Nepal | August 11, 2020

EDITORIAL: Focus on lawmaking

The Himalayan Times
Share Now:

Rather than seeking pork barrel fund for their constituencies, lawmakers would do well to focus on the lawmaking process 

In a parliamentary democracy, parliamentarians have twin tasks: form a government and make laws. That is why they are called lawmakers. They are not supposed to be engaging in day-to-day development activities. Constitutionally, it is the responsibility of the government to carry out development works and provide services to the people based on the approved fiscal budget. The lawmakers, by virtue of the separation of power among the executive, legislative and judiciary, are supposed to conduct study and research in myriad areas so that they can make laws to address the emerging challenges in society. They, however, have every right to mount pressure on the executive to allocate budget to development projects that benefitt a large section of society.  But all these programmes have to be carried out through the state mechanism, as even a single penny of the taxpayer cannot be spent unaccounted for. They can form a parliamentary panel, if necessary, to see if such projects have been completed on time or have benefitted the people.

However, our lawmakers have developed a wrong tendency of seeking pork barrel funds for the development of their constituencies, where the government can allocate budget in its fiscal budget. The lawmakers started seeking such pork barrel funds soon after the restoration of democracy in 1990, and continues till today. Independent studies carried out by various institutes in the past have proved the total failure of the pork barrel fund, known as the constituency development fund. The fund has had little impact on the given constituencies. Much of the fund allocated to one or the other programme has gone to waste and done little more than appease the influential cadres and the vote bank of the elected representatives, whose sole motive is to get re-elected by misusing the taxpayers’ money. It also does not provide a level playing field for those who could not get elected or who want to stage a comeback.

Considering these anomalies, Finance Minister Yubaraj Khatiwada, in his first fiscal budget on May 28 last year, excluded the pork barrel fund meant for the lawmakers. However, he had to relent to his own party’s lawmakers, who threatened to fail the budget if he did not allocate budget for the pork barrel projects. Later on, Khatiwada allocated a budget of Rs 40 million to each of the 165 constituencies with a rider. Under the provision, a lawmaker elected under the First-Past-the-Post (FPtP) shall form a panel with other PR lawmakers and rural and urban municipality chairs/ deputy chairs as its members to select projects as outlined in the guideline. But it is the FPtP lawmakers who have the final call on the projects in case of no consensus. One year down the road, some of the PR lawmakers are now crying foul for being treated like “second-class” lawmakers. That said, the PR lawmakers do not have their own constituency, where they can spend the fund that is hardly utilised for the stated purpose. Learning lessons from the past, the government would do well not to dole out any money to the lawmakers, who lack institutional capacity to spend and monitor the fund. It would be better if they focussed solely on the lawmaking process, which is their responsibility.


Honest cabbie

In a show of rare honesty, a taxi driver has handed over a bag containing gold ornaments worth a whopping Rs 350,000, left behind by a woman, to the Traffic Police. And it has come to be known that this is not the first time the cabbie, Simal Rai, 38, has handed over to the police things left behind by his passengers. The news has found good coverage in the Nepali media, and we would like to believe that although the country is plunged in chaos, filth and corruption, there are people of integrity who are happy with whatever they earn for the day without having to steal from others.

When it comes to honesty, taxi drivers in Kathmandu (or elsewhere) are not known to live by it. Rarely will a taxi give a ride with the fare meter on, and when it does, you find that it has been tampered with. Last fiscal year, 8,100 taxis were booked for various offences in Kathmandu. On the roads of the capital, unscrupulous taxi drivers rule the roost and refuse to provide their service over short distances. Cabbies would earn a lot of kudos if they were to provide their service honestly without cheating the passengers every now and then.

 


A version of this article appears in print on February 22, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Isolation ward set up

RAJBIRAJ, AUGUST 9 With the rise of COVID infection, Tilathi Koiladi Rural Municipality has brought an isolation ward with 100 beds into operation in the rural municipality of Saptari district. As many as 28 infected people are receiving treatment in the new isolation ward set up at Public Hig Read More...

‘Ruling party lawmakers against provincial govt’

HETAUDA, AUGUST 9 Bagmati Province Chief Minister Dormani Poudel today claimed that lawmakers of the Provincial Assembly from his party were hatching a conspiracy against his government. Inaugurating Fifth Makawanpur District Assembly meeting of District Coordination Committee in Hetauda, CM P Read More...

CIAA books Nepal Water Supply Corporation employee with bribe in Dhading

KATHMANDU: The Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority (CIAA) has detained a government employee with a bribe of over Rs 1 million from Dhunibensi  Municipality-8 in Dhading district. The arrested, identified as engineer Santosh Sah, Chief of Nepal Water Supply Corporation, Butw Read More...

DC shooting leaves 1 dead, some 20 injured

WASHINGTON: A dispute that erupted into gun fire during a large outdoor party in Washington, DC, early Sunday left one person dead and some 20 others injured, including an off-duty officer “struggling for her life,” according to police. Christopher Brown, 17, died in the shooting that occurre Read More...

Trump end run around Congress raises questions on his claims

BRIDGEWATER: President Donald Trump’s end run around Congress on coronavirus relief is raising questions about whether it would give Americans the economic lifeline he claims and appears certain to face legal challenges. Democrats called it a pre-election ploy that would burden cash-strapped state Read More...

Italy's pioneering comic actor, Franca Valeri, dies at 100

ROME: Franca Valeri, an elegant, ironic and versatile actor who pioneered female comic roles in Italy's post-war years and helped the nation laugh at its foibles, has died at 100. The Corriere della Sera newspaper quoted her daughter, Stefania Bonfadelli, an opera singer, as saying that Valeri di Read More...

Red Cross trains thousands of NKoreans to help cope with coronavirus, floods

SEOUL: The Red Cross has trained 43,000 North Korean volunteers to help communities, including the locked-down city of Kaesong, fight the novel coronavirus and provide flood assistance, an official with the relief organisation said on Monday. North Korean leader Kim Jong Un declared an emerge Read More...

Department of Immigration, visa services

Department of Immigration halts visa services after a staffer tests positive for Covid-19

KATHMANDU: Department of Immigration (DoI) has halted its services from Monday until further notice after one of its employees was diagnosed with Covid-19. As there has been a steady rise in coronavirus-infection cases in many parts of the country, government offices have been conducting PCR test Read More...