Copenhagen to Antalya: Nepal keeps making the case. Who is making it work?

At 8:37 on the morning of August 26,2026, the north face of Langtang Lirung let go. Rock and glacier ice plunged 1,400 meters into the Lhende Khola, and seven minutes later a wall of water and debris moving at 188 kilometers an hour tore through the border below. There was no warning. Families in 38 countries learned by phone call, or by silence, that the Himalayas had swallowed someone they loved. No standing ovation in Dubai had built the siren they needed. That is what seventeen years of talking looks like when it meets a mountain.

Look at how we cover these conferences. Who went, who they met, where they spoke. Then we move on. Hardly anyone asks what came of it. But after thousands of Nepalis and hundreds of foreigners were killed or left missing in a single morning, "attendance" is not a report. COP31 in Antalya is a fair place to start asking. Nepal and Bhutan wanted a separate mountain agenda item and did not get the consensus they needed. Kyrgyzstan's proposal fell short too. Consultations are still going, mountain language may yet be salvaged, and a line in a draft decision is a start, not a summit. Even if a word of it survives into the final text, this was still a misstep, and people deserve to know where the talks broke down.

On mountain diplomacy, the best way forward is to look backward. Mountains entered the global rulebook in 1992, when Chapter 13 of Agenda 21 put them on the UN's map. Kyrgyzstan gave the cause a home a decade later with the Bishkek Global Mountain Summit of 2002, the first of its kind. Nepal's own lead came in climate terms, and it was real. It launched the Mountain Initiative in Copenhagen in 2009, carried the argument to Cancún and Durban, and hosted mountain countries in Kathmandu in 2012. Even then, the Kathmandu Call for Action was asking for dedicated financing for mountain adaptation and mitigation. Seventeen years on, the government should be able to say which partnerships survived, which commitments were followed up, and which files stayed put when governments changed. If every new minister has to learn the mountain agenda from scratch, Nepal has thrown away something it should have kept.

The journey has had its moments. Dubai was the high point. At COP28 in December 2023, then Prime Minister Pushpa Kamal Dahal hosted a roundtable called "Call of the mountains: who saves us from the climate crisis?" Secretary-General António Guterres co-hosted, just after his visit to Nepal. Credit where it is due, the FAO Mountain Partnership counts five mentions of mountains in the first Global Stocktake text, and COP28 mandated an expert dialogue on mountains and climate change, which met in Bonn the following June. But five mentions in a negotiated text do not add up to five working warning systems. Nepal's climate lead agency should tell us what it built on that base - a stronger negotiating team, wider alliances, proposals other governments would fund, better monitoring and preparedness at home. We should be told.

Bhutan's partnership is welcome, and the two countries joined other mountain countries for a discussion at COP31. But sharing a stage is not the same as building a bloc big enough to carry a decision. Being early on this issue doesn't make the mountain agenda Nepal's property. It means successive governments have a record to answer for.

No Image

That record raises an awkward question. In 2009, Nepal built a mountain coalition. In 2026, it went to Antalya and filed its own proposal together with Bhutan. UNFCCC documents show that Kyrgyzstan, acting for the Mountain Group, had already asked for the existing mountain dialogue to become a standing annual item. Nepal and Bhutan's version went further - a scientific assessment, an annual high-level dialogue, a dedicated work program. That may explain the separate filings, but nobody has said so publicly. What happened next tells its own story. Neither proposal made the agenda when it was set. Only after days of consultations did the two sides merge their texts, reportedly the day before the plenary, and the title was reworked after some countries grew uneasy with its 1.5°C wording. Bishkek showed Kyrgyzstan was still organizing. Antalya showed Nepal was still catching up. If other glaciated and downstream countries were offered a place in a joint text and said no, the government should tell us. If nobody asked them, Nepal gave away the strength of its own legacy.

India and China are the harder part, so credit where it starts. At the UN General Assembly in New York in September, Prime Minister Balen Shah did what climate diplomacy is supposed to look like: he took the right idea to the right stage at the right moment. A Himalayan Climate Resilience Mechanism - Nepal, India and China sharing satellite data, monitoring, early warning and disaster help across borders - is exactly the offer a country in Nepal's position should be making. It showed instinct. It showed ambition. Both neighbors sat at the center of it, and the speech made headlines at home and abroad.

