Nepal | September 26, 2020

Three Indian climbers make fake Everest summit claim?

Rajan Pokhrel
Share Now:

KATHMANDU: Three Indian climbers, who claimed that they made it to the roof of the world on May 26, had not even reached Camp IV on Mt Everest this spring season, THT investigation has revealed.

The revelation comes at a time when local media outlets and communities in the northern Indian state of Haryana celebrated their so-called triumph of Mt Everest immediately after three climbers including two women returned to their home country last week.

Officials as well as the eyewitnesses shared that Indian climbers including Vikas Rana from Sudkain Khurd village of Jind district, Shobha Banwala, a resident of Karora in Kaithal district, and Ankush Kasana from Lalpura of Hisar district in Haryana had only reached Camp III before abandoning their summit pushes on May 26.

The climbers made fake claims as they had not even been to the South Col this spring season, which ran from March to May, Managing Director at Prestige Adventures Pvt Ltd, Damber Parajuli said. The climbers were part of an eight-member expedition run by Prestige Adventures.

“We met them at the base camp at around 12:30 pm on May 26, the day when Haryana climbers claimed to have summitted Mt Everest,” Chhiring Sherpa, a high-altitude climber, said, adding that it was highly unlikely to descend from the summit point to the base camp within a couple of hours.

Talking to this daily, the trio, however claimed that they reached the summit point at around 10:30 am. “We made it to the summit of Mt Everest after finding a fair weather on May 26; four Sherpa climbers guided us to the top of the world,” Kasana, 29, told THT.

The Department of Tourism was expected to issue our summit certificates in the next two weeks, Banwala, 21, said, adding that they along with four Sherpa guides were the only climbers who made it to the top of Mt Everest on May 26. When asked about the names of Sherpas, who accompanied them to the top, the climbers refused to share. “We don’t know their names,” Banwala said. They also declined to share their summit photos.

Ngima Norbu Sherpa who guided Vikas Rana to Camp III said that he along with other Sherpa climbers descended to the base camp on May 25. “We have no idea about their summit attempt,” he said, adding that the climbing guides decided to descend after Indian climbers couldn’t move above Camp III.

Prestige Adventures took four Indian climbers including Mohini Nehra of Haryana from Makalu Extreme Treks to share their climbing permit, Parajuli said. “Mohini was rescued from Camp II while their team leader Ricardo Dario Birn from Argentina also failed to head towards the summit due to illness,” he added. Megha Parmar was the only member of the Birn-led eight-member expedition who reached the Everest summit on May 22, Parajuli, who is also the president of Expedition Operators Association of Nepal, said.

Oxana Morneava, who runs Makalu Extreme Treks along with her Nepali partner Dorchi Sherpa, said that they had already reached Haryana to celebrate the victory of their clients. “We don’t know the details but the trio claimed that they made it to the top on May 26,” the Russian woman climber, said.

Interestingly, the DoT had already conducted debriefing for the Birn-led expedition, accepting the summit claims made by the Indian climbers. The expedition’s liaison officer Bishwa Bandhu Regmi, who stayed at the Everest base camp for only two days in mid-May, also authenticated the climbers’ claim while submitting his team’s report to DoT. When asked about the status of the climbers of Birn-led expedition, Regmi said he had no idea about the summit details. Base camp officials also confirmed that no summits were made on May 26.

As Birn was evacuated from Camp III, another Indian climber Ratnesh Pandey had been authorised to conduct debriefing on behalf of the team leader, Parajuli said. DoT record shows that Pandey had also approved the climbers’ fake summit claim while submitting his report to DoT.

DoT’s Director Meera Acharya confirmed that the team had already conducted its debriefing to conclude the expedition. “As per the debriefing report, three climbers – Vikas, Shobha and Ankush – had reached the Everest summit on May 26,” she said.

According to her, Megha Parmar had already received her certificate presenting a summit photo to DoT while other climbers have not applied for the certificates till date. Each year, the DoT updates its list of Everest summiteers on the basis of debriefing reports.

Earlier, Indian police constables Dinesh Rathod and his wife, Tarakeshwari, had been sacked from the force for faking Mt Everest climb in 2017. The couple had also been banned from climbing in Nepal for ten years.

This season, at least 381 expedition members representing 44 teams had obtained climbing permit to attempt to scale Mt Everest, according to Acharya.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

COVID-19 pushes more children into poverty

KATHMANDU, SEPTEMBER 24 The number of children living in multi-dimensional poverty has soared to approximately 1.2 billion due to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, according to a new analysis published by UNICEF and Save the Children today. This is a 15 per cent increase in the number of ch Read More...

One buried to death, five missing in landslides

BHAIRAHAWA, SEPTEMBER 24 One person died and five others went missing in landslides at different places in Palpa this morning. In Surangdanda, ward 2 of Rambha Rural Municipality, Motisara Gaha, 27, died when a landslide buried his home. Similarly, in Phoksingkot of the same ward, five persons Read More...

In-person classes start in Sudurpaschim

DHANGADI, SEPTEMBER 24 Schools, which had remained shut for long due to the coronavirus pandemic, have started in-person classes in different districts of Sudurpaschim Province. The schools were closed for the last six months after the government imposed nationwide lockdown to stop the virus s Read More...

SAARC Council of Ministers holds virtual meeting

KATHMANDU, SEPTEMBER 24 Minister of Foreign Affairs Pradeep Kumar Gyawali urged member states of South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation to explore all viable options to hold the 19th SAARC Summit. Delivering his opening remarks at an informal meeting of the SAARC Council of Ministers Read More...

Panel recommends effective handling of COVID crisis

KATHMANDU, SEPTEMBER 24 The Parliamentary Sub-committee of Education and Health Committee of the House of Representatives has recommended the Government of Nepal to provide a report of real time polymerase chain reaction tests to the concerned persons without delay. The authorities concerned u Read More...

NMA Birgunj chapter asks doctors to wear black bands at work

BIRGUNJ, SEPTEMBER 24 Nepal Medical Association Narayani chapter Birgunj has protested the mistreatment of agitating Dr Govinda KC, who had started his 19th hunger strike demanding quality health service and medical education. NMA Narayani chapter also asked doctors to sport black bands at Read More...

Sindhupalchowk, a crisis-hit region

DHULIKHEL, SEPTEMBER 24 Battered by a series of natural disasters in the past three months that caused huge loss to life and property, Sindhupalchowk has been declared a crisis-hit region. The government announced this today. Alongside Sindhupalchowk, Baglung is also declared a crisis-hit regi Read More...

One dead, six hurt as landslide sweeps bus in Daunne

KAWASOTI:  A person died while six others sustained injures after the passenger bus they were travelling on was swept by a landslide at Daunne in Nawalpur on Thursday night. The deceased has been identified as Harish Chandra KC of Aathbiskot Rural Municipality-10 in Rukum West, informed Deputy Read More...