Nepal | July 06, 2020

Bill to amend NHRC Act in accordance with constitutional provisions: Minister

Himalayan News Service
Share Now:

Kathmandu, June 28

Although the government has been vehemently criticised for bringing the National Human Rights Commission Act (Amendment Bill) that proposes giving the Attorney General overriding power against recommendations of the rights body, the government is in no mood to relent on the issue.

Minister of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs Bhanu Bhakta Dhakal told the Law, Justice and Human Rights Committee of the House of Representatives today that the government brought the NHRC Act (Amendment) Bill in line with the provisions of the constitution.

Dhakal cited Article 158 of the constitution to argue that the Attorney General had the final authority to institute case against the accused.

The NHRC, civil society members and political parties, including Nepali Congress, Samajwadi Party-Nepal and Rastriya Janata Party-Nepal, have opposed incorporation of the provisions in the NHRC Act (Amendment) Bill that gives the AG a final say on whether or not to institute cases against those persons whose names could figure in NHRC’s recommendations for action.

Article 158 (2) of the constitution states, “The Attorney General or government attorneys subordinate to him or her shall represent the Government of Nepal in lawsuits wherein the rights, interests or concerns of the Government of Nepal are involved. Except as provided otherwise in this Constitution, the Attorney General shall have the right to make a final decision as to whether to institute any case on behalf of the Government of Nepal in any court, judicial body or authority.”

Kevin Deveaux, an international adviser of UNDP, presented a paper on “The Role of Parliamentary Committee in Ensuring Human Rights” at the panel meeting today. Soon after Deveaux’s presentation, NC lawmaker Dev Prasad Timilsina opposed the government’s move of keeping the NHRC under AG’s jurisdiction. He said the bill was brought  to curtail NHRC’s powers.

Office bearers of constitutional bodies were saying that they would not accept the bill if its provisions did not reflect their views, according to Minister Dhakal.  He, however, did not name any office bearer.

Chairperson of the NHRC Anup Raj Sharma, talking to THT, said the original NHRC Act contained similar provision that the government has incorporated in the recent bill and when the matter had reached the Supreme Court seven years ago, it said that the provision of the Act was unconstitutional. Advocate Om Prakash Aryal had filed a case challenging the AG’s sweeping powers in the bill.

Sharma said in principle, AG had the power to decide whether or not to institute a criminal case but the constitution had made it clear about exceptional cases. “Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority and the Judicial Council make independent decisions to initiate cases under their jurisdictions. NHRC, which was established under the Paris principles, also had similar autonomy and independence,” he argued.

Sharma said that if AG was given the power to override NHRC recommendation as provisioned in the bill, then the AG who is appointed by the prime minister might not act upon the NHRC’s recommendations and the guilty might not be punished.

The bill is in the House of Representatives now. Though the minister was rigid on the bill’s provisions, Chair of the Law, Justice and Human Rights Committee Krishna Bhakta Pokharel in the meeting said the committee would address the concern raised by NHRC. “The panel has held discussion with NHRC and it is going to solve the problems,” he said.


A version of this article appears in print on June 29, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority (CIAA) building

Engineer booked for accumulating illegal assets

KATHMANDU, JULY 4 The Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority yesterday filed a charge-sheet at the Special Court against Bharat Raj Acharya, an engineer at the Department of Roads. He has been charged with accumulating disproportionate assets worth around Rs 32.2 million. Ac Read More...

Pokhara International Airport

60 per cent work of Pokhara Regional International Airport completed

POKHARA, JULY 4 Almost 60 per cent construction work of Pokhara Regional International Airport has been completed. The China-based CAMC Engineering Company has been entrusted with the contract to complete the project by 10 July 2021. The estimated project cost is Rs 22 billion. Construction of Read More...

COVID victim’s body laid to rest amid obstruction

DAMAULI, JULY 4 After 12-hour obstruction by the locals, a body of 44-year-old man who died of COVID-19, was laid to rest in Ludi Dobhan, bordering Sahid Lakhan Rural Municipality and Gorkha Municipality in Gorkha at 6:00pm today. The man had died in Gorkha Hospital at 5:00am today. CDO Surend Read More...

Lockdown tightened in Lamjung

LAMJUNG, JULY 4 Lamjung District COVID-19 Crisis Management Centre today decided to open essential shops and businesses besides pharmacies from 5:00am to 12:00noon. A meeting of the centre took the decision in view of the rising COVID-19 cases in the district. Lamjung CDO Krishna Prasad Adh Read More...

Province 2

Quarantine facilities emptying in Province 2

JANAKPUR, JULY 4 The number of people staying in quarantine centres has been decreasing. As of last Thursday, the number of people quarantined in eight districts of Province 2 has gone down to 3,770. Two weeks ago, the number of people staying in 455 quarantines facilities of the province w Read More...

Dhankuta map

Opening of new park in Dhankuta delayed due to dispute

DHANKUTA, JULY 4 Even after the completion of construction work of Banjhakri Park months before the deadline, its scheduled inauguration couldn’t take place yesterday due to a dispute between the provincial and local government over the right to inaugurate the park in Dhankuta’s Mahalaxmi Mun Read More...

Private school teachers hit streets demanding salary of lockdown period

Many teachers don’t voice their concerns fearing action from school administration ITAHARI, JULY 4 Private schools’ teachers of Sunsari district have hit the streets to press for payment of their long due salaries. Organised under the banner of Institutional School Teachers’ Union, Suns Read More...

Benchmark index surges 4.54 per cent in volatile trading

KATHMANDU, JULY 4 The Nepal Stock Exchange (Nepse) reopened fully for the first time after the lockdown was imposed on June 29 and in volatile trading till July 2, the benchmark index surged by 4.54 per cent or 54.53 points. After the trading in the sole secondary market was suspended followin Read More...