Then the idea vanished. Somewhere between New York, Kathmandu and Antalya, the Prime Minister's proposal fell through the floor of the machinery beneath him.

That is the real scandal, and it is not his idea but it is what his government did with it. From the public record we can see, there is no formal invitation to India and China, no written proposal on any table, no follow-up at all. Somebody was tasked with turning that speech into diplomacy, and there are only three places that job could have lived: the Prime Minister's Office, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and the ministry that runs Nepal's climate negotiations. One of them knows where the file is. India and China cannot be forced to agree, but if they were asked and said no, publish their answer. And if nobody asked, then the country watched its leader make the right move on the world stage while the system below him left the hand empty.

Weeks after Rasuwa, a cross-border warning system is not an applause line. It is the difference between a family running uphill and a family counted among the missing. The Prime Minister showed he understands that. Now his government has to show it can execute what its leader already understands. He should demand answers, not assurances. If the answer is that nobody followed up, the country is entitled to know who did not.

Diplomacy is only half the test. What happened at home matters more, and Rasuwa shows what weak follow-through costs. According to Onlinekhabar, a government committee set up after the July 2025 flood recommended cross-border early warning, scientific risk assessments, safer infrastructure and measures for exposed settlements. The outlet found none of it had been carried out before the disaster on August 26. None of those recommendations needed foreign recognition. They needed decisions, money and a named official for each task. There's a grim efficiency in commissioning a warning, filing it, and later commissioning a study of the damage.

Not every mountain disaster can be predicted or prevented, and any inquiry should separate what was knowable from what only became clear afterwards. The slope on Langtang Lirung was coming down whether or not anyone was watching it. But monitoring, mapping and warning are exactly the things a country controls, and uncertainty is no excuse for sitting on risks that were already identified. None of this lets the big emitters or the donors off the hook either. Nepal needs deeper emissions cuts, adaptation finance and fair arrangements for loss and damage, and donors should be judged on money delivered, not pledges announced. Still, an unread report in Kathmandu is an unread report.

So, at home, the Prime Minister's Office should require a funded program with named responsibilities across infrastructure, water, energy, finance, foreign affairs and disaster management. Municipalities need technical staff and steady money. Monitoring can't stop between emergencies, and warning procedures should be tested before anyone's life depends on them. Seven minutes was all it took for the water to reach the border. A tested system does not need long. It needs to exist.

International cooperation should back that work up. It is why I have been pushing for the International Center for Glaciers and Permafrost (ICGP), a concept I originated. It would be an intergovernmental institution with a global mandate on glaciers, permafrost and adaptation, helping countries turn scientific knowledge into preparedness, safer investment and practical cooperation. Every glaciated country should be invited to shape it, with downstream countries in the room. Nepal could champion it; India, China, Pakistan, Bhutan and other mountain countries could help build support. No single country should own it.

Antalya is not over, and Nepal should push for the strongest outcome it can get. When the delegation reports back, draft language shouldn't be passed off as an adopted decision, a consultation as a funded program, or a dialogue as protection delivered. A Nepal–India–China mechanism and the ICGP will only matter if governments understand them, sign on and pay for them. Copenhagen, Kathmandu and Dubai should read as one continuing record of work, not a string of openings that governments let slip. And the clock is ticking: in October 2027, mountain countries gather again at Bishkek+25, a full quarter-century after Kyrgyzstan first got them in a room. Will Nepal arrive with a record, or with another speech?

After Rasuwa, no more open questions. What gets monitored, and by whom? Who hears the warning first? Which homes and bridges get moved or reinforced before the next slope lets go? These are not requests. A country that has buried this many people gets to name the answers it expects, and to keep a list of everyone standing in the way of them.

Nepal has spent seventeen years asking the world to listen. Kathmandu has yet to listen to itself...

Rajouria is a climate and diplomatic strategist working on climate resilience, glacier risk and international cooperation. He holds a Master in Public Administration from Harvard's Kennedy School. He conceived the proposed International Center for Glaciers and Permafrost (ICGP), a focused global platform for science, adaptation, risk reduction and cooperation among glaciated countries, and has been its leading advocate. He also led the Asian Development Bank's funded concept-level study for the glacier center.