Nepal | July 08, 2020

‘Bid to render national rights body toothless’


Ram Kumar Kamat
Share Now:

Kathmandu, April 14

The government has prepared a draft bill to amend the National Human Rights Commission Act proposing to give more discretionary power to the Attorney General on the rights body’s recommendations seeking prosecution of human rights violators.

The draft bill, which the government is preparing to register in the Parliament Secretariat, also proposes that the NHRC should make recommendations for filing court cases to the Office of the Attorney General.

The draft bill also states that if the AG tells the NHRC to conduct further probe into certain cases, the latter should comply with the order. The draft bill also states that the AG will have the authority to take a final call on filing cases against alleged human rights violators after analysing additional evidences submitted by the NHRC.

NHRC member Mohna Ansari said although the OAG had the power to not file certain cases in the court, it could not exercise such power in those cases where the NHRC, after completing full investigation, named the perpetrators and sought actions against them. She said the rights body had clearly recommended prosecution of human rights violators, particularly security forces. The spirit of the constitution is that NHRC’s recommendations should be acted upon, not ignored, she argued. Ansari also said the AG had authority to complete its own investigation in cases where the NHRC’s investigation might not be complete, particularly in identifying culprits. “We submit our reports to the Prime Minister’s Office and it will be wrong of the OAG to tell us to investigate further,” she said. “This draft bill,” Ansari argued, “Proposes to give unnecessary discretionary power to the Attorney General on the prosecution of cases.”

“We had forwarded an original draft to the government but we had not proposed these provisions in our draft,” she added, “If this draft becomes part of the NHRC Act, then human rights violators can easily get clean chits.”

She said the NHRC’s autonomy should be respected or else it would not be able  to function independently. “In Sri Lanka, security officials have to take clearance from their National Human Rights body to travel out of the country. This is a developing concept, which might be justified in other parts of the globe as well,” she added.

Human rights lawyer Mohan Kumar Karna said the existing NHRC law also authorised the AG to take a call on whether or not a case should be filed and that provision itself was flawed. “OAG is the government’s supporting wing and often human rights violations are committed by state authorities, so the OAG might not take an impartial decision if it is given sole authority to prosecute rights violations,” he said, adding that the law should be changed to either authorise the NHRC to file cases against rights violators or a separate autonomous prosecution body should be created.

The new bill, however, proposes to give the NHRC power to recommend more reparations for victims of human rights violation.

A version of this article appears in print on April 15, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Transport entrepreneurs deposit vehicle keys at banks in Pokhara

POKHARA: After failing to deposit the loan installment in the wake of extended lockdown, transport entrepreneurs handed-over vehicle keys to bank officials in Pokhara, on Monday. As many as ninety entrepreneurs associated with Prithvi Highway Bus Association handed over the keys to officials Read More...

Protecting the Economically Vulnerable Population

Kathmandu, July 7 What started as a health crisis in the form of the COVID-19 pandemic has now unfolded into a global economic and livelihood crisis. While the ubiquitous quarantines and lockdowns may have saved many lives and provided an additional benefit of  environmental improvement, their e Read More...

Tottenham Hotspur

Keane own goal gives Spurs win over Everton

Keane own goal gives Spurs win Mourinho secures 200th Premier League win Son and Lloris have halftime bust-up LONDON: An own goal by Michael Keane proved the difference as Tottenham Hotspur beat visitors Everton 1-0 in a dour clash on Monday to move up to eighth in the standings an Read More...

Actor Depp takes on UK tabloid in court battle over 'wife beater' claims

LONDON: Johnny Depp begins legal action against a British tabloid on Tuesday in a case that is likely to delve into the private lives of the Hollywood star, his ex-wife actress Amber Heard and a number of other well-known figures. Depp, the 57-year-old star of the "Pirates of the Caribbean" f Read More...

Yanqi-Nepal meet China’s bid to keep NCP united?

Kathmandu, July 6 China’s Ambassador to Nepal Hou Yanqi yesterday met Madhav Kumar Nepal, a senior leader of the ruling Nepal Communist Party (NCP), raising eyebrows as the meeting took place at a time when the internal rift within the NCP is heading towards a climax. Nepal’s former perma Read More...

Student union asks guardians not to pay school fees

BHOJPUR, JULY 6 Nepal Student Union, Bhojpur, has asked guardians not to pay any fees to schools for the lockdown period. At a time when PABSON and N-PAB- SON have asked guardians to pay fees to schools even for the lockdown period, NSU, Bhojpur, has asked guardians not to pay fees for the loc Read More...

175 suicide deaths in Sudurpaschim during lockdown

DADELDHURA, JULY 6 As many as 175 people have died by suicide during the nationwide lockdown in Sudurpaschim Province. Police said that suicide deaths have been reported from all nine districts of the province from March 24 till date. Police said suicide deaths were more common among males com Read More...

Indian side admits constructing embankment in Dasgaja area

RAUTAHAT, JULY 6 A joint survey team of Nepal and India gauged the Dasgaja area with a global positioning system which showed that the Indian side had constructed an embankment on 200 metres of encroached land in Dasgaja area. India had built a 10-metre tall embankment at Banjaraha of Ishnath Read More...