Nepal | June 07, 2020

Crippled commissions: Victims’ long wait for justice

Ram Dayal Rakesh
Share Now:

Even 12 years after the signing of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement, which ended the decade-long civil war in the country, conflict victims are still awaiting justice just as two transitional justice bodies drag their feet

Illustration: Ratna Sagar Shrestha/THT

The Commission of Investigation on Enforced Disappearance Persons (CIEDP) and Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), constituted to deal with cases related to the decade-long civil war, have in the last four years managed to accomplish only a little. They have largely failed to do anything substantial to console the conflict victims. Around 66,000 complaints have been registered with both the commissions, and most of them are against the top party leaders.

As the two commissions remain hamstrung by various factors, including lack of fund and human resources, transitional justice is in jeopardy even 12 years after the signing of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA) that ended the decade-long war.

The problem basically arises from the appointment (of officials) process. The TRC and CIEDP officials have been appointed on party quotas. So there are concerns whether they are unwilling to work towards completing the transitional justice process. “Justice delayed is justice denied” is a common saying, so the delay has stoked fears among conflict victims whether they would ever get justice. Countless war victims still don’t feel comfortable sharing their grievances, for they fear retribution, and in the meantime they feel there is no guarantee that their grievances would be addressed.  They still lack information on the difference between applying for relief and giving testimony for truth, justice and reparation.

Many victims have not been able to register complaints. There are others who have no updates on the transitional justice process. For example, son of Bechan Mandal of Godaita Municipality of Sarlahi was killed brutally in broad daylight in a sugarcane field during the conflict. There was no proper coordination between government institutions and civil society networks for informing the victims and their relatives at local levels.

Some of the victims were not allowed to register their complaints at the local peace committees. Many victims did not submit their testimony because they thought they might be asked to return the interim relief they had received earlier. When the TRC and CIEDP were first instituted back in 2015, nine years after the signing of the CPA, they had a two-year mandate to complete the transitional justice process. With their term extended until February 2019, the two commissions now have little time in their hands. Neither the civil society nor the conflict victims are hopeful that they would be able to complete their tasks.

And recently there is a new twist in the tale. Conflict victims have demanded that a high-level mechanism be set up to create a conducive environment for the transitional justice process by bringing all the stakeholders, including political parties, security agencies and the victims, together.

Conflict victims last month adopted “Conflict Victims’ Charter” demanding that a document of common consensus on transitional justice be drafted by the to-be-formed mechanism
with the participation and consent of conflict victims, and existing policies and laws be amended or rewritten on the basis of the document.

“The commission(s) to be established thereafter must be impartial, independent, empowered and autonomous, with the goal of ending impunity and ensuring lasting peace through a transitional justice process that is transparent, gender sensitive, inclusive and participatory,” read the charter. It has also warned that the conflict victims would seek “alternative recourse to justice” if terms of the two commissions are extended under the existing circumstances. Furthermore, conflict victims have arrived at consensus that truth-seeking, justice and reparation for victims, prosecution and punishment for perpetrators, institutional reform, end to impunity and reconciliation — the core values of transitional justice — must be taken into account while dealing with war-era cases.

They are also not in favour of blanket amnesty to anyone for any heinous crime. They have also insisted that reconciliation must happen only with the independent and informed consent of the victims. “Amnesty and reconciliation are not acceptable
in the case of serious violation of human rights,” they have said.

This shows conflict victims are fed up with the interminable wait for justice. They also claim that the laws governing these two commissions were formed without their consent.

Conflict victims have waited for too long and the political leadership seems to be unwilling to address their concerns. If the government continues to refuse to listen to their genuine grievances and address them, they will be forced to seek alternative recourse to justice. They are already making up their minds to reach out to the international forum to seek justice.

Nepal’s peace process has been time and again hailed by the political leadership as home-grown and exemplary. But until conflict victims get justice, the peace process will remain incomplete. This will tarnish the country’s image in the international arena.

Given this scenario, the two commissions formed with the good intention of delivering justice to conflict victims have overall failed. There is little hope of justice from these two crippled commissions now. That said, conflict victims cannot be left in a state of limbo. Justice must be ensured to them.


A version of this article appears in print on December 21, 2018 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

15 yrs on, Bandarmudhe blast victims still await justice

CHITWAN, JUNE 5 Fifteen years have passed since the infamous Bandarmudhe bomb blast, but the victims of the incident are still awaiting justice. The bomb blast carried out by the then rebelling CPN Maoist on a passenger bus at Madi of southern Chitwan had taken the lives of 38 people, leaving Read More...

michael jordan

Jordan giving $100 million for racial equality, justice

CHARLOTTE: Michael Jordan and the Jordan Brand are giving $100 million to organizations dedicated to promoting racial equality and social justice. In a joint statement Friday on social media, Jordan and the Jordan Brand said money will be paid over 10 years with the goal of “ensuring racial equ Read More...

Buffalo officers suspended in shoving of 75-year-old man

BUFFALO: Dozens of Buffalo police officers stepped down from the department's crowd control unit Friday, objecting to the suspensions of two fellow officers in the shoving of a 75-year-old protester who fell and cracked his head. Prosecutors were investigating the encounter captured by a TV crew Read More...

Swab collection halted for five days in Sudurpaschim

DHANGADI, JUNE 5 Sudurpaschim Province has halted collection of throat swab samples for five days. Province Health Directorate Office Dhangadi said it had stopped collecting swab samples as more than 1,000 swabs were on hold and left to be tested. “We have more than 1,000 swab samples yet Read More...

Hollywood star Leonardo DiCaprio dedicated to ending disenfranchisement of Black America

KATHMANDU: Joining a growing list of Hollywood celebrities donating to organisations working for equal rights during the 'Black Lives Matter' protests in the US, actor Leonardo DiCaprio too has announced donations while urging others to take action. Taking to Twitter on June 5, the Once Upon A T Read More...

NAC chartered flight to Narita scheduled for Sunday

KATHMANDU: Nepal Airlines Corporation (NAC) has scheduled a chartered flight for Narita in Japan on Sunday. The flight has been scheduled to operate on the request of a travel agency. In a press release issued by the NAC, on Thursday, it stated that the Nepali Embassy in Japan has no role in o Read More...

K-pop boyband BTS rank 48 on Forbes world's highest-paid celebs list

KATHMANDU: Forbes has named BTS as one of Top 50 highest-paid celebrities in the world on its latest annual list out on June 4. The K-pop band is placed at 47 on the list with an estimated $50 million pretax income. Soompi quotes Forbes as stating, “The K-pop supergroup grossed $170 million o Read More...

K-pop SHINee's Taemin readying for July comeback

KATHMANDU: Taemints and Shawols can look forward to Taemin's comeback in July. After SPOTV News reported that SHINee's maknae Taemin would be releasing a new album in July, Soompi says that SM Entertainment, SHINee's label, confirmed the news. “Taemin is preparing for a July comeback. Beginn Read More...