Nepal | August 14, 2020

The right to family: Support children to have one

Dev Datta Joshi
Share Now:

Research has shown that, in their first years, children learn to form emotional attachments with caregivers, and they may lose this ability if they do not have stable family members with whom they can form such feelings

Research has shown that there are at least eight million children who have been placed in orphanages or other such foster institutions across the globe. In practice, the vast majority of children placed in such institutions, or orphanages, are not orphans. Estimates differ by country, but some 80-98 per cent of children placed in orphanages have at least one living parent. Most children are placed in institutions because of poverty or disability. Children are also placed in institutions for lack of accessible healthcare, social support services or education in the community.

For both children and parents, the right to a family has long been recognised as a matter of international human rights law. Article 16 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) states that “family is the natural and fundamental group unit of society and is entitled to protection by society and the State.”

The Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) favours the protection of children to live with a family, but it does allow for the placement of children in “suitable institutions” when families are unavailable. The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) now creates stronger protections, requiring governments to ensure that all children receive the protection they need to live and grow up in a family.

Article 19 of the CRPD states that all people with disabilities have the right to live in the community with choices equal to others. Article 19 has been described as “a foundational platform for all other rights” because “a precondition for anyone to enjoy all their human rights is that they are within and among the community.” Article 19 is sweeping in its breadth and universal in its commitment to integration as it applies to all people with disabilities – no matter the type or severity of their disability.

The CRPD is stranded in a social model of disability rather than a medical or welfare model. A social model of disability, based on human rights issues, emphasises the fact that people with disabilities are holders of rights and not objects to be associated with charity.

Instead of allowing real or perceived impairment to hold a person back from exercising their rights or participating in society, this new anti-discrimination framework requires that society be made more accessible to bring about rights protection and full inclusion. Instead of looking to see whether a child is too disabled to live in society as part of a family (or whether a parent can keep his or her children), the CRPD requires society to become accessible by providing the support necessary to allow that child to live and grow up in a family.

The framework for legal enforcement using this social model of disability provides a more effective way of protecting both children and parents from denial of the right to a family.

Both in the developed and developing countries, poor and marginalised families are under pressure to give up their children because of economic demands and social stigma. It is obvious that most parents do not place their children in institutions eagerly; rather, they place them out of fear, trusting that they have no choice but to remove their children from their homes and place them in institutions.

Several other factors may contribute to the pressures on parents to give up their children. For example, deeply ingrained stigma against children with disabilities may bring shame onto an entire family with a disabled child. Also, parents of children with disabilities are told to place their children in institutions for necessary treatment and care.

Eric Rosenthal, executive director of Disability Rights International (DRI), states that despite strong international policies against institutions, there are many pressures on families, leading to new placement of children. The forces that lead to the break-up of families have, unfortunately, received support from misguided development and donor practices that support the institutionalisation of children. In many parts of the world, extensive charity aid and volunteer support create incentives for governments or private business to build new orphanages.

Placement of young children in institutions has been shown to be associated with abnormal brain development – increasing risks for emotional, cognitive and behavioural disorders. Research has shown that, in their first years, children learn to form emotional attachments with caregivers, and they may lose this ability if they do not have stable family members in their lives with whom they can form emotional attachments.

One large study among boys and girls from institutions in five African countries found that more than 50 per cent of children reported experiences of physical or sexual abuse. The most effective and cost effective approach to protecting children and avoiding any form of family break-up is to provide protection and support so that they can stay in their family or extended family.

In summary, the CRPD has created protections for the right to family. The vast majority of children now placed in institutions have parents who have never been given the support, opportunities or accommodation they need to keep their children. Governments are under an obligation to create the support needed for children to live in families and not in institutions, residential care or group homes.

Joshi is a human rights lawyer

A version of this article appears in print on September 04, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Pandemic and State: How is state accountable?

COVID-19 Global Lens The COVID-19 pandemic presents the world with a huge challenge: everyone and every area is affected, and the response has to be both quick and consorted. This pandemic may be primarily a health crisis for some states, but COVID-19 is also an education crisis, an employment an Read More...

Int’l Youth Day marked by holding virtual programmes

KATHMANDU, AUGUST 12 The International Youth Day was commemorated around the world today, including in Nepal, by organising various youth related events. In Nepal, the day was observed around the theme, ‘Youths’ Engagement for Employment Promotion and Environment Conservation’. The event Read More...

‘End political interference in BPKIHS’

DHARAN, AUGUST 12 Nepali Congress-aligned Tarun Dal and Nepal Student Union staged a demonstration in Dharan today seeking the fulfilment of demands, including a halt to the Senate meeting of BP Koirala Institute of Health and Sciences. Demonstrating in front of the institute’s main gate, th Read More...

Nawalparasi map

Paper mill in Nawalparasi resumes operation

NAWALPARASI, AUGUST 12 A paper factory at Madhyabindu Municipality in the district has resumed operation following a halt of two years. Established in 2018, the industry named Quality Paper Industries Pvt Ltd makes use of paper waste and local raw materials, said Suresh Kumar Gupta, chairperso Read More...

Kailali witnessing gradual loss of forests

GODAVARI, AUGUST 12 Forests are shrinking every year in Kailali due to increasing encroachment. The under-construction Rani-Jamara-Kulariya Irrigation Project, Khutiya-Dipayal Fast Track, Seti Highway and Postal Highway have contributed to loss of forests in the district. Deforestation in Bhaw Read More...

Female inmates of Nepalgunj prison sent to Bardiya and Dailekh

NEPALGUNJ, AUGUST 12 Following the confirmation of COVID-19 in some inmates, Nepalgunj prison administration in Banke has shifted its female inmates to other districts. At a time when concerns are being heard about the number of inmates exceeding the capacity of the prison, the prison administ Read More...

‘Manage uranium mines properly’

MYAGDI, AUGUST 12 Experts have drawn the government’s attention to lack of seriousness in managing uranium deposits discovered in different regions, including in Mustang and Chure. At a virtual interaction ‘Nuclear science and society’ organised by Nepal Russian Science Society in coordi Read More...

3 dead, 6 in hospital after train derails in Scotland

LONDON: Three people were killed and six others injured Wednesday when a passenger train derailed in northeast Scotland after heavy rain and flooding hit the area. The train driver was believed to be among the dead, British Transport Police said. The Rail, Maritime and Transport union said that t Read More...