Nepal | June 03, 2020

Polygraph test inadmissible as evidence

• EVIDENCE ACT AMENDMENT BILL

Ram Kumar Kamat
Share Now:

Kathmandu, May 18

The new Evidence Act (Amendment) Bill being considered by the National Assembly intends to make the Evidence Act compatible with provisions of the newly enacted civil penal code, yet it doesn’t incorporate provisions related to polygraph test and the admissibility of declaration of the dying as evidence.

The bill incorporates provisions related to admissibility of audio-visuals, including video conference as evidence as provisioned by the new civil and penal code.

Senior Advocate Yadu Nath Khanal said detectives conducted polygraph tests on suspects in some cases in the past, but since the Evidence Act did not incorporate provisions related to polygraph test, they could not be taken as evidence even though the polygraph test is recognised as a valid method of collecting evidence in other countries.

The bill says a person’s statement just before death, could be admissible in the court, but the amendment bill does not add any details on admissibility of dying declaration as evidence.

Khanal said the bill should have clarified how the dying declaration could be deemed as evidence and whether or not it should be undersigned by the dying person or whether it could be an oral statement given to anybody.

“This bill fails to add details whether a dying declaration made to family members or persons other than competent authority should be taken as evidence,” Khanal said, adding that there was a subjudice case where the victim told the competent authority that her husband did not try to kill her, but the woman’s sister told the authorities that she had told her that her husband poured kerosene on her and set her ablaze. According to Khanal, the district court did not validate the statement of the victim’s sister as the victim’s dying declaration, but the high court overturned the district court’s decision.

The case is now subjudice at the Supreme Court.

Khanal said admissibility of dying declaration was based on the principle that ‘a dying person never lies’ but in today’s age when people do not care about religious virtues and sin, caution should be exercised while accepting dying declaration as evidence.

The bill stipulates that in some cases, parties may bring their own witnesses to the court on the very day the case is filed in the court.

This provision is aimed at avoiding risk of intimidation, coercion and enticement government witnesses could face from the accused or powerful people.

The bill stipulates that the court may examine other experts on a subject matter if the expert related to a particular case dies or fails to appear before the court to record his/her statement for any reason. This provision could increase success rate in government cases as the government had lost many cases due to experts’ failure to appear before the court to record their statements. Experts’ opinions are crucial to establish guilt in criminal cases.

The bill stipulates that any deal done through digital or electronic means may be admissible as evidence. Digital signatures will be deemed valid. A co-accused’s implicating statement can also be taken as evidence if the crime is confessed and others are implicated.


A version of this article appears in print on May 19, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Timo Werner

Leipzig move into third spot with 4-2 win at Cologne

BERLIN: RB Leipzig reclaimed third place in the Bundesliga with an entertaining 4-2 victory at Cologne on Monday that put them firmly on course for a Champions League spot with five games left in the season. Leipzig's second win in their last six league games put them two points ahead of Bo Read More...

Yubaraj Khatiwada

Idea came from private schools: Khatiwada 

Education Minister Pokharel says he had no clue about it  Kathmandu, June 1 Finance Minister Yubaraj Khatiwada today said the proposal to make each private school responsible for improving education quality of at least one public school was brought in consensus with the private school owners. Read More...

Nepal's Constitution

JSP-Nepal registers private constitution amendment bill 

Kathmandu, June 1  Janata Samajwadi Party-Nepal today registered a private constitution amendment bill at the Parliament Secretariat seeking to change several provisions of the constitution to address the demands of Madhesis, Janajatis and other marginalised groups and communities. The J Read More...

Plan to evacuate Nepalis from abroad unveiled

KATHMANDU, JUNE 1 The government has released an 11-point action plan to bring back and manage citizens who have been affected by COV- ID-19 and want to return home. Deputy Prime Minister Ishwor Pokharel, who is also coordinator of the High-Level Coordination Committee for the Prevention and C Read More...

Quarantined people’s swabs collected after minor’s death 

Bajura, June 1  The swab samples of people kept in the quarantine facility at Dhuralsain Secondary School were collected after the death of a two-year-old child in Budhiganga Municipality, Bajura. Municipality Mayor Dipak Bikram Sha said the child, who was infected with COV- ID-19, died Read More...

Tourist standard hotels agree to government rate for quarantine

KATHMANDU, JUNE 1 Tourist standard member hotels of the Hotel Association Nepal are ready to provide quarantine service at Rs 2,000 per night with four meals a day. Disclosing member hotels’ decision today, Binayak Shah, first vice-president of HAN, said, “Our proposal was to charge Rs 3,0 Read More...

Ten new Covid-19 cases detected in Gandaki province, five each in Parbat and Syangja

POKHARA: As many as 10 new cases of coronavirus infection were detected in Gandaki Province on Tuesday morning, taking the provincial tally to 37. According to Gandaki Health Directorate, Parbat reported its first five confirmed cases while the other five hailed from Syangja. Among the infecte Read More...

12 migrants returning from India killed in accident

NEPALGUNJ, JUNE 1 Twelve persons were killed and 21 were injured when a vehicle carrying migrant workers returning from India met with an accident in Thuriya forest of Banke’s Rapti Sonari Rural Municipality last night. According to District Police Office, the accident occurred when a bus ca Read More...