Nepal | July 05, 2020

Behind plane crashes: Cultural aspect

Suraj Bhandari
Share Now:

The investigation report will dig through the series of events that led to the accident. It will point out the ‘Human Factor’ as the main reason. We had the same report for the Tara Air crash. But those reports don’t get into the mind of pilots, those reports do not look at airline management, and the reports do not take a leaf from Gladwell

Twin otter crash. Illustration: Ratna Sagar Shrestha/THT

On May 27th,  we lost Goma Air Let 410, on May 30th 2017 we lost a Nepal army Skytruck, on February 24  we lost Tara Air Twin Otter and on February 26th 2016 we lost Air Kasthamandap, PAC 750XL and many lives were lost  in these accidents, and thousands of  dreams were shattered.

These accidents happened at a time when the industry is still on a limp to try to tell the world that Nepali airline companies are safe. Among the brave pilots that we have lost in those accidents I remember Captain Paras who as a pilot had an excellent safety record. Captain Colonel Kailash Gurung was known to be assertive and experienced Captain Dinesh lost his life while he succeeded in saving his passengers. Captain Roshan Manandhar was one of the best with more than 20,000 hours of flight experience, I had known him since 2012 during my simulator training.

While shedding tears for the departed, I recalled Malcolm Gladwell’s famous book, Outliers: the story of success, in which the author talks of crashes involving experienced captains and of the relatively inexperienced first officer and a brand new aircraft with the best equipment similar to the recent air crashes in Nepal.

He points out how Korean Aviation suffered due to high power distance index (PDI) in the cockpit. I believe that to some extent, this might very well be the reason for air accidents in Nepal.

Power Distance is the psychological state where there is difference in figures of authority. High power distance index means you will believe everyone has a specific place in hierarchy of power. You will expect the power to be divided unequally, just like in cultures like in Nepal. It’s not our culture to  question a superior authority. This particular tradition is seen in offices, families, schools, and security agencies and in every layer of our society.

After every air crash, an inquiry committee is formed that reports on the cause and provides recommendations. But so far, no one has particularly tried to dig into the cultural aspect of air crashes in Nepal.

The reality is that in the Nepali aviation industry, which happens to conform with Nepali cultural values, a first officer, no matter his/her experience, is seldom listened to. Let’s face it: in Nepal, once inside the cockpit, the first officers are not empowered to question the decisions they are not comfortable with.

Whenever there is an air crash in Nepal, we follow a cycle. First we get sad for losing our loved ones. Then we are angry and blame others. Then we accept the fact as fate and finally forget the whole thing.

And after a few months, the same thing repeats. Isn’t this a similar feeling that we went through during the Sita Air crash on the Manaharain Kathmandu or the Buddha Air crash in Lalitpur ? We have almost forgotten the Tara Air Myagdi crash and yet again we lost Goma Air and Nepali Army aircraft and our friends.

It is imperative to break this chain. When we are sad, we are supposed to promise ourselves that we will never let this happen again, either by investing millions in our infrastructures, equipment, training or implementation of rules.

When we are angry, we are supposed to react by pressing the authorities to do their part, just like the American people did after the Buffalo, NY crash of Dash 8 Q400.  We need to turn our anger into strength.

We are not supposed to accept that plane crashes are the results of fate, there is an absolutely zero act of the divine for plane crashes, there is always something tangible and measurable. We are never supposed to forget the accidents and our future generation should be confident that we did our part to save their lives.

When accidents like these tend to topple the whole system and the whole industry, we have to realize that we are in desperate times, and this demands desperate measures. We try to find a reason for every crash. We talk about bad weather and human error, and leave out important issues like power relations inside the cockpit.

We know using Visual Flight Rules (VFR) flight for Instrument Meteorology Conditions (IMC) is not allowed; yet pilots do it, on a regular basis. We need to ask the major question. Why do they do it? Not who did it?

The very first question after a crash is, who was the pilot? Which airlines was it? Where did it crash? But nobody asks why did it crash.

The EU did their part in nudging us by blacklisting. This has hurt our industry, and this industry is backbone of our economy and we can’t afford to have more air crashes.

The aircraft that crashed in Lukla that day was a brand new aircraft and highly sophisticated in terms of equipment available to the pilots. Yet that plane crashed.

The investigation report will dig through the series of events that led to the accident. And will point out the ‘Human Factor’ as the main reason. We had the same report for the Tara Air crash. But those reports don’t get into the mind of pilots, those reports do not look at airline management, and the reports do not take a leaf from Gladwell.

Bhandari is First Officer with the Himalaya Airlines Pvt. Ltd


A version of this article appears in print on June 12, 2017 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Colombia sex workers

Colombian army fires 31 members for alleged sex abuse against minors

BOGOTA: The Colombian army said on Friday it fired 31 of its members accused of involvement with sexual abuse or violence against minors, amid recent accusations of sex abuse of young girls by soldiers. At least 118 members of the army have been investigated since 2016 for sex crimes against mino Read More...

Mexican soldiers kill 12 in cartel clash near border

MONTERREY: Mexican soldiers killed 12 alleged drug cartel members wearing military gear in the violent border city of Nuevo Laredo on Friday, Tamaulipas state security officials said, in another instance of mass murders that have driven Mexico’s homicides. Officials said armed gunmen clad in mi Read More...

Four killed in separate road accidents in Province 1

PANCHTHAR: Two persons died in a tractor accident that occurred in Aathrai Rural Municipality-5, Tehrathum district on Friday evening. The deceased have been identified as local residents Lalit Khabas (38) and Shyam Magar (40). The tractor (Me 1 Ta 6219) heading towards Sukepokhari from Chuhan Read More...

Clash ensues as police stop local farmers from ploughing fields in Khokana

KATHMANDU: A clash has occurred between local farmers and police personnel in Khokana, Lalitpur district, today. The clash erupted as security personnel stopped farmers from ploughing fields. It has been reported that a few security personnel were injured in the clash. Police even fired severa Read More...

Locals at risk while crossing river using suspension bridge in Bajura

BAJURA: Incessant rainfall in Bajura has raised the water level of Budhiganga River to touch Taprisera suspension bridge leaving commuters, who use the bridge to cross the river, at a great risk. The bridge, which connects Tribeni Municipality and Budhiganga Municipality, is getting partially sub Read More...

Nepal’s Covid-19 tally hits 15,491 as 232 new cases surface on Saturday

KATHMANDU: The Ministry of Health and Population has recorded 232 new cases of the coronavirus infection on Saturday taking the country’s total infection count to 15,491. As many as 272 people have been discharged from health facilities following recovery in the last 24 hours, taking the total Read More...

Nepal logs two more COVID-19 related deaths on Saturday

KATHMANDU: Nepal has recorded two more COVID-19 related deaths, confirmed the Ministry of Health and Population, at its regular media briefing, on Saturday. A 44-year-old male, resident of Palungtar Municipality-7, Gorkha, has succumbed to the coronavirus infection. The swab sample of the decease Read More...

Bajhang Landslide Update: Four bodies recovered

BAJURA: Four persons, who were missing in the landslide that occurred at 2:00 am on Saturday in Mallesi of Kedarsyun Rural Municipality in Bajhang district, have been found dead. Bodies of 40-year-old Rammati Jethara and her 12-year-old son Prayag Jethara were found buried in the debris of the la Read More...