Nepal | May 30, 2020

All climbers don’t stand atop Mt Manaslu while ‘successfully’ summitting it

Rajan Pokhrel
Share Now:

KATHMANDU: There a general understanding that the climbers should have reached the main summit point — the prescribed altitude of respective mountain — to qualify as successful summiteers. Mt Manaslu (8,163 m) which lies in western Nepal, however, has been a different case.

Most of the climbers who claimed victory over the world’s eighth highest peak avoided the main summit point in the autumn climbing season, according to some climbers and their support staff.

Expedition organisers claimed that over 150 climbers, including foreigners and Sherpas, stood atop the peak on September 30 and October 1 as the mountain witnessed a fair weather.

“Interestingly, there were three points with different altitudes to summit the mountain,” a climber shared. According to him, 90 per cent of the climbers, however, did not stand atop the main summit point.

According to Mingma Sherpa, Managing Director at Seven Summit Treks, it is a general practice on Mt Manaslu that climbers have different three options to make summit. “Main summit point at the altitude of 8,163 metres is quite tiny and it can accommodate only two person at a time,” he said.

It was quite impossible for all climbers to make it the main point as they found a very short-window to make a summit, he further explained.

Climbers also agreed that the two summit places situated some five to 10 metres below the main summit point.

“It’s not a serious issue,” Sherpa added.

Ang Tshering Sherpa, the President of Nepal Mountaineering Association, however, blamed the inexperienced rope-fixing team for causing such a mess in the mountain. “The team had not only delayed the rope-fixing work but also failed to place the ropes up to the main summit point,” he claimed.

Mingma, a record climber, however, was not ready to buy the NMA boss’ claims. “The practice to make summit in two more points than the main summit has been continued since early days,” he said, adding that it’s a tradition followed by all climbers even since or before Italian legendary climber Reinhold Messner made it to the top of the peak.

Expedition Operators Association of Nepal had mandated the Seven Summit Treks to fix ropes to the climbing route up to the summit on Mt Manaslu this year.

The Department of Tourism said that it had only issued certificates to an expedition team which returned from Mt Manaslu till date.  It was a difficult task for DoT to verify the claims of climbers whether they made it to the height of 8,163 m, according to an official.

“The liaison officer of the respective group should recommend for certificates saying he/she stayed at the base camp throughout the climbing period while the team also needs to submit summit photo to get a summit certificate,” the official said.

Asthmatic Canadian claims summit without O2
Christopher Manning, a Canadian mountaineer who suffers from asthma patient, said that he along with his climbing partner successfully climbed Mt Manaslu without artificial oxygen in the autumn season.

Sharing his experience with THT Online, the alpinist said that he and Amy McMillin from Seattle of the US successfully submitted the peak without climbing Sherpas and supplemental oxygen.

“I might be the first with asthma to climb the world’s eighth highest peak without oxygen,” he said, “The summit point itself was a ‘nightmare’ as it’s very, very small.”

According to him, his dream was to climb many of the 8000m peaks and Mt Manaslu was the perfect start, with it being in Nepal and a relatively easy objective.

He observed that the government has to enforce cleanliness in mountains, recalling that there was no one on the mountain to enforce the rule of garbage deposit.

“I’m not overly impressed with our liaison officer who showed up for one day and it’s a joke and frustrating,” he commented.

Theft is also an issue where we had a cache, two shovels and a rope stolen in two separate incidents, he added. “Amy and I did acclimatise and tried to set up higher camps. But our Camp I cache was stolen so, we ended up hauling everything up the mountain in a single push for the summit.”

“The actual climb is quite straightforward and with seemingly limited danger in only a few spots,” he said, “I’m not surprised the death rate has dropped so much over the years and safe camp placement at Camp III and the route between Camp II-III needs to be thought out.”

