For most of my life, Chhath meant a break. School and work paused, the house filled with the smell of thekua and the sound of folk songs, and it felt like a holiday. This year I saw it differently. Nothing about the festival changed. I was just paying closer attention, and what I saw bothered me.

Chhath is performed near water, and here that means the riverbank. Everyone gathers there to thank the Sun, and I expected a community united in devotion. Instead, I watched people divided by caste, with different groups assigned different stretches of the bank. The argument over who deserved a larger space grew so heated that it nearly turned into a riot. Hundreds of people had come to worship the same god, and they were ready to fight over whose caste had the better claim to the shore. It was hard to see the irony as anything but tragic. A festival meant to humble us before something greater had become a stage for our smallest instincts.

Then there is the burden on women. Many fast for days without even a sip of water. Alongside the fast, they cook the prasad, often waking at midnight or working through the night, because what is offered to God must be prepared with perfect care. In the society I saw, I did not see a single man helping in any visible way. Maybe I missed something, and I know my own view is limited. But the pattern was too consistent to dismiss. What troubles me most is that these are husbands who, I believe, truly love their wives. How can love coexist with watching someone you care about endure so much hardship and doing nothing to ease it? Devotion that depends on one person's suffering while another stands by is not something I can fully admire.

Underneath all of this sits something I find even harder to understand: the fear of God. I don't claim any deep understanding of the divine. But one thing feels true to me. Whatever God is, I cannot believe it is cruel, and I believe it is forgiving. Yet in the name of fearing God, people are held to impossible standards, children are scolded and pressured, and everyone is made anxious about getting every ritual exactly right. If faith makes people afraid of one another and of themselves, I have to ask what it is really serving.

Finally, there were the stray dogs. They wandered toward the riverbank as they always do, looking for a sip of water or a scrap of food. They were chased away, threatened, even beaten. In a place filled with prayers for blessing and mercy, a hungry animal was treated as a contamination. Compassion that stops at the edge of one's own species, or one's own caste, is not much of a compassion at all.

I don't write this to condemn Chhath. It has real beauty: the discipline, the gratitude toward nature, the sight of lamps and offerings glowing at dusk by the water. Those things are worth keeping. But a tradition stays alive only if people are willing to look at it honestly. If we are truly worshipping something greater than ourselves, it should show in how we treat the people beside us, the women who carry the work, the children who learn from us, and even the animals at the water's edge. That is the Chhath I would want to celebrate.