Nepal | September 30, 2020

Efficient capital market: Its mechanism

Roshan Luitel
Share Now:

What most investors normally do is hold on to their investment for as long as they can, and after they off-load it, never look back at it again. This mentality stems from the fact that people get emotionally tied up with the security they own

Illustration: Ratna Sagar Shrestha/THT

Apart from analyzing change in profits and a few financial ratios viz. earnings per share (EPS), price to earnings ratio (P/E), and Net Worth, a typical Nepali stock market investor would not choose to go any further before making his investment decision.

I have been an active investor myself and have closely looked into the mechanism of Nepali capital market. The catalysts that trigger a buy/sell decision, according to a research by Bharat Singh Thapa who studied the investment behavior of Nepali investors, are based mostly on recommendations and rumors.

The research showed that the percentage of retail investors whose investment decisions are based on such factors represent a staggering forty-five and a few basis points.

This number, as alarming as it sounds, is not surprising. For a market that is defined as ‘Inefficient’ in financial terms, maybe the above mentioned factors are the only ones that are needed to make a rational investment decision.

Markets like Nepal where psychology is the predominant driver of stock market swings, fundamental and technical analysis are yet to establish their strong foot-hold.

When people talk about Nepali capital market as being inefficient, it shouldn’t be assumed that virtually every investor in a well-developed, efficient market has the intellectual prowess to pick the best of the financial securities available.

It’s actually the asset managers, investment bankers and other financial institutions that try to act rationally, based on their analysis, to bring a financial security to its equilibrium point.

Alpha is a term that usually does not a standing place in Nepali investment community. Alpha is a regression coefficient, or typically knows as a Jensen’s alpha, that, according to Investopedia, is a risk adjusted performance measure to analyze the performance of a portfolio based on a certain risk level, typically reflected by beta.

Looking just at the return without giving much attention to the risk level is what gets people into trouble because they are allured by the high return prospect but fail to assess the risk level of a security. Alpha, if positive, compensates for the risk level indicated by beta and should be a better alternative from a portfolio that has a negative alpha.

Going back to Nepse, how often do we notice a company with negative earning records surpass a comparable company with positive EPS and good cash flow? How much of the future expectation is discounted and how much into the future a typical investor looks into before making a buy or sell decision?

An intrinsic value for a stock is a mix of adjusted historical records, and discounted future expectations but, this method of calculating a probable intrinsic value has yet to become mainstream in Nepali capital market.

An investor needs to hone the ability of controlling his emotions and should be able to take multiple positions for a same security. This is a strategic maneuver that might sound simple to undertake but is actually very difficult to execute.

Someone who bought Chilime at Nrs1000 and sold it at Nrs2000 and took the position again at Nrs1100 is a rational and prudent investor. What most investors normally do is hold on to their investment for as long as they can, and after they off-load it, never look back at it again.

This mentality stems from the fact that people get emotionally tied up with the security they own and falsely believe that the stock is always undervalued and therefore, refrain from selling it. The ability to trade the same security more than once tells that emotion did not play a dominant role, rather rationality did.

What about the timing of investments? What is the right time to enter the market? Or should you take a plunge with as little information as possible which would, quite naturally, increase the risk threshold? The same research by Bharat Singh Thapa indicates that around forty one percentage of retail investors base their investment decisions on “Media Stories’.

This is a single factor that had the highest weight among all other factors that determined the investment decision for a Nepali Investor.

If people are looking at news and waiting for big chunks of information before they invest, the train will leave the platform meaning the prices would have already adjusted the information from the news and they will be forced to buy the security at inflated prices.

Thus, one needs to be able to act with as little information as possible by gauging the probabilities of the best, base, and worst case scenarios. It is said “If you can act on the mere twenty percent information and the probability statistics that you have, you’ll end up buying ‘gold’.”

The move from inefficiency towards efficiency is not a sprint but a marathon. Overall financial system and infrastructures need to be gradually updated to move towards a more efficient state.

The economy, financial institutions and investors need to move in a tandem in order to create a strong and sustainable market. While that happens, what retail investors need to do is to prepare themselves for the next generation of financial markets that will have plethora of products and services.

It is imperative for Nepali Stock market investors to update their investing skills, build financial acumen, leverage the benefits of a small capital market, and develop skills to hedge against systematic risks.


A version of this article appears in print on May 09, 2017 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Diogo Jota

Liverpool maintain 100% start with win over Arsenal

LIVERPOOL: Premier League champions Liverpool maintained their 100% start to the season with a 3-1 win against Arsenal at Anfield on Monday leaving them level on nine points with pacesetters Everton and Leicester City. The visitors took the lead through an Alexandre Lacazette strike but L Read More...

Fulham, Aston Villa, Ivan Cavaleiro, Matty Cash

Villa beat Fulham 3-0 to move into top four

LONDON: Aston Villa moved into the Premier League top four after they strolled to a 3-0 win at Fulham thanks to goals from Jack Grealish, Conor Hourihane and Tyrone Mings in a lopsided contest on Monday. The result left Villa, who narrowly avoided relegation last season, fourth on a maximu Read More...

Private hospitals, labs to charge Rs 3,899 for PCR test

KATHMANDU, SEPTEMBER 28 Private hospitals have fixed their own rate for conducting polymerase chain reaction tests, saying that the fee allocated by the Ministry of Health and Population was too less. Eight private hospitals and labs, including HAMS Hospital, Star Hospital, B&B Hospital an Read More...

President issues ordinances on acid attack punishment, acid sale regulation

KATHMANDU, SEPTEMBER 28 President Bidhya Devi Bhandari today issued two ordinances to increase jail sentence for acid attackers and to regulate the sale and distribution of acid and other harmful chemicals. One of the ordinances amended the new penal code, proposing to increase jail term for a Read More...

Editorial: Unemployment problem cannot be addressed unless all levels of govt work together to create jobs within the country

The unemployment problem cannot be addressed unless all levels of govt work together to create jobs within the country Unemployment is a big problem in Nepal. That is why youths in large numbers migrate to other countries, mostly India, the Middle East, Malaysia, South Korea and Japan, where they e Read More...

Ayurvedic literature: Delving into its history

The travelogue of Chinese pilgrim Faxian was the earliest testimony to describe the healthcare system in ancient South Asia. It is close to the description by the earliest Ayurvedic compendium, Charaka Samhita Ayurveda has become a buzzword in the contemporary setting of medicine in the era of COVI Read More...

Six student leaders arrested for staging protest outside Chinese Embassy in Kathmandu

KATHMANDU, SEPTEMBER 28 Six student leaders of Nepal Student Union, the student wing of major opposition Nepali Congress, were arrested today for staging a protest outside the Chinese Embassy at Baluwatar against the alleged border encroachment by the Chinese side in Humla district. The NSU le Read More...

Woman found dead in Saptari district

A police team has been deployed from Province Police Office, Janakpur, to investigate the case RAJBIRAJ, SEPTEMBER 28 A 50-year-old woman was found dead at Mayanakaderi village, Ward No 2 of Tirhut Rural Municipality, Saptari, yesterday. The body of Dayaman Devi, wife of local Shiv Narayan, w Read More...