Nepal | May 27, 2020

‘Japanese grant radars to cost CAAN dear’

Rajan Pokhrel
Share Now:
International terminal of Tribhuvan International Airport. Photo: TIA

International terminal of Tribhuvan International Airport. Photo: TIA

Kathmandu, September 29

While the Tribhuvan International Airport (TIA)-modernisation project under the aegis of Japan International Cooperation Agency is all set to commission airspace surveillance radars at the sole international airport and Bhattedanda (south of Kathmandu Valley) in a few months, the equipment has not only found to be unproven but also substantially overpriced, according to stakeholders.

Japanese NEC-supplied radars that the Civil Aviation Authority of Nepal (CAAN) received as grant worth Rs 906 million from the government of Japan in 2014 are also unlikely to meet mandatory technical requirements specified by the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO), a CAAN director shared.

ICAO requires the ground equipment to be of very high quality in terms of reliability, availability and integrity in order to ensure safety of flights. Besides, the radar systems must be capable of providing ‘safety nets’ that allow air traffic controllers to intervene in a timely manner when aircraft get within unsafe distances.

Though new radars are said to have been custom-built for Nepal and no identical facilities exist anywhere else, the high base price of the Japanese radar translates into higher spare parts cost in the equipment’s life cycle, said another CAAN director.

Interestingly, field-proven radar equipment with identical features have recently been acquired by many countries, including India, from European manufacturers at about one-third the price.

“It is here CAAN’s double standards come to light — on the one hand when CAAN floats tenders for sensitive aviation ground equipment, only suppliers with proven equipment are shortlisted, while on the other the safety philosophy gets unceremoniously chucked out of the window when grant is received,” he added.

It is virtually impossible to find a Japanese aviation equipment manufacturer winning open tenders abroad in comparison to the towering brands like Sony, Canon, and Toyota. It remains to be seen what liabilities the NEC radars will bring in the course of its service, another air traffic controller at TIA said, claiming that bid specifications were highly tailored to allow NEC to walk away with the trophy.

Even the Toshiba-supplied radar system currently in operation at the TIA lacked the minimum safe altitude warning safety nets from the very beginning and its painful lack was felt repeatedly in multiple crashes — Lufthansa Cargo Flight 8533 (1999), Necon Air flight (1999) and Buddha Air Beechcraft (2011).

Though the crashes were customarily attributed to crew error, the flight crew community still continues to blame “little or no assistance from ground” while the in-house investigation chose to overlook this important fact out of prejudice and ignorance, a ministry official said.

“Clearly, the new radar system is unlikely to meet the ICAO stipulations and will continue to bother air safety in the next decade as well,” a Nepal Airlines captain said, adding that the other identical grant-story is that of the MA-60 aircraft.


A version of this article appears in print on September 30, 2015 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Budget expectations

The government is all set to announce the budget for next fiscal year on Thursday and people involved in different sectors have various expectations. Amid this, The Himalayan Times spoke to a few tourism entrepreneurs who were not satisfied with the government’s policies and programmes to learn ab Read More...

File photo of the headquarters of the World Health Organisation in Geneva

WHO warns of 'second peak' in areas where COVID-19 declining

GENEVA: Countries where coronavirus infections are declining could still face an “immediate second peak” if they let up too soon on measures to halt the outbreak, the World Health Organization said on Monday. The world is still in the middle of the first wave of the coronavirus outbreak, WHO Read More...

15 including ward chair arrested in connection with Dalit youth's killing in Rukum

JAJARKOT: Police have arrested Dambar Bahadur Malla, ward chair of Chaurjahari Municipality-8 along with fifteen others in connection with the death of three youths in Rukum West. Three more are still missing while scores were injured in the incident. One of the youths, Nawaraj BK (21) of Bheri M Read More...

Australian PM calls for economic overhaul to fuel post-coronavirus recovery

Truce between employers and workers needed: PM Australia plots economic recovery Australia records just over 7,100 cases of COVID-19 Six cases from ship recently arrived from the UAE recorded SYDNEY: Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison on Tuesday called for an ideological truc Read More...

Nepal reports highest single-day spike, Covid-19 spreads to 46 districts

KATHMANDU: Health Ministry on Tuesday confirmed 90 new cases of coronavirus infection which has taken the Covid-19 case tally to 772 in the country. This is the highest single-day total recorded in Nepal, so far. The new infections were detected through tests carried out at the National Public Read More...

Prime Minister Oli calls an all-party meeting

KATHMANDU: Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli has called an all-party meeting today. The meeting has been called to discuss COVID-19 situation in the country, the government's response and the way ahead. PM Oli had addressed the nation yesterday regarding the same. In addition, it has been learnt th Read More...

NHRC calls for immediate legal action in Chaurjahari incident

KATHMANDU: National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has expressed its concern over the killing of Nawaraj BK, Tikaram Sunar and Ganesh Budha and the circumstances of three others missing in the incident in Soti of Rukum West. Issuing a press release on Tuesday, NHRC expressed its sadness over the Read More...

FIFA bans Haiti soccer official for sexual abuse allegations

ZURICH: The president of Haiti’s soccer federation has been suspended from the sport while under investigation for alleged sexual abuse of young women players at the national training center. FIFA said its ethics committee investigators removed Yves Jean-Bart from duty for 90 days. That interim Read More...