Nepal | August 08, 2020

Bill that curtails NHRC’s rights not acceptable, say former chief justices

Jagdish Panday
Share Now:

If the government curtailed the rights of the NHRC, civil society would take to the streets

Kathmandu, July 12

Former chief justices, civil society members and legal eagles today said they would not accept it if the bill registered in the Parliament to amend the National Human Rights Commission Act was endorsed without removing the provisions that curtail the rights of the rights watchdog.

During a programme organised here, they said the bill’s provision had curtailed the rights of the NHRC in terms of its autonomy, administrative and financial power. The bill proposes more discretionary authority to the attorney general on the rights body’s recommendations seeking prosecution of human rights violators. It also proposes that the NHRC should make recommendations for filing court cases to the Office of the Attorney General. The bill also states that if the AG directs the NHRC to probe into certain cases, the latter should comply with the order. The draft bill stipulates that the AG will have the authority to take a final call on filing cases against alleged human rights violators after analysing additional evidences submitted by the NHRC.

Former chief justice Sushila Karki said she was doubtful whether the government was trying to render the constitutional body a weak division of the government.  “Provisions limiting the functions and jurisdiction of the NHRC should be removed from the bill to make it an independent constitutional body,” she added saying that she would keep on fighting to ensure that the government respected human rights.

She said the government was responsible for deteriorating human rights condition in the country.

Another former chief justice and chairperson of Constitution Watch Group Kalyan Shrestha said political parties did not respect democratic norms and values. “The government seems reluctant in implementing court orders and recommendation of the NHRC,” he said. Shrestha also questioned whether the government with two-thirds majority was above the country’s constitution.

Shrestha said the constitutional commissions were formed to help the government. “It is not right to interpret decisions by constitutional commissions as directed at failing the government. In democracy the government should be ready to accept criticism.”

Shrestha also criticised the government for allocating paltry 20.1 million rupees for the NHRC. “Will it be enough to run the office of the NHRC? The commission looks after implementation of 31 fundamental rights of the constitution, other national and international laws and carries out investigations into different other cases,” he said, adding that the government should at least allocate Rs 21 billion for the commission.

Former chief justice and Chair of NHRC Anup Raj Sharma said that he would continue to fight to protect human rights in the country.

Senior Advocate Shambhu Thapa said AG should not be given the power to control the NHRC. “The AG cannot direct or recommend a case to the NHRC, rather the AG should act on the recommendations of the NHRC.”

Civil society member Kapil Shrestha said if the government curtailed the rights of the NHRC through the amendment bill, civil society would take to the streets against it. He also reminded the government of their struggle to protect human rights during late king Mahendra’s regime.

Defending the questions and comments, Deputy Parliamentary Party Leader of the ruling Nepal Communist Party (NCP) Subas Chandra Nembang, Chief Whip of NCP Dev Prasad Gurung, Minister of Law Justice and Parliamentary Affairs Bhanu Bhakta Dhakal and Chair of  Parliamentary Law, Justice and Human Rights committee Krishna Bhakta Manandhar assured that the government and the Parliament would finalise the bill in line with the constitutional provisions.

At the beginning of the programme, legal expert Bipin Adhikari, presented a paper based on human rights and the NHRC bill stating that the government should not curtail the rights of the NHRC.


A version of this article appears in print on July 13, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Sevilla, Leverkusen cruise into Europa League quarter-finals

Five-times winners Sevilla made light work of AS Roma when first half goals from Sergio Reguilon and Youssef En-Nesyri gave them a 2-0 win over AS Roma and sent them into the Europa League quarter-finals on Thursday. Sevilla's win, in a tie reduced to a single match played in Duisberg, Ge Read More...

Mexico, coronavirus outbreak;

Mexico's coronavirus death toll tops 50,000

MEXICO CITY: Mexico's health ministry on Thursday reported 6,590 new confirmed coronavirus infections and 819 fatalities, bringing the country's totals to 462,690 cases and 50,517 deaths. The virus is spreading quickly; just over two weeks ago, the health ministry reported 40,000 deaths. M Read More...

University of Washington forecasts 300,000 US COVID-19 deaths

WASHINGTON: Nearly 300,000 Americans could be dead from COVID-19 by Dec. 1, University of Washington health experts forecast on Thursday, although they said 70,000 lives could be saved if people were scrupulous about wearing masks. The prediction by the university's widely cited Institute for Read More...

MoWCSC

Licence of child care home seized

Kathmandu, August 6 The National Child Rights Council, under the Ministry of Women, Children and Senior Citizens, seized the licence of Kapan-based Care Child Orphanage following the rescue of 11 children sheltering there yesterday. Stating that the orphanage had violated the provisions in the Read More...

Covid-19 positive Province 2 home minister in home isolation

JANAKPURDHAM/KATHMANDU, AUGUST 6 Province 2 Internal Affairs and Law Minister Gyanendra Yadav has contracted COVID and has been staying in ‘isolation at his home as per the doctor’s advice’ since he tested positive for the virus’. Yadav, who is asymptomatic, has urged everyone who Read More...

Student enrolment remains uncertain

Kathmandu, August 6 Mainly private schools in the country have been running online classes. However, due to poor internet facility and frequent power cuts, online classes have not been effective in Nepal. Preparations to resume student enrolment since August 17 have been marred by increasin Read More...

Community spread feared in Siraha

Siraha, August 6 The spread of COVID-19 in the community has caused terror in Siraha of late. Just yesterday, four persons involved in different occupations tested positive for the virus here, according to District Health Office. Two of the four are health professionals of a polyclinic; one Read More...

VTM crunch hits Banke

Nepalgunj, August 6 The shortage of Viral Transport Medium used for collecting and transporting swab samples has hit the health offices in Banke. The local levels bought the VTMs and offered them to health offices as they did not have it. Mayor of Nepalgunj sub-metropolis Dhawal Shamsher Ra Read More...