepal expects India to support its developmental aspirations. India expects Nepal to appreciate its security sensitivities. Neither expectation is unreasonable. A similar rationale underpins the Gorkha recruitment into the Indian Army. The revised Agnipath framework has addressed many of the reservations that initially led Kathmandu to suspend recruitment. Nepal should now move towards reopening the door for the Gorkha enlistment. This is not merely about preserving a historic military tradition; it is about expanding opportunities for Nepal's youth. India can readily meet its recruitment requirements from its own vast manpower pool. The greater beneficiaries of resumed recruitment would be thousands of young Nepalis seeking stable careers and economic mobility. The visit also offers an opportunity to broaden the relationship beyond traditional political and security concerns. Energy cooperation, hydropower exports, connectivity and trade facilitation are expected to feature prominently. Nepal's hydropower potential and India's growing energy demand create a natural basis for deeper partnership. Improved rail and road links, integrated check posts and logistics corridors can likewise generate tangible gains for both A test of statesmanship: Can PM Shah turn a new page in Indo-Nepal relations? the economies. Equally important is investment in people. If Nepal seeks greater cooperation in education, skills development, sports and youth exchange programmes, India should actively consider such initiatives. Investments in young people would generate long-term goodwill and align the partnership with the aspirations of a new generation. India, meanwhile, must recognise that Nepal's political landscape is changing. Even as Shah visits India, a delegation from his Rastriya Swatantra Party is expected to travel to China. Such engagement should not be viewed through a zero-sum prism. Nepal will naturally maintain relations with multiple partners. India's answer should be deeper engagement and greater responsiveness, not strategic anxiety. Ultimately, the success of Shah's visit will not be measured by communiqués or ceremonial photographs. Sensitive issues, including the boundary dispute, will remain and require patient diplomacy. The real measure of success will be whether both the countries create sufficient confidence to manage disagreements while expanding cooperation where interests clearly converge. India remains Nepal's natural partner, a reality no other neighbour can easily substitute. For both the countries, the challenge is no longer merely to manage the relationship but to modernise it. Connectivity, energy, trade, youth development and economic growth must drive the next phase of engagement between the two countries. If this visit advances even a tiny part of that larger agenda, it will have accomplished more than many headline-grabbing diplomatic initiatives. The true test of leadership is not how loudly one invokes history, but how wisely one rises above it. Shah's first visit to India offers precisely such a moment. (The author is a veteran of the 4th Gorkha Rifles of the Indian Army and an analyst on public policy, geopolitics and strategic affairs. The views expressed are personal.)