Nepal | July 14, 2020

‘JC’s actions can undermine independence of judiciary’

‘If JC were to punish judges then no one would get bail’

Himalayan News Service
Share Now:

Kathmandu, August 17

The Judicial Council’s recent action against some judges of Biratnagar High Court has touched off a debate in the legal sector with some legal experts saying the  JC needs to strike a balance while taking punitive action against erring judges.

The JC had taken punitive action against some BHC judges for passing erroneous order in the 33.5 kg gold smuggling and Sanam Shakya murder case. It sacked BHC Judge Umesh Kumar Singh and served warning letters to two other judges Thir Bahadur Karki, and Sadhuram Sapkota.

The Supreme Court, had, however, endorsed the BHC judges verdicts in almost all cases except one.

Former justice of Supreme Court Bala Ram KC said High Court judges should be impeached if they had made mistakes along the lines of the removal process of Supreme Court justices or else, they would not be able to function independently. “Summoning High Court judges to the JC is wrong because judges are not civil servants,” KC said and added that in India, High Court Judges were removed through impeachment much the same way as Indian Supreme Court Justices were removed.

If any high court judge erred in any case, he/she could be deprived of the bench while the investigation was on, but he/she should not be transferred to the JC on deputation, KC argued. “I think the chief justice should make efforts to bring the required reform in laws to make high court judges independent,” KC added. He also said that in order to ensure independence of judiciary, provisions should be made to provide pay and perks to judges from the consolidated fund.

Senior Advocate Mithilesh Kumar Singh also said that the JC had summoned some Biratnagar High Court judges accused of wrongdoing in the 33.5 kg gold smuggling case and put them on deputation for months. The SC had recently ordered the JC to take action against two Pokhara High Court judges for acting beyond their jurisdiction in a case. “If a judge errs, then there is higher court to correct it. We have three tiers of courts that ensure checks and balances so when a lower court judge errs in an order, then there is a higher court judge to check this, but that should not mean that the JC should take punitive action against a lower court judge for passing erroneous order,” Singh said and added that if lower court judges were punished by the JC for passing orders, then no judge would not grant bail to the accused. “No jail, only bail is a concept emerging in democracies,” he said.

Senior Advocate YadunathKhanal said there was widespread feeling in the legal fraternity that the JC did not use its
judicial mind while recommending actions against BHC judges and if such feelings grew, people would seek changes in the constitution to ensure that High Court judges were removed only through impeachment. “Under the existing system, the JC can take action against erring judges of all tiers, but it should do that only after thoroughly investigating allegations against judges,” he said and added that the JC should refrain from taking populist steps.

Advocate Sunil Ranjan Singh also said the JC’s action against High Court judges had scared other judges and most judges were choosing to send the accused to judicial custody evening cases where there were sufficient reasons for granting bail to the accused. “If judges are scared of the JC’s action, they won’t use their judicial mind in cases. Independence of the judiciary also means that judges should be able to use their judicial mind,” he said.

Summoning judges to the JC undermines the morale of judges as it brings them in the spotlight for negative reasons, he argued.

A version of this article appears in print on August 18, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Manchester United, Marcus Rashford, Premier League

United stay fifth after Saints grab last-gasp leveller

MANCHESTER: Manchester United's Champions League qualification hopes suffered a blow after an equaliser deep in stoppage time from Michael Obafemi earned Southampton a 2-2 draw in the Premier League at Old Trafford on Monday. United, unbeaten in 18 games in all competitions, were poised to m Read More...

Capital budget spending at two-decade low of 40 per cent

KATHMANDU, JULY 13 With just two days remaining for the 2019-20 fiscal year to end, capital budget expenditure throughout the year stands at one of the worst ever at 39.62 per cent. Officials at the Ministry of Finance said capital expenditure during the current fiscal year, which was primaril Read More...

Mayur company resumes bus service in Kathmandu

Kathmandu, July 13 Mayur Yatayat Company resumed its bus services from today in Kathmandu valley amid the COVID-19 pandemic. The decision of Mayur Yatayat has come as a relief to commuters at a time when other public transportation entrepreneurs were refusing to operate their services citing f Read More...

‘Press freedom should involve accountability’

Kathmandu, July 13 Minister of Communications and Information Technology Dr Yubaraj Khatiwada said the CIT Ministry ought to start digitisation first, by utilising the advancement of information technology. As the government has adopted a digital framework, we should become paperless in our activ Read More...

Absconding murder suspect held after 13 years

Kathmandu, July 13 Police have nabbed one of the two prime murder suspects of the much-hyped Sitapaila murder case that had happened 13 years ago. Two workers at a saw mill had allegedly killed its owner, his wife and inflicted serious injuries to their 15-year-old son on the night of 2 Januar Read More...

US debates school reopening, WHO warns 'no return to normal'

MIAMI: The resurgence of the coronavirus in the United States ignited fierce debate Monday about whether to reopen schools, as global health officials warned that the pandemic will intensify unless more countries adopt comprehensive plans to combat it. “If the basics aren’t followed, there is Read More...


COVID-19 control, disaster management top priorities

Kathmandu, July 13 Tokha Municipality in Kathmandu has set priorities for containment of COVID-19 crisis and disaster management in the budget for the upcoming fiscal year. The municipality that is located in the northern belt of Kathmandu unveiled a budget for Rs 1.58 billion for the fiscal y Read More...

US budget deficit hits all-time high of $864 billion in June

WASHINGTON: The federal government incurred the biggest monthly budget deficit in history in June as spending on programs to combat the coronavirus recession exploded while millions of job losses cut into tax revenues. The Treasury Department reported Monday that the deficit hit $864 billion last Read More...