Nepal | June 03, 2020

Apex court’s constitutional bench ineffective, many cases pending

Ram Kumar Kamat
Share Now:

Kathmandu, October 28

The constitutional bench of the Supreme Court has not heard cases for weeks.

SC Co-spokesperson Nagendra Kalakheti said the constitutional bench would conduct hearings after Tihar when Justice Deepak Kumar Karki returned from leave. As per the rule, the constitutional bench cannot hear cases if any member of the five-member bench is absent.

There are 223 cases in the constitutional bench that comprises Chief Justice Om Prakash Mishra and four senior justices —   Deepak Raj Joshee, Cholendra Shamsher JB Rana, Deepak Kumar Karki and Kedar Prasad Chalise.

A source said the constitutional bench had not been able to conduct hearings because justices of the bench were not willing to sit on the panel with Justice Deepak Raj Joshee after he was rejected by the Parliamentary Hearing Committee for the post of chief justice on August 3.

Stalled hearings of the constitutional bench have led to the debate whether the bench ought to be restructured or whether a separate constitutional court should be formed to adjudicate constitutional cases.

Senior Advocate Chandra Kanta Gyawali said as the three tiers of government were implementing  federal laws and policies, there were chances of their laws contradicting the constitution or clashing with the jurisdiction of other governments. Hence, there should be a separate constitutional court to handle such cases. “The constitutional bench had quashed most of the cases it adjudicated and when it did entertain some cases, the quality of verdicts was very low,” he said.

Former SC justice Girish Chandra Lal and senior advocate Surendra Kumar Mahto, however, said the chief justice should have the power to assign alternative member to the constitutional bench in case of a member’s absence. “We need not look for an alternative to the constitutional bench because no other bench can be as impartial,” Lal said. “The judiciary is independent and whenever Nepal’s judiciary has faced any challenge, people have supported its independence, which is a good thing,” he argued.

Mahto said lack of efficacy of the constitutional bench was not enough ground to argue in favour of a constitutional court. He said political parties could appoint judges of the constitutional court on the basis of political quota and this could adversely impact adjudication of constitutional cases.

“But if the quality of justice delivered by the constitutional bench was not excellent, then we could think of forming a constitutional court,” he added.

A source said the SC had issued a mandamus writ telling the government to form constitutional bench through a collegium whereby the chief justice could recommend other justices whenever the need arose. “If a constitutional court is formed to settle constitutional cases, it may  kill the Supreme Court,” the source added.




A version of this article appears in print on October 29, 2018 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Timo Werner

Leipzig move into third spot with 4-2 win at Cologne

BERLIN: RB Leipzig reclaimed third place in the Bundesliga with an entertaining 4-2 victory at Cologne on Monday that put them firmly on course for a Champions League spot with five games left in the season. Leipzig's second win in their last six league games put them two points ahead of Bo Read More...

Yubaraj Khatiwada

Idea came from private schools: Khatiwada 

Education Minister Pokharel says he had no clue about it  Kathmandu, June 1 Finance Minister Yubaraj Khatiwada today said the proposal to make each private school responsible for improving education quality of at least one public school was brought in consensus with the private school owners. Read More...

Nepal's Constitution

JSP-Nepal registers private constitution amendment bill 

Kathmandu, June 1  Janata Samajwadi Party-Nepal today registered a private constitution amendment bill at the Parliament Secretariat seeking to change several provisions of the constitution to address the demands of Madhesis, Janajatis and other marginalised groups and communities. The J Read More...

Plan to evacuate Nepalis from abroad unveiled

KATHMANDU, JUNE 1 The government has released an 11-point action plan to bring back and manage citizens who have been affected by COV- ID-19 and want to return home. Deputy Prime Minister Ishwor Pokharel, who is also coordinator of the High-Level Coordination Committee for the Prevention and C Read More...

Quarantined people’s swabs collected after minor’s death 

Bajura, June 1  The swab samples of people kept in the quarantine facility at Dhuralsain Secondary School were collected after the death of a two-year-old child in Budhiganga Municipality, Bajura. Municipality Mayor Dipak Bikram Sha said the child, who was infected with COV- ID-19, died Read More...

Tourist standard hotels agree to government rate for quarantine

KATHMANDU, JUNE 1 Tourist standard member hotels of the Hotel Association Nepal are ready to provide quarantine service at Rs 2,000 per night with four meals a day. Disclosing member hotels’ decision today, Binayak Shah, first vice-president of HAN, said, “Our proposal was to charge Rs 3,0 Read More...

Ten new Covid-19 cases detected in Gandaki province, five each in Parbat and Syangja

POKHARA: As many as 10 new cases of coronavirus infection were detected in Gandaki Province on Tuesday morning, taking the provincial tally to 37. According to Gandaki Health Directorate, Parbat reported its first five confirmed cases while the other five hailed from Syangja. Among the infecte Read More...

12 migrants returning from India killed in accident

NEPALGUNJ, JUNE 1 Twelve persons were killed and 21 were injured when a vehicle carrying migrant workers returning from India met with an accident in Thuriya forest of Banke’s Rapti Sonari Rural Municipality last night. According to District Police Office, the accident occurred when a bus ca Read More...