The climber who also runs Summit8000 along with Bangaluru mountaineer Satyarup Siddhanta said they would return to Mt Everest, Mt Cho Oyu, Mt Shishapangma and Mt Manslu next year. “As I’m planning on Mt Everest without oxygen, I will certainly be the first asthmatic to climb without oxygen and support staff if successful.”

Mt Amadablam overcrowded

More than 200 climbers representing 18 teams have already left for Khumbu region to attempt to climb Mt Amadablam (6,812 m).

According to Gyanendra Shrestha, an official at the Department of Tourism under the Ministry of Culture, Tourism and Civil Aviation, Mt Amadablam topped the autumn chart receiving over 200 foreign climbers in the autumn season.

“Most of the world climbers have already reached the base camp to acclimatiSe while the DoT issues a 45-day permit to each expedition in the season.”

Meanwhile, climbers have claimed that rope-fixing work was being delayed due to lack of sufficient number of trained Sherpas.

“We found only two Sherpas at Camp II to fix the ropes,” Nima Gyalzen Sherpa who was at Camp II with his team shared.

Iswari Poudel, Managing Director at Himalayan Guides said that the team would fix the ropes up to the summit within the next three days.

“The delay was caused by bad weather as there were six more Sherpas to fix the ropes,” he claimed. EOAN has assigned HG to fix ropes on Mt Amadablam this season.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Are we doing enough for the mental health of healthcare workers?

The number of coronavirus patients has been increasing over the past few days in Nepal. In the current scenario, it seems like the numbers would further increase in the coming days. Given that healthcare workers and frontline staff are the first responders to manage the ongoing pandemic with limited Read More...

With a gay protagonist, Pixar short ‘Out’ makes history

NEW YORK: In Steven Clay Hunter’s 23 years as an animator at Pixar, he has drawn a seven-armed octopus, a Canadian daredevil and a wheezing toy penguin. But there were scenes he never expected to animate until he began working on his short, “Out.” Hunter wrote and directed the nine-minute Pi Read More...

Govt aims to make Nepal self-reliant in milk, meat

KATHMANDU, MAY 28 The government has targeted to make the country self-reliant in milk, meat and vegetables in the upcoming fiscal year. Unveiling the federal budget for the next fiscal year, Finance Minister Yubaraj Khatiwada said that the budget for fiscal 2020-21 will be more focused on inc Read More...

Heavy discount on income tax for small businesses

KATHMANDU, MAY 28 Announcing the federal budget for fiscal year 2020-21, Finance Minister Yubaraj Khatiwada has offered heavy income tax exemption to small and cottage industrialists. The government has exempted income tax of up to 75 per cent for businesses with annual transactions of up to R Read More...

In Pictures: Sithi Nakha in Lalitpur

People clean the traditional stone taps and pond to mark the "Sithi Nakha" festival, in Lalitpur, on Thursday, May 28, 2020. The Newar community celebrate Sithi Nakha to mark the beginning of monsoon season by cleaning water sources such as ponds, wells, and stone spouts. Photo: Naresh Shrestha/ Read More...


Three dengue patients identified in Tanahun

TANAHUN: As many as three patients of dengue have been identified at GP Koirala National Centre For Respiratory Diseases in Shuklagandaki Municipality, Tanahun. According to Chief of the Centre, Dr Ram Kumar Shrestha, two of the three patients are receiving treatment there while the third patient Read More...

 Hong Kong govt warns removing US special status is 'double-edged sword'

Hong Kong tells Washington to stay out of its affairs Trump expected to make China announcement later Friday China security ministry to "guide" Hong Kong police HONG KONG: Hong Kong told the United States to keep out of the internal debate over new national security laws being imposed b Read More...

Worldwide coronavirus cases cross 5.82 million, death toll tops 359,000

More than 5.82 million people have been reported infected with the novel coronavirus globally and 359,389 have died, a Reuters tally shows. Infections have been reported in more than 210 countries and territories since the first cases were identified in China in December 2019. New York Mayor B Read More...