Nepal | January 17, 2021

EDITORIAL: Start a probe

The Himalayan Times
Share Now:

While Nepal welcomes FDI, we must see to it that there are no shady deals to circumvent the country’s laws

Time and again, the multinational telecommunications company, Ncell, has been making headlines in the media, and always for the wrong reason, of course. This does little to boost its image shrouded as it is in one controversy after another. This time around, an investigation by journalists from Nepal and Britain have uncovered that the major stakeholding company in Ncell at different periods of time may have financed the local partners of the company to purchase 20 per cent of the shares as required by Nepali law, hoping there would be a transfer of the shares should Nepal’s law decrease or eliminate the limit on foreign ownership. While the purchase and sale of Ncell’s shares may have benefitted a handful of Nepali investors, who used funds that came covertly via tax havens, it challenges Nepal’s law on foreign exchange controls, taxation and foreign ownership.

Under Nepal’s Foreign Exchange (Regulation) Act, a Nepali person or entity cannot get financing from abroad to buy shares of a company in Nepal without permission from the central bank.

Ncell has been mired in controversy ever since Telia of Sweden quietly left Nepal in 2016, after selling its 80 per cent stake in the company to another telecom giant, Axiata, of Malaysia, without clearing its capital gain tax. And throughout these years, the government’s focus has been solely on recovering the capital gain tax worth tens of billions of rupees from the company. As a result, the purchase and sale of Ncell’s 20 per cent shares by local investors has largely escaped the attention of the government.

Neither has it bothered to investigate where the local partners got the money from or even if it came through a legal channel.

The Ncell investigation, carried out by the Centre for Investigative Journalism-Nepal and Finance Uncovered of London, shows that Axiata paid $90 million to a secretive offshore company to fund the purchase of Ncell’s 20 per cent shares by businesswoman Bhavana Singh Shrestha. The 20 per cent stake is worth well over US$ 300 million and has earned more than $80 million in dividends since 2016.

There are valuable lessons to learn from Ncell’s operations in Nepal. While Nepal welcomes foreign direct investment (FDI), we have to be on our guard to see that there are no shady deals to circumvent the country’s laws. While foreign companies are here to make a profit and are legally authorised to repatriate all of their earnings back home, we, too, have every right to see that the companies pay every penny that they owe Nepal under Nepal’s tax laws. This demands strong supervision and coordination among the different departments and agencies of the government, such as the Large Taxpayer Office, Department of Money Laundering Investigation, Office of the Auditor General and Commission for Investigation of Authority, among others. Given the many ways big companies use to intimidate the country, the concerned departments must build up their capacity. And, of course, the politicians and authorities must show resolve to get to the bottom of any suspicious deal if there are any and assist in investigating such transactions, not covering them up for personal benefit.

Freed Haliyas’ woes

It has been 13 years since the Haliyas – land tillers – were freed from the age-old semi-bonded labour system in 2008. However, the government has done little for their rehabilitation. There are more than 19,000 freed-Haliyas, mostly in the remote districts of Karnali and Sudurpaschim provinces, according to a report published by a commission formed by the government shortly after their emancipation. However, they have received no support from the government till date.

Recently the freed-Haliyas of Bajura have filed a lawsuit against the government via the Dhangadi-based National Human Rights Commission, stating that they were economically, socially and culturally discriminated even though the government freed them from the Haliya system. The petitioners have demanded that each of them be provided at least five katthas of land and that the five-point deal reached between them and the government in the past be implemented. The food scarcity due to the outbreak of COVID-19 has made their life even more difficult. The condition of the women and children is even more pathetic. As the constitution has guaranteed the right to food and shelter, the government cannot escape from its duty in providing both to the disadvantaged group.




A version of this article appears in print on January 11, 2021 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Six Covid-19 fatalities recorded today, death-tally shifts to 1,954

KATHMANDU: The nationwide coronavirus death-toll has advanced to 1,954 with six more fatalities reported on Saturday. Globally, 2.01 million people have lost their lives to Covid-19 while more than 93.8 million people have been infected by the novel coronavirus. Today, 240 new cases surfaced a Read More...

240 new Covid-19 cases registered on Saturday; nationwide tally hits 267,056

KATHMANDU: Nepal on Saturday reported 240 new cases of coronavirus infection from across the country. With this, the nationwide infection count has advanced to 267,056. Of the total cases, 87 are females while 153 are males. In the last 24 hours, 131 cases surfaced in Kathmandu valley. The cap Read More...

Raindrops are pictured on the window of a car as a man holding an umbrella passes by during the rainfall in Kathmandu

Country witnesses partly to generally cloudy weather in most places

KATHMANDU: Weather will remain partly to generally cloudy in most places across the country, the Department of Hydrology and Meteorology said. It will be partly to generally cloudy in Province 1, Bagmati and Gandaki Provinces with chances of light rainfall owing to the influence of low pressure s Read More...

Trump administration carries out 13th and final execution

TERRE HAUTE: The Trump administration early Saturday carried out its 13th federal execution since July, an unprecedented run that concluded just five days before the inauguration of President-elect Joe Biden — an opponent of the federal death penalty. Dustin Higgs, convicted of ordering the kil Read More...

Traffic is seen as number of vehicles increases in the street after government and private offices, banks and financial institutions have partially been opened during 77th day of nationwide lockdown imposed amid concerns over novel coronavirus outbreak in Kathmandu, on Monday, June 8, 2020. Photo: Naresh Shrestha/THT

131 new Covid-19 cases recorded today in Kathmandu valley

KATHMANDU: The three districts of Kathmandu valley recorded 131 additional cases of coronavirus infection, on Saturday. Of the newly infected, 42 are females while 89 are males. Kathmandu district alone witnessed 115 cases of infection while Lalitpur and Bhaktapur reported 12 and four cases, r Read More...

'Janata Samajwadi Party committed to reinstate the dissolved HoR'

RAUTAHAT: Janata Samajwadi Party cadres have converged at an assembly in Santapur of Rautahat to protest the 'autocratic' move by Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli of dismantling the Lower House, on Saturday. Addressing scores of attendees at the demonstration, JSP leader Anil Kumar Jha stated that th Read More...

Nepali climbers script history scaling K2 in winter season

KATHMANDU: At least 10 Nepali climbers have scripted history in mountain-climbing by making the first ever winter ascent of the world’s second highest peak this afternoon. Legendary climbers Mingma Gyalje Sherpa and Nirmal Purja (Nimsdai) along with other Nepali Sherpa climbers stood atop M Read More...

In Pictures: Frontline COVID-19 health workers on duty

Kathmandu, January 16 A health worker is seen through a door inside the intensive care unit of COVID-19 isolation ward at Teku-based Sukraraj Tropical and Infectious Disease Hospital (STIDH), in Kathmandu, on Saturday. The ward currently has 11 COVID-19 patients under treatment. Dr Anup Bas Read More...