Nepal | June 07, 2020

End impunity: Don’t make mockery of HR

Ram Dayal Rakesh
Share Now:

Human rights and good governance are two sides of the same coin. They are inter-related and inter-connected. The concept of human rights is incomplete without good governance though the idea of good governance is a new one

Illustration: Ratna Sagar Shrestha/THT

Nepal, compared to other Asian countries, has been a significant signatory of several international conventions regarding human rights and humanitarian law. These international conventions have openly denounced impunity. Nepal, as a state party to these conventions, should implement the legal and constitutional measures to end impunity. It is a matter of regret that impunity has not been fully addressed till now. For instance, a teenager, Nirmala Pant, was raped and murdered, but the perpetrators have yet to be arrested and punished even months after the incident took place. Many others perpetrators of human rights abuse have not been punished, and they are challenging the rule of law in the state.

Amnesty International (AI), in its report of 2017/18, mentions that a climate of impunity has persisted in the country. According to its report, there are eight areas of human rights violations in the country. They include transitional justice, enforced disappearance, impunity, abuse by police personnel and armed groups, use of children as soldiers, torture and other forms of ill-treatment, and violence against women. The report further states: “Impunity continued for perpetrators of human rights abuses during the conflict – no case had been tried before a civilian court and survivors of sexual violence reported that police refused to file their complaints.”

On torture, the report states that national laws providing safeguards against torture fell short of international standard, and were hardly implemented given that more than 1,300 new cases of torture have been recorded since 2006.

Very recently, the present chair of National Human Rights Concern Nepal (NHRCN), said that in its probe of an encounter with the police, in which two alleged abductors of a child were killed in a forest in Bhaktapur, it needed further investigation.

First, why did the police need to fire 17 bullets at the two Tamang boys – the alleged abductors? Secondly, how did the police know that the child, Nishan Khadka, who was abducted for ransom and killed, was buried at a certain location? Could it be that the two Tamang boys were detained by the police, and they revealed the location during interrogation? The police said there was two-way firing. But no cartridges of bullets fired at the police were found at the site.

Incidents of police encounters have been on the rise in the country. Two gangsters – Chari and Ghainte – having connections with the political parties were shot dead in police encounters. A thorough investigation of such cases needs to be carried out by the government to see if the encounters were indeed genuine.

The NHRC chair has also mentioned that during the Tarai movement, shots were fired at three children who were not part of the agitation: A boy who was looking out of a window at home; a child sleeping on his mother’ lap; and a teenager observing the agitation. He has also asserted that they were not part of the agitation. They were shot either on the chest or back when the police are authorised to shoot only below the knees. Bullets were also fired when there was no need to shoot.

The government had constituted two commissions led by former Supreme Court Justice Girish Chandra Lal and judge Ali Akbar Mikrani to investigate the cases. Reports of both the commissions have not been made public. There’s no justification for not making such reports public in a democratic country.

Every day, there are reports of rape in the media from all corners of the country, but nobody seems to pay any attention to it. There seems to be confusion about what rape really stands for.

Human rights and good governance are two sides of the same coin. They are inter-related and inter-connected. The concept of human rights is incomplete without good governance though the idea of good governance is a new one. Good governance sounds simple, but its implementation is crucial for the success of democracy.

Transitional justice is in jeopardy. Take the example of the recently formed committee, headed by former chief justice Om Prakash Mishra, to recommend names of the members of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) and Commission on the Investigation of Enforced Disappeared Persons (CIEDP). The government has drawn flak for not consulting and taking consent of the victims’ representatives and human rights activists in the formation of the committee. Besides Mishra, the committee has one member each from the Nepali Congress, the former CPN-UML and the CPN-Maoist Centre, as in the 2015 commission. The government has not learned from its past mistake. Again, if party activists are to be appointed in these commissions, the result will be the same.

The newly-appointed officials in the two commissions will not be able to finish 63,000 cases in the TRC and about 3,000 cases in the CIEDP within their tenure of two years.

The government should, therefore, amend the TRC Act according to the 2015 Supreme Court ruling and international standard, and then appoint the officials. There should not be any attempt to appoint party cadres to the two commissions. They must at least try to heal the wounds of the conflict victims who have been suffering for more than one decade. They have not received any reparation, either. This is also injustice.


A version of this article appears in print on April 19, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Supreme Court of Nepal

SC orders release of illegally-detained man

KATHMANDU, JUNE 5 The Supreme Court today rebuked District Administration Office, Siraha, and others for unlawfully detaining Chakra Bahadur Khatri, a resident of Khotang district, for more than a year. The court asked the National Human Rights Commission to secure the release of the man and w Read More...

Trump orders big US troop cut in Germany, official says

BANGOR, MAINE: US President Donald Trump has ordered the military to remove 9,500 troops from Germany, a senior US official said on Friday, a move likely to raise concerns in Europe about the US commitment to the continent. The move would reduce US troops numbers in Germany to 25,000, from the 3 Read More...

15 yrs on, Bandarmudhe blast victims still await justice

CHITWAN, JUNE 5 Fifteen years have passed since the infamous Bandarmudhe bomb blast, but the victims of the incident are still awaiting justice. The bomb blast carried out by the then rebelling CPN Maoist on a passenger bus at Madi of southern Chitwan had taken the lives of 38 people, leaving Read More...

michael jordan

Jordan giving $100 million for racial equality, justice

CHARLOTTE: Michael Jordan and the Jordan Brand are giving $100 million to organizations dedicated to promoting racial equality and social justice. In a joint statement Friday on social media, Jordan and the Jordan Brand said money will be paid over 10 years with the goal of “ensuring racial equ Read More...

Buffalo officers suspended in shoving of 75-year-old man

BUFFALO: Dozens of Buffalo police officers stepped down from the department's crowd control unit Friday, objecting to the suspensions of two fellow officers in the shoving of a 75-year-old protester who fell and cracked his head. Prosecutors were investigating the encounter captured by a TV crew Read More...

Kylie Jenner tops Forbes highest paid celebs list a week after Forbes' scathing report of her not being a billionaire

LOS ANGELES: After making headlines a week ago in a Forbes report for not being a billionaire, Kylie Jenner on June 4 was ranked at Number 1 by Forbes in its annual world's highest paid celebrities list. She was followed by musician Kanye West, who is married to her half-sister Kim Kadarshian Read More...

Swab collection halted for five days in Sudurpaschim

DHANGADI, JUNE 5 Sudurpaschim Province has halted collection of throat swab samples for five days. Province Health Directorate Office Dhangadi said it had stopped collecting swab samples as more than 1,000 swabs were on hold and left to be tested. “We have more than 1,000 swab samples yet Read More...

Hollywood star Leonardo DiCaprio dedicated to ending disenfranchisement of Black America

KATHMANDU: Joining a growing list of Hollywood celebrities donating to organisations working for equal rights during the 'Black Lives Matter' protests in the US, actor Leonardo DiCaprio too has announced donations while urging others to take action. Taking to Twitter on June 5, the Once Upon A T Read More...