Nepal | September 24, 2020

Pesticide suicides: Let’s prevent them

Leah Utyasheva
Share Now:

According to the WHO, at least 20 per cent of pesticide suicides could be prevented through restricting access to poisons. Restrictions on highly hazardous pesticides will prevent suicides and save thousands of Nepali lives

Illustration: Ratna Sagar Shrestha/THT

Pesticide self-poisoning is the second most common method of suicide in Nepal. Globally, out of 800,000 individuals who die from suicide each year, about 15-20 per cent die from pesticide self-poisoning. Most suicides due to pesticide ingestion happen in agricultural communities around the globe, where—as in Nepal—small-holder farming is an important source of income. Statistics on suicide are notoriously unreliable and prone to underestimation. In Nepal, the under-reporting is happening due to stigma, fear of negative consequences on the part of families, and perceived illegality of suicide attempts.

Available data for Nepal show suicide rate considerably higher than the global average—in 2012, it was 24.9 per 100,000 population compared to the global average of 11.4 per 100,000 population. Generally, the WHO estimates that its South- East Asia Region accounts for 39 per cent of global suicides, but only 26 per cent of the global population.

Pesticide suicides are usually impulsive decisions that happen at the moment of crisis, with people thinking about killing themselves for less than 10 minutes. Most people who engage in suicidal behaviour do not want to die; rather suicide serves as a response to psychosocial stressors. If a person is prevented from using a highly lethal method, s/he may use a method with lower lethality, thereby increasing the chance of survival, or the suicidal impulse may pass. Surviving a suicidal period usually allows the person to find support from family, community, and medical/ psychological services or another way to deal with the stress. Evidence from other countries suggests that removing highly toxic substances from the market significantly reduces suicide rates by giving people more time to think about their decision.

According to the WHO, at least 20 per cent of pesticide suicides could be prevented through restricting access to poisons. This approach to suicide prevention is called means restriction. In view of the WHO, this is one of the most effective methods of suicide prevention. The means restriction approach suggests that if there is no easy access to the means for suicide, more people with no longstanding desire to die will survive their crisis and find solutions to their problems.

Means restriction has proven to be highly effective in the reduction of suicide in the UK after the domestic gas supply was made less toxic. Barrier installation on bridges and railway platforms to prevent jumping in front of trains also showed to be successful in Hong Kong and other countries.

Implementing legislation to limit the use of highly hazardous pesticides (HHPs) in agriculture has been a highly successful approach to suicide reduction, reducing the overall suicide numbers in countries where small-scale farming is common, such as Sri Lanka. In Sri Lanka, banning certain HHPs has led to major reductions in case-fatality for pesticide poisoning and suicides, resulting in a 70 per cent reduction in the suicide rate over 20 years.

In Nepal, as in other agricultural societies, where small-holder farmers use highly toxic substances to increase farm productivity, the wide availability of highly toxic pesticides makes them an easy option to be used for poisoning at the moment of crises.

In comparison with high-income countries, where agricultural strength toxins are only available to licensed workers, in low income countries, strong pesticides are freely sold in shops and are frequently stored at home. Unlike low toxicity substances commonly used for poisoning in the West many of these pesticides are highly lethal if ingested. This means that fatality of self-poisoning is much higher in agricultural communities such as Nepal than in other countries.

Restricting access to the means of suicide (ie banning and removing HHPs from agricultural practice through legislation and importation limitations, and otherwise reducing availability) is the most effective way to prevent deaths due to pesticide self-poisoning. This is especially true where the intent is low, and pesticide poisoning a common means of suicide. Implementing legislation to limit the use of HHPs in agriculture has been a highly successful approach to suicide reduction, reducing overall suicide numbers in countries where small-scale farming is common.

To facilitate a means restriction approach to suicide prevention in Nepal, a two-year research project has begun to identify which HHPs are most commonly used for suicide, and to implement a stricter regulation to them. The research is conducted by the Centre for Pesticide Suicide Prevention (CPSP)—an initiative of the University of Edinburgh in partnership with the Nepal Public Health Foundation with ethical approval of the
Nepal Health Research Council. At present 10 hospitals across Nepal are involved, with a further three hospitals about to be included. Researchers collect anonymized data from hospital records about pesticide poisoned patients to find out chemical compounds that are involved in poisoning.

This research initiative opens up an opportunity for the Government of Nepal to make a significant contribution to national suicide prevention, supporting the government’s target to reduce the national suicide rate by 2020.

Utyasheva is policy director of Centre for Pesticide Suicide Prevention at University of Edinburgh

A version of this article appears in print on September 10, 2018 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

As US surpasses 200,000 COVID-19 deaths, Wisconsin sounds alarm over surges in cases

NEW YORK: Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers on Tuesday declared a new public health emergency and extended a face mask mandate into November to fight a coronavirus flareup in his state, as the number of people who have died across the United States since the pandemic began passed 200,000. In-pers Read More...

Govt urged to implement apex court’s order on jailbirds

SC order aims to avoid crowds in prisons KATHMANDU, SEPTEMBER 22 The National Human Rights Commission has urged the government to implement provisions stipulated in the Criminal Offences (Determination and Execution of Sentence) Act-2017, for improvement of prison conditions. The NHRC made th Read More...

Code of conduct vital in journalism: Prez

KATHMANDU, SEPTEMBER 22 President Bidhya Devi Bhandari has called for journalists to fully abide by the code of conduct for consolidation of democracy. Addressing the 51st anniversary of the Press Council Nepal in Shital Niwas here today, the head of the state underscored the need of compl Read More...

Probe into prisoner’s death sought

KATHMANDU, SEPTEMBER 22 Kin of a prisoner, who allegedly died of COVID-19 while undergoing treatment at Bir Hospital, have demanded investigation into the death. Ram Lakhan Jaiwal, 63, of Siddhartha Municipality-5, Rupandehi died at the hospital on Saturday. He had been serving sentence in the Read More...

Attempts to dismiss rape exposed, ward chair chased off

BARA, SEPTEMBER 22 There are reports of attempts to cover up a rape incident in Subarna Rural Municipality, Bara. What is worse, an elected local representative is learnt to have been involved in such attempts. On Friday evening, a 12-year-old girl was raped in Auraiya in Subarna Rural Municip Read More...

Schools in Byas moot possibility of physical classes

DAMAULI, SEPTEMBER 22 Byas Municipality today held a meeting with head teachers and principals of community and private schools to find a way for reopening schools that have been shut for a long time due to COVID-19. The municipality held a meeting to discuss the possibility of opening sch Read More...

126 lost lives in Gandaki landslides, floods this monsoon

POKHARA, SEPTEMBER 22 As many as 126 people lost their lives to natural disasters such as floods and landslides in Gandaki Province this monsoon. Gandaki Province Minister of Internal Affairs and Law Hari Bahadur Chuman said that most of the casualties happened in Myagdi and Baglung districts. Read More...

Probe panel recommends action against three cops

DHANGADI, SEPTEMBER 22 A probe committee formed to investigate the death of Amar Bahadur Chand, who died in Kailali Police Custody, has recommended action against three police personnel. Chand had died in the toilet of Bahuliya Border Police Post on August 12. The probe committee led by SP Raj Read More...