Nepal | July 07, 2020

CIAA’s selective approach slammed

• LALITA NIWAS LAND GRAB CASE

HIMALAYAN NEWS SERVICE
Share Now:

Kathmandu, February 8

The Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority filed charge sheet on Wednesday against 175 individuals for their role in the Lalita Niwas land grab case, but it did not indict two former prime ministers Madhav Kumar Nepal and Baburam Bhattarai saying the CIAA had no authority to question the legality of the collective decisions of their Cabinets.

The CIAA, however, indicted former ministers Bijay Kumar Gachhadar, Dambar Shrestha and Chandra Dev Joshi for forwarding proposals or signing documents related to the transfer of ownership of Lalita Niwas land.

Jurists, however, say the CIAA’s decision not to indict the two former prime ministers in the Lalita Niwas land grab case was against the spirit of the law.

Constitutional expert Bhimarjun Acharya said although the Cabinet had the power to frame policy that could not be questioned by the CIAA, the Cabinet should be held accountable if its decisions were mala fide. “Policy and decisions are two different things. While policies are about general things, decisions are about particular things and they come under the jurisdiction of the CIAA,” Acharya said and added that as Cabinet decisions transferred government land in the name of individuals and bogus land tenants, all Cabinet members whose consent effected the transfer should be held responsible.

Former justice Balaram KC said Section 4 (b) of the CIAA Act that barred the CIAA from questioning policy decisions of the Cabinet was against Article 239 of the constitution. “No office, not even the Cabinet, enjoys immunity if its decision endorses corrupt practice,” he argued.

KC said the judiciary and Parliament that enjoyed immunity for certain acts did not enjoy immunity if their actions endorsed corrupt practices and the same should be the case with the Cabinet. KC said the CIAA’s decision not to indict former prime ministers Nepal and Bhattarai was wrong. “The CIAA violated Article 18 or equality clause of the constitution by choosing not to indict the two former prime ministers and indicting some other former ministers,” he added.

KC also said the CIAA’s decision not to indict Nepal Communist Party (NCP)’s General Secretary Bishnu Paudel’s son Navin Paudel and Justice of Supreme Court Kumar Regmi for purchasing the controversial land just because they told the anti-graft body that they were ready to return the land plots to the government was wrong. “The CIAA could have said that it did not indict Paudel and Regmi because it did not find any evidence of their involvement in corruption, but how could the CIAA say that it was not indicting these people because they were ready to return the land plots?” he wondered.

KC said the CIAA’s selective approach in Lalita Niwas land grab case had raised question over the anti-graft body’s efficiency and its relevance.


A version of this article appears in print on February 09, 2020 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Hotel Soaltee refutes reports on premises being sealed, operations running says GM

KATHMANDU: Hotel Soaltee Crown Plaza Pvt Ltd has refuted media reports of the hotel being sealed after placing Nepal Airlines staff in quarantine, including the aircrew that tested positive for Covid-19. Talking to THT Online over the phone, the hotel's General Manager Upaul Majumdar said, "The Read More...

Nearly 40 suicide deaths reported amid COVID-19 lockdown in Tanahun

DAMAULI: Thirty-nine persons have died by suicide in the duration of the COVID-19 lockdown, which was imposed on March 24, in Tanahun district. According to Superintendent of Police (SP) Arun Poudel, of the 39 cases, in 35 persons died by hanging. Meanwhile, three cases of death were by intention Read More...

Transport entrepreneurs deposit vehicle keys at banks in Pokhara

POKHARA: After failing to deposit the loan installment in the wake of extended lockdown, transport entrepreneurs handed-over vehicle keys to bank officials in Pokhara, on Monday. As many as ninety entrepreneurs associated with Prithvi Highway Bus Association handed over the keys to officials Read More...

Protecting the Economically Vulnerable Population

Kathmandu, July 7 What started as a health crisis in the form of the COVID-19 pandemic has now unfolded into a global economic and livelihood crisis. While the ubiquitous quarantines and lockdowns may have saved many lives and provided an additional benefit of  environmental improvement, their e Read More...

Tottenham Hotspur

Keane own goal gives Spurs win over Everton

Keane own goal gives Spurs win Mourinho secures 200th Premier League win Son and Lloris have halftime bust-up LONDON: An own goal by Michael Keane proved the difference as Tottenham Hotspur beat visitors Everton 1-0 in a dour clash on Monday to move up to eighth in the standings an Read More...

Actor Depp takes on UK tabloid in court battle over 'wife beater' claims

LONDON: Johnny Depp begins legal action against a British tabloid on Tuesday in a case that is likely to delve into the private lives of the Hollywood star, his ex-wife actress Amber Heard and a number of other well-known figures. Depp, the 57-year-old star of the "Pirates of the Caribbean" f Read More...

Yanqi-Nepal meet China’s bid to keep NCP united?

Kathmandu, July 6 China’s Ambassador to Nepal Hou Yanqi yesterday met Madhav Kumar Nepal, a senior leader of the ruling Nepal Communist Party (NCP), raising eyebrows as the meeting took place at a time when the internal rift within the NCP is heading towards a climax. Nepal’s former perma Read More...

Student union asks guardians not to pay school fees

BHOJPUR, JULY 6 Nepal Student Union, Bhojpur, has asked guardians not to pay any fees to schools for the lockdown period. At a time when PABSON and N-PAB- SON have asked guardians to pay fees to schools even for the lockdown period, NSU, Bhojpur, has asked guardians not to pay fees for the loc Read More...