Nepal | December 02, 2020

Thwart US veto or await new president? WTO has leadership dilemma

Reuters
Share Now:

BRUSSELS/WASHINGTON: Faced with a veto from the United States, the World Trade Organization has two unpalatable options for selecting its next leader – override its biggest paymaster with a vote or hope for a change of US president and wait until he takes charge.

With just days to go before the US election, President Donald Trump’s administration struck another blow to the global trade watchdog on Wednesday by rejecting Nigeria’s Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, the woman proposed by a nomination “troika” to be the WTO’s next director-general.

Okonjo-Iweala, who would be the first African WTO leader, is also a US citizen.

In a short statement, the office of the US Trade Representative said it supported a rival candidate, South Korean Trade Minister Yoo Myung-hee, as someone with hands-on experience in international trade.

One Geneva-based diplomat said Washington changed direction “in a chaotic” way in the very last throes of the leadership race to support Yoo, blocking the process.

“It seems like they were improvising,” the diplomat said.

Okonjo-Iweala’s spokeswoman Molly Toomey rejected any suggestion that the former Nigerian finance minister was not qualified for the job: “Needless to say, WTO members wouldn’t have selected a DG who is missing any skills or qualifications.”

William Reinsch, a former senior U.S. Commerce Department official now with the Center for Strategic and International Studies, predicted furious discussions behind the scenes to get the United States to change its position.

Trump has described the WTO as “horrible” and biased towards China and threatened to leave, and it is difficult to imagine his administration would acquiesce by Nov. 9, when the WTO will hold a meeting designed to appoint its new leader.

Even if Trump loses the election, he will remain in office until Jan. 20, inauguration day, making any early resolution even less likely.

It would not be the first time the WTO has faced a roadblock over its leadership. In the past it has found ways round them.

In 1999, two candidates divided WTO members, with a compromise finally found to give each a term. New rules were then put in place to avoid a repeat.

Candidates least likely to attract a consensus “shall withdraw”, the 2003 rules say, with a vote to be taken “as a last resort”. Korea’s Yoo could withdraw, but her team did not respond on Thursday to questions about her future intentions.

HUMILIATION

A vote may appear an easy fix, but is more a nuclear option.

Simon Evenett, trade professor at Switzerland’s University of St Gallen, said large WTO members would see this as an unwelcome precedent.

“Big players like subtle vetos. Publicly losing a vote is humiliating,” he said.

Washington might see recourse to a vote almost as an act of war and an excuse to make good Trump’s threat to quit the WTO. It is not even clear how WTO members would decide to hold a vote.

This leaves a final possibility, relying on a change of U.S. president.

Rufus Yerxa, a former senior U.S. trade official who now heads the National Foreign Trade Council, said the result of the U.S. election would be decisive.

“For the people in Geneva that are trying to make this decision, the election will determine if they’re going to be in another showdown fight… or whether they can afford to wait him out and deal with the Biden administration,” he said.

One senior U.S. trade official said that if Democratic challenger Joe Biden won, WTO members would be well-advised to hold off until he took office. Biden, he added, would be anxious to “get off on the right foot” with the WTO.

The United States has already disabled the WTO’s role as a global trade arbiter by blocking appointments to its Appellate Body, which acts like a supreme court of trade. Could it manage further months without a leader?

In theory, the director-general’s role is limited. He or she runs a secretariat of over 600 people, a job the current deputy director-generals can fulfil.

Pascal Lamy, WTO director-general from 2005 to 2013, says the lack of clarity creates a margin for manoeuvre, subject to WTO members acquiescing.

“They can lend you authority. It’s limited and on lease. They don’t give it to you, they lend it to you. You need a vision, and a desire to take this organisation from A to B,” he said.

This role, part facilitator, part visionary, in multilateral trade would be missing.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Nepal COVID-19 Update: 1304 new cases, 2073 recoveries, 21 fatalities recorded on Tuesday

KATHMANDU: Nepal’s Health Ministry, in its regular press briefing, shared the latest updates on coronavirus contagion from across the country, and government’s response to the health crisis. READ ALSO: 530 of 1304 cases reported today from Kathmandu valley Till date, 1,746,330 tests throu Read More...

Nepalgunj Airport

Nepalgunj airport to be developed as hub airport: Minister Bhattarai

NEPALGUNJ: Minister for Culture, Tourism and Civil Aviation Yogesh Bhattarai today stressed for developing the Nepalgunj Airport as one of the hub airports in the country. While inaugurating the extended airport apron here today, Minister Bhattarai said that the Nepalgunj and Biratnagar airports Read More...

Jones seals progress for depleted Liverpool with win over Ajax

LIVERPOOL: Teenager Curtis Jones grabbed a 58th-minute winner as an injury-hit Liverpool qualified for the knockout stage of the Champions League with a 1-0 win over Ajax Amsterdam at Anfield on Tuesday. The victory ensured top spot in Group D for Juergen Klopp's side with 12 points after riv Read More...

Ministry of Home Affairs

Bar on strike in delivery of essential services

KATHMANDU, DECEMBER 1 The Government of Nepal has imposed a ban on strike or bandh in production, supply, sale and distribution of 25 essential goods and services amid the COVID pandemic. As per a notice published by the Ministry of Home Affairs in Nepal Gazette yesterday, the ban was imposed Read More...

Porto join Manchester City in advancing in Champions League

PORTO: FC Porto joined Manchester City in advancing to the next phase of the Champions League after the two played out a goalless draw in their Group C clash on Tuesday. The point, combined with defeat for Olympiakos in France, was enough to ensure Porto finished second while City, wh Read More...

Cops accused of opening fire called for interrogation

RAUTAHAT, DECEMBER 1 Two policemen, who were accused of opening fire in Bardibas of Mahottari have been called to the district police office in Jaleshwor for interrogation. Police had fired dozens of tear gas shells and bullets to control a demonstration of angry locals who were protesting aga Read More...

Majority prevails in NCP Sectt

KATHMANDU, DECEMBER 1 Majority members' will prevailed today in the Secretariat meeting of the ruling Nepal Communist Party (NCP), as Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli was forced to agree to discuss the proposal of party Co-chair Pushpa Kamal Dahal, although the PM wanted Dahal to withdraw his proposa Read More...

Call to curb violence against children

KATHMANDU, DECEMBER 1 In the context of increasing incidents of violence against children in the country, Save the Children has condemned such acts against children, particularly sexual violence against girls. Issuing a press release yesterday, Save the Children called upon federal and local g Read More...