Nepal | November 30, 2020

EDITORIAL: Uphold press freedom

The Himalayan Times
Share Now:

We cannot imagine a democratic society without freedom of speech and free flow of information

Some lawmakers from the ruling and opposition benches have registered amendments on a number of clauses of the Right to Privacy Bill tabled in Parliament. The Bill has drawn flaks from various walks of life, including the Federation of Nepali Journalists, the main opposition Nepali Congress and the intelligentsia. The Bill has inserted restrictive measures against mediapersons and the media outlets from making public information detrimental to public post holders. The Nepal Law Commission proposed the draft of the Bill to protect individuals’ privacy, proposing a jail sentence up to three years or a fine up to Rs 30,000 or both for violating individual’s right to privacy. Under the right to privacy, an individual’s citizenship certificate, passport, academic qualification, voter identity card, driving licence, bank accounts, debit and credit card, cheques and drafts, details about immovable property and securities cannot be made public unless required by law. The mediapersons cannot make public of such details of any serving or retired public officers even if there is a reasonable doubt that public office holders or government officials committed unlawful acts or are trying to commit unlawful acts.

The lawmakers seeking amendments to the Bill have also sought immunity for the mediapersons and photographers while reporting or commenting on issues of public importance and inappropriate conduct of serving and retired public post holders. The lawmakers have also sought amendment to a clause that restricts journalists from taking record of communications or conversations of public importance. An amendment proposal has also been registered seeking definition of public post holders as those “who are supposed to exercise public authority or discharge any responsibility or duty”. The Bill has to be enacted by Parliament by September 19, the deadline set by the constitution.

The Bill has some draconian provisions with harsh punishments. If the Bill is passed as proposed by the Nepal Law Commission, Nepal’s press freedom could go back to the dark ages and, it also will not be in conformity with the new constitution that has guaranteed full press freedom. We cannot imagine a democratic society without freedom of speech and free flow of information. If someone is holding the public position, s/he should not get immunity from public scrutiny though his/ her right to privacy should be fully respected as long as they do nothing wrong. It should also be noted that right to press freedom is not for the mediapersons. Press freedom is exercised by the mediapersons—who are the only medium of communication with the people—to make the general public well-informed about the functioning of the state and its machinery and other myriad issues related to larger public interests. If press freedom is curtailed in the name of right to privacy, the state machinery will become more and more autocratic and people will be deprived of right to information on right time. Thomas Jefferson, a principal author of the Declaration of Independence, once famously wrote he would prefer “newspapers without government” over “government without newspapers”. His statement sums up the importance of media freedom in a democratic society. Let’s hope our lawmakers will not curtail the press freedom while enacting the privacy bill.

Death in Qatar

Qatar is one of the favoured destinations among Nepali migrant workers. As the Gulf nation gears up for the 2022 World Cup, it is engaged in massive construction of stadiums where workers from Nepal and other countries land jobs. But they are often forced to work in life-threatening conditions. In a recent case, 23-year-old Tej Narayan Tharu from Morang, died on August 14 at one of the proposed venues for 2022 tournament. He is said to have fallen to death while performing access platform related work. But sadly, Nepali officials seem to be in the dark about the incident.

Nepal has drawn world attention time and again for the high number of deaths of Nepalis in the Gulf countries and Malaysia. Though some efforts have been made—in terms of helping the family bring the bodies and providing compensation—Nepal does not seem to have been able to maintain a strong mechanism to respond to the situations Nepali workers face. While there is a compensation policy in place, families of victims are often caught in the red tape. It’s the responsibility of the state to safeguard its citizens at home and abroad.


A version of this article appears in print on September 05, 2018 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

National Covid-19 tally reaches 231,978 on Sunday with 1255 fresh infections

KATHMANDU: The countrywide Covid-19 tally reached 231,978 as 1255 additional infections emerged on Sunday. The capital hosts the highest amount of active cases which, on an average, reports half of the daily reported live infections. Likewise, 1404 people who were earlier infected with the vir Read More...

25 more fatalities registered today; Covid-19 death-toll advances to 1,479

KATHMANDU: Twenty-five more fatalities were reported in the last 24 hours with which Nepal’s Covid-19 death-tally has now advanced to 1,479. Meanwhile, 1,255 fresh coronavirus cases as reported today took the nationwide coronavirus case count to 231,978. Over 1.4 million deaths from the dis Read More...

2020's last lunar eclipse to be witnessed on November 30

KATHMANDU: The last lunar eclipse of 2020, a Penumbral one in which the moon passes through Earth's outer shadow, is on November 30. A penumbral lunar eclipse is less alike to other eclipses and much like a full moon except the moon will be a shade darker. This eclipse will be visible from muc Read More...

Kathmandu Valley records 548 new cases on Sunday

KATHMANDU: The three districts of Kathmandu Valley reported a total of 548 new cases of coronavirus infection on Sunday. Of the new cases, 244 are females and 304 are males. As many as 422 cases were recorded in Kathmandu district while Lalitpur and Bhaktapur reported 61 and 65 cases respectiv Read More...

Afghanistan car bombing kills at least 30 security force personnel

KABUL: A car bombing in the Afghanistan's central province of Ghazni killed at least 30 Afghan security force members on Sunday, officials said, and casualties could increase given the intensity and location of the blast. Baz Mohammad Hemat, director of the provincial hospital in Ghazni, said Read More...

Smith hits second straight ton as Australia post 389-4 vs India

SYDNEY: Steve Smith led an imperious display from Australia's top-order batsmen with his second straight century as the hosts piled on a massive 389 for four against India's listless bowlers in the second one-day international in Sydney on Sunday. The match followed a script similar to Fr Read More...

Chinese Defence Minister calls on PM Oli

KATHMANDU: Chinese Defence Minister Wei Fenghe has called on Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli at the latter's official residence in Baluwatar. The State Councilor and Defence Minister of China arrived here this morning on a one day official visit. Fenghe had asserted that his short visit to Ne Read More...

Bayern made to sweat for 3-1 win at Stuttgart

STUTTGART: Kingsley Coman scored one goal and set up another as Bayern Munich came from a goal down to beat VfB Stuttgart 3-1 on Saturday and stay top of the Bundesliga. It was the seventh consecutive game that Bayern, who face Atletico Madrid in the Champions League next week, conceded a goa Read More...