Nepal | January 18, 2021

EDITORIAL: Undemocratic move

The Himalayan Times
Share Now:

If the lawmakers are barred from putting questions to the PM, it will undermine the parliamentary supremacy

In parliamentary democracy, the Parliament is the supreme body elected by the people. The constitution has clearly defined the roles and responsibilities of the three organs of the state – legislature, executive and judiciary – all of which function independently. As the chief of the executive body, the Prime Minister is accountable to the Parliament. A government is formed by the majority vote of the Parliament. Therefore, the Prime Minister and his council of ministers have to take informed consent of the sovereign body on every decision they take. The government runs its administration and executes its decisions based on the laws enacted by the federal Parliament. That is why the PM and his/her ministers are directly accountable to the legislature. This ensures checks and balances in a democratic system.

However, this did not happen on Sunday when PM KP Sharma Oli addressed the House of Representatives for the first time after the winter session of the federal Parliament commenced on December 26. He was giving a written speech on the issues of “public importance”, highlighting the “achievements” his administration had made over the last nine months in office. During his hour-long speech, the PM claimed that the country was moving towards a higher growth trajectory, that corruption was under control, that the law and order situation was improving, and that a number of development projects were being executed as per schedule. He also painted a rosy picture of the country’s economy, which, according to Finance Minister Yubaraj Khatiwada, had been in “tatters” when Oli took office nine months ago.

The lawmakers from the opposition bench had lent their ear patiently until he finished his speech. Once the PM left the rostrum, the main opposition Nepali Congress sought explanation on a number of issues from the PM, who refused to take questions from the opposition lawmakers. Speaker Krishna Bahadur Mahara did not allow them to ask questions on the PM’s speech, which, they said, were full of factual errors regarding the country’s economy, thus misleading the general public. The PM’s statement failed to satisfy the opposition lawmakers, creating a ruckus in the Lower House. First, the Speaker refused to allow the lawmakers to ask questions to the PM. When the lawmakers started shouting, he relented, and allowed only five lawmakers to raise questions with the PM. Opposition lawmakers said it was an insult to the lawmakers, who, they said, had every right to ask questions to the PM on his speech of public importance. After the main opposition gheraoed the well, the Speaker adjourned the meeting for 15 minutes, only to put it off till Wednesday. It all seems that the PM wanted to have his version heard while shunning criticism from the opposition. In this case, Mahara did not play an impartial role as Speaker. When the Business Advisory Committee meeting was held, the Speaker was against the lawmakers raising questions over the PM’s speech. It is an undemocratic move to bar the lawmakers from raising questions with the PM. If the lawmakers are barred from putting questions to the PM it will undermine parliamentary supremacy. The PM should be accountable to the sovereign Parliament.

Garbage disposal

The decision of the Ministry of Urban Development to prepare a blueprint to build the necessary infrastructure for a landfill site at Banchare Danda is long overdue, given that the Sisdole landfill site at Okharpauwa is already up to its neck with garbage. The key to lengthening the lifespan of a landfill site is to recycle as much waste as possible. Since 80 percent of the waste generated in the Valley can be recycled, only 20 per cent will land up at Banchare Danda that spreads over 792 ropanis of land. The $50 million Integrated Solid Waste Management Project is, thus, expected to solve Kathmandu Valley’s refuse disposal needs for the next 50 years.

Attractive as the scheme may sound, small irritants should not be allowed to obstruct the project. The Kathmandu Metropolitan City has 1,100 staff working in its waste management sector and about 150 trucks and other equipment. The KMC has demanded that the new project take over their management. Since the project is to be developed under the private-public partnership model, its success could very well be worth emulating for other municipalities.


A version of this article appears in print on January 08, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Price of precious metals fall

KATHMANDU, JANUARY 16 The price action of precious metals in the trading week of January 10 to 15 suggests investor indecision and impending volatility in the international markets. According to the rate list of the Federation of Nepal Gold and Silver Dealers’ Association (FeNeGoSiDA), gold Read More...

Sherpa, Acharya take lead

KATHMANDU, JANUARY 16 Pemba Sherpa and Sadbhav Acharya took lead after the first day of the Indian Ambassador’s Invitational Golf Tournament here at the Gokarna Golf Club today. Played under stabelford 3/4 handicap format, the seven-handicap amateur golfer Sherpa earned 39 points to stay Read More...

Tikapur carnage convict says he will revolt for justice

DHANGADI, JANUARY 16 Laxman Tharu, who has been sentenced to life imprisonment for his role in the Tikapur carnage by the High Court, said he would start a revolt for justice. Tharu, who had been underground following the High Court’s verdict, informed about his preparations to take up a Read More...

Over 2,000 absconding convicts nabbed

KATHMANDU, JANUARY 16 Nepal Police said it arrested a total of 2,332 persons absconding after being convicted for various crimes from different parts of the country in fiscal 2019-20. Nepal Police claimed jail sentence of 1,378 years along with around Rs 380 million in fine from them. The numb Read More...

Nepse crosses new milestones

KATHMANDU, JANUARY 16 The country’s sole secondary market sailed past new milestones in the trading period between January 10 and 14, with Nepal Stock Exchange (Nepse) index advancing by 4.19 per cent or 92.05 points weekon-week to settle at a new high. The share market continues to be a Read More...

Britain invites G7 leaders to Cornish resort for June summit

LONDON: Britain announced plans to hold the first in-person meeting of the G7 for nearly two years in June, inviting the leaders of major developed economies to a picturesque seaside village to discuss rebuilding from the pandemic and climate change. Prime Minister Boris Johnson says he wants to us Read More...

Facebook to ban ads promoting weapon accessories, protective gear in US

Facebook Inc said on Saturday it will ban advertisements for weapon accessories and protective equipment in the United States with immediate effect until at least two days after U.S. President-elect Joe Biden’s inauguration on Jan. 20. Following the attack by supporters of President Donald Trump Read More...

Betty White marks 99th birthday Sunday; up late as she wants

LOS ANGELES:  True to form, Betty White has something impish to say about her birthday Sunday. “Since I am turning 99, I can stay up as late as I want without asking permission!” she told The Associated Press in an email. White's low-key plans include feeding a pair of ducks that regularl Read More...