Nepal | July 16, 2020

Rift in JC over names, seniority list


Himalayan News Service
Share Now:
Supreme Court (SC) of Nepal has questioned Cabinet expansion.

Supreme Court of Nepal. Photo: THT/File

Kathmandu, February 26

Differences in the Judicial Council over who should be the new justices of the Supreme Court and who should be recommended on the top of the list is delaying the appointment of justices in the Supreme Court.

A knowledgeable source said Minister of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs Agni Prasad Kharel wants to recommend Attorney General Hari Krishna Karki on the top of the nominees’ list so that he could become chief justice after Cholendra Shamsher JB Rana but Chief Justice Kalyan Shrestha wants Chief Judge of Appellate Court, Hetauda, Bishwambhar Prasad Shrestha on the top of the nominees’ list.

Minister Kharel, however, said the issue had not yet been discussed in the JC and was merely a media created controversy. When asked if the JC under Shrestha would be able to appoint new SC justices, Kharel said the issue would be discussed in 3-4 days. Shrestha will retire as CJ in six weeks.

New justices could not be appointed on the vacant positions of the apex court during former chief justice Ram Kumar Prasad Sah’s tenure mainly due to the differences over names and seniority lists and some jurists expressed doubts that if JC did not nominate new SC justice soon, it might not be able to do so during Shrestha’s tenure.

Five-member JC has only three members, as Nepal Bar Association and prime minister are yet to recommend nominees to the JC.

The Central Committee of the Nepali Congress urged the government a few days ago to nominate SC justices only after two more nominees are recommended to the JC.

Chief of SC Bar Narahari Acharya said the appointment of justices in the SC could be free from controversy only if the JC recommended names after it got full shape.

NBA Vice Chair Tika Ram Bhattarai said the NBA was not recommending anybody to the JC mainly because it would be meaningless in the absence of the Parliamentary Hearing Committee.

“JC has taken decisions to transfer lower court judges and has also taken some punitive actions. I believe that JC is free to appoint SC justices even if there are only three members in the body,” Bhattarai added.

Minister Kharel said he did not believe that NC had decided that the JC should nominate new SC justices only after it got full shape. “If the NC has made this decision, then it is against the independence of judiciary,” he added.

As per the new constitution, there need to be 21 justices, including the chief justice, but there are only 10 justices.

SC has more than 21,301 cases to dispose, but due to delay in appointment of justices, the apex court is able to dispose not more than 60 cases a day.

A version of this article appears in print on February 27, 2016 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Surya Nepal donates Rs 10mln to COVID-19 fund

POKHARA: Surya Nepal Pvt Ltd has contributed ten million rupees to COVID-19 fund set up by Gandaki Province, on Tuesday. On behalf of Surya Nepal Pvt Ltd, Gautam Yadav and Baburam Karki handed over the cheque amount to Chief Minister Prithvi Subba Gurung. "This support has boosted our morale i Read More...

162 infected with coronavirus in Tanahun district

DAMAULI: As many as 162 persons have been infected with coronavirus in Tanahun district, so far. According to the District Health Office, 144 males and 18 females staying under quarantine upon arrival from foreign countries tested positive for the virus. DHO Chief Shankar Babu Adhikari said, Read More...

Three dead, one missing in Syangja landslide

POKHARA, JULY 14 Three lives were lost in a landslide in Kaligandaki Rural Municipality, Syangja, this morning. According to Syangja Chief District Officer Ganga Bahadur Chhetri, three of the six persons who had come to repair a drinking water pipeline at about 09:00am died after they were Read More...


339 sickle cell anaemia patients in Dang district

DANG, JULY 14 There are 339 patients of sickle cell anaemia in Dang. A total of 169 patients are under regular medication in Ghorahi Sub-Metropolitan City. Fifty-two news cases were found in the sub-metropolis and 118 new cases were found in Dangisaran Rural Municipality in tests carried out l Read More...

Decision to ramp up tests in Sudurpaschim yet to be implemented

DHANGADI, JULY 14 Sudurpaschim provincial government’s decision to set up coronavirus testing laboratories in several districts is yet to be implemented. It may be noted that the provincial government here in March-April had decided to establish a laboratory each in Baitadi and Doti, and one Read More...

DCC accords priority to implement Halesi masterplan

KHOTANG, JULY 14 The District Coordination Committee of Khotang has prioritised implementation of Halesi master plan. The fourth district assembly passed the resolution presented by DCC Chief Babi Chamling yesterday. The district assembly also prepared an annual programme for implementing the Read More...

Second phase of repatriation to begin today

KATHMANDU, JULY 14 The government is starting the second phase of repatriation process of stranded Nepalis across the world from Wednesday. After one month of the repatriation process, which started on June 10, the government had paused the process for a few days. However, officials at the Read More...

Public transport reopens gradually in valley

KATHMANDU, JULY 14 Almost four months after the government halted public transportation service to curb the spread of coronavirus, some transport operators have started resuming services within the Kathmandu valley. The government had finally decided on July 9 to allow the operation of public Read More...