Nepal | July 09, 2020

Madhesi inclusion in judiciary still a far cry

Himalayan News Service
Share Now:

Kathmandu, December 7

Although the constitution guarantees proportional inclusion of all social groups in all state organs, the judiciary has not been ensuring this principle in the appointment of judges.

Of the 11 Supreme Court justices who were appointed on 1 August  2016, there was only one Madhesi Judge — Anil Kumar Karna.

Nine judges of the SC were appointed after these appointments, yet there was no judge from the Madhesi community. Tej Bahadur KC and Purushottam Bhandari were appointed judges of the Supreme Court in January 2017. Bam Kumar Shrestha, Dambar Bahadur Shahi and Tanka Bahadur Moktan were appointed SC judges in October 2017. Similarly, Prakash Dhungana, Sushmalata Mathema,  Hari Phuyal, Kumar Regmi and Manoj Kumar Sharma were appointed SC judges in April this year.

The Judicial Council recommended 80 High Court judges in 2017, but there were only three Madhesis and one Dalit judge. Out of 80 HC judge nominees, 62  were from Khas Arya group accounting for 31.25 per cent of the population. Only four persons, or 5 per cent, from the Madhesi community were nominated.

JC has recommended only three women as High Court judges against more than 51.4 per cent population of women.

Nepal Bar Association had opposed the appointment of High Court judges terming it a violation of the Judicial Council Act.

Advocate Pankaj Karna said there had to be 17 to 18 Madhesi judges among 80 high court judges to reflect the proportionality of the Madhesi population, but there were less than five Madhesi judges. “The chief justice-headed JC has not been following the principle of proportional inclusion in the judiciary and unfortunately the SC, which upholds the constitution, often quashes writ petitions filed against the JC’s failure to ensure proportional inclusion,” Karna added.

Karna said arguments were often made that there were not many Madhesis among district judges, hence their inclusion could not be ensured in appointment of high court judges, but if the JC wanted to ensure proportional inclusion, it could appoint judges from among lawyers.

“JC must prepare a list of clusters of judges in all tiers of court and start appointing judges accordingly to ensure proportional inclusion. If the JC cannot ensure proportional inclusion due to lack of seats, then it must prepare a backlog system whereby people of the clusters whose participation could not be ensured, should be ensured later,” Karna argued.

He said political parties that were supposed to raise the issue of proportional inclusion in the judiciary were maintaining mysterious silence over violation of constitutional and legal provisions.

Chief Attorney of Province 2 Dipendra Jha said Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs, who had raised the issue of proportional inclusion all these years, must form a committee to ensure that constitutional and legal provisions of proportional inclusion were fully implemented. He said diversity in the judiciary was essential to ensure fair and balanced interpretation of laws and the constitution.


A version of this article appears in print on December 08, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

In Pictures: Rallying forth in Prime Minister's support

Supporters of Prime Minister KP Oli organised a rally at Lagankhel, Lalitpur, on Wednesday, for the seventh day. The pro-prime minister demonstrations were held in the wake of recent political developments wherein PM Oli is being asked to step down from his either of his posts. Read More...

Over 90pc COVID-19 recovery reported in Rautahat

RAUTAHAT: Rautahat district, which has been hard-hit by the pandemic, has shown a promising rate of COVID-19 recovery. The district with about 92 percent of patients being discharged from health facilities has bagged much appreciation for the efforts of the concerned authorities. According to Read More...

India's COVID-19 challenges continue; 22,752 fresh cases detected on Wednesday

KATHMANDU: India's challenges with the ongoing coronavirus crisis continues with the confirmation of more than 22,000 cases on Wednesday. According to the Union Health Ministry of India, in the last 24 hours, as many as 22,752 positive cases of the respiratory infection have been detected country Read More...

Coronavirus , vaccines, vaccines trails

'At war time speed', China leads COVID-19 vaccine race

SEOUL/SINGAPORE: China is forging ahead in the race to develop a vaccine to help control the COVID-19 pandemic, with Sinovac Biotech's experimental vaccine set to become the country's second and the world's third to enter final stage testing later this month. While a laggard in the global va Read More...

Djokovic accuses critics of 'witch-hunt', undecided on US Open

BELGRADE: Novak Djokovic has accused critics of subjecting him to a "witch-hunt" after his regional Adria Tour tennis event ended in a novel coronavirus fiasco and said he was still uncertain whether he would play at the Aug. 31-Sept 13 US Open. Images and videos of the players hugging at t Read More...

Kanye West

Kanye West breaks ranks with Trump, vows to win presidential race

WASHINGTON: Rapper Kanye West signaled he no longer supported US President Donald Trump and said he would enter the presidential race to win it, according to an interview published on Wednesday. West, previously a vocal supporter of Trump, announced on Saturday that he would run for president in Read More...

Harvard, MIT sue to block ICE rule on international students

BOSTON: Harvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology filed a federal lawsuit Wednesday challenging the Trump administration's decision to bar international students from staying in the US if they take classes entirely online this fall. The lawsuit, filed in Boston's federa Read More...

95 discharged after recovering from COVID-19 in Tanahun

DAMAULI: As many as 95 persons have been discharged upon recovery from coronavirus infection in Tanahun district, on Wednesday. According to Tanahun District Health Office (DHO), the patients were released after two of their consecutive specimens drawn within 24 hours tested negative for the Read More...