Nepal | July 09, 2020

Act amendment process snail-paced

• Transitional Justice

Roshan S Nepal
Share Now:
  • Law ministry plans to finalise draft before the start of the winter session of Parliament

Kathmandu, October 25

Although the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs had said it would initiate discussions with stakeholders — including political leadership and victims — on the draft amendment to Transitional Justice Act after Dashain, the process has not moved ahead as expected, thanks to various reasons such as transfer of officials concerned.

Ramesh Dhakal, who had been overseeing the process until he was with the ministry as joint secretary, has now been promoted to secretary and transferred to the Office of the Prime Minister and Council of Ministers a month ago.

Secretary at the law ministry Rajib Gautam said consultations would be expedited once Dhakal’s replacement was named.

“Currently, the process has stalled. Dashain has just concluded, so we will soon expedite consultations,” said Gautam.

The ministry now expects to finalise the draft amendment to Enforced Disappearances Enquiry, Truth and Reconciliation Commission Act 2014 before the start of the winter session of the Parliament which is likely to begin no earlier than January. “We expect the draft to mature before the start of the Parliament session,” he said.

The ministry has been saying that the amendment would be done on the basis of six factors — Comprehensive Peace Accord; Nepal’s national and international obligations related to human rights; fundamental principles of transitional justice; decisions and orders of the Supreme Court; sentiments of conflict victims; and Nepal’s legal and political processes.

The Supreme Court has ordered the government to amend the act in line with international standards.  The apex court has ruled that there should not be amnesty for grave human rights violations such as extra-judicial killing, enforced disappearance, torture, rape and other acts of sexual violence; the statute of limitations for grave offences must be removed; cases recommended by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the Commission of Investigation on Enforced Disappeared Persons must be prosecuted; torture and enforced disappearance must be criminalised through the enactment of laws; cases before court cannot be transferred to the TRC or the CIEDP; dignified and respectable reparation for victims; and reconciliation cannot be made without the consent of victims.

The TRC and the CIEDP, which were formed in February 2015 to investigate conflict-era rights violations, have so far failed to completely investigate even a single case. And one of the major reasons for this failure is lack of necessary legislation, besides crunch of human and financial resources.

Of more than 63,000 complaints filed with the TRC, it has carried out preliminary investigation into just under 3,000 complaints.

As far the CIEDP is concerned, it aims to complete first-phase of detailed investigation into around 1,700 complaints before Tihar festival. Of the 3,197 complaints the CIEDP has received, it has recommended 2,512 complaints for detailed investigation.

The two commissions have said they can function well only if they are ensured act amendment, adequate budget and human resources.

Conflict victims say along with the law formulation, the government should also work to win victims’ trust and ensure their ownership of the transitional justice process. “The state has so far failed to win our trust. The present situation is we are just a weak service seeker,” he said. “The government is only making offers to us without ascertaining what we actually need.”

 


A version of this article appears in print on October 26, 2018 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Making sure our four-legged friends are fed

KATHMANDU The lockdown came into effect in Nepal on March 24 to curb the spread of coronavirus confining people to their homes while schools, offices and businesses shut down. Nobody knew how the situation would unfold and for how long the lockdown would continue. At that moment Founder of Dis Read More...

China, coronavirus

Serious brain disorders in patients with mild Covid-19 symptoms, warn UK neurologists

KATHMANDU: UK neurologists have warned that serious and potentially deadly brain disorder might be triggered among patients with mild Covid-19 symptoms or recovering patients. Publishing the paper in the journal Brain on Wednesday, neurologists said that there was a rise in a life-threatening con Read More...

Rain-triggered flood cuts road section, inundates half-dozen houses in Saptari

RAJBIRAJ: Half a dozen houses have been inundated as rain-triggered flood gushed into a human settlement in Tilathi Koiladi Rural Municipality-3 of Saptari district. The flood has also destroyed paddy planted in approximately 100 bigaha of fields, it has been reported. Two thatched-roof ho Read More...

Trump administration informs United Nations of US withdrawal from WHO

KATHMANDU: Trump administration that has been critical of the World Health Organisation (WHO) over its handling of coronavirus pandemic has formally withdrawn the United States from the UN health body, on Tuesday. The United Nations confirmed that the US would leave WHO on July 6, 2021, following Read More...

China, US trade tit-for-tat visa curbs over Tibet

BEIJING/WASHINGTON:  China said on Wednesday it will impose visa restrictions on US citizens who have engaged in what it called "egregious" behaviour over Tibet, in apparent retaliation against US restrictions on Chinese officials. US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said on Tuesday the United Sta Read More...

Serbian police say 23 held, 60 hurt in clashes

BELGRADE: Serbian police say 23 people have been detained and scores of police officers and demonstrators injured in clashes that erupted over announced return of lockdown measures against the new coronavirus. Police director Vladimir Rebic told the state RTS television that police are working to Read More...

Worldwide coronavirus cases cross 11.89 million, death toll over 543,500

At least 11,891,395 people have been reported to be infected by the novel coronavirus globally and 543,539 have died, a Reuters tally showed. Infections have been reported in more than 210 countries and territories since the first cases were identified in China in December 2019. The Worl Read More...

West Indies must try to win inside four days: Lara

LONDON: Batting great Brian Lara has said West Indies' best chance of victory against England is to race out to an early lead and secure the win inside five days. All-rounder Jason Holder is part of the tourists' impressive bowling attack but questions remain about their batting ahead of the Read More...