Nepal | August 13, 2020

Opinion: When floods strike, it’s the poor who suffer

Dipendra Gautam
Share Now:

The 2017 and 2019 monsoon floods in Nepal dilapidated many settlements, especially in the southern part of the country and across the riverbanks in the middle and high mountains. The 1993 and 2008 floods had already provided some lessons that should not have been forgotten to downscale the loss of lives and property. The notorious floods of 2017 and 2019 were in many aspects the same as those of 1993 and 2008. The key question here is whether Nepal is learning from the destruction and losses and acting proactively to counteract the multi-faceted challenges of floods.

Traditionally, floods used to be dealt in isolation – just as a hydrologic and hydraulic phenomenon with little to sparse influence on other dimensions. Since the challenge is multi-faceted, multi-disciplinary approaches are a must to deal with it. To this end, our research group recently conducted an interdisciplinary research on flood hazard mapping and flood vulnerability analysis of wattle and daub houses that are dominant across the river banks in the southern parts of the country and are mostly constructed by the people dwelling in informal to slum and squatter settlements.

The paper entitled ‘Catchment-scale flood hazard mapping and flood vulnerability analysis of residential buildings: The case of Khando River in eastern Nepal’, published in the prestigious Journal of Hydrology: Regional Studies, summarises that the conventional understanding of flood damage to residential buildings is too conservative and needs a serious revision.

Unlike reinforced concrete and brick or stone houses, which are more robust than wattle and daub houses, floods can easily sweep away such houses leaving no impression of a settlement behind. We considered the notorious Khando River that passes through Saptari district in eastern Nepal to assess the impact of flooding and estimate the flood itself at various time intervals.

Due to grave sediment transport and channel shifting, the flooding pattern in most non-perennial rivers, such as the Khando, should be treated rather probabilistically. Over the decades, meandering river and channel shifting have made thousands of people homeless and caused enormous losses. The analysis outlined that even for a low return interval, the flooding would be really high. This may have feeble impact in areas without settlements and farms, but when the flood takes its course via settlements, then most of the wattle and daub houses will suffer beyond repair.

Due to lack of adequate foundation and superstructure strength, even an inundation of 0.1 meter may initiate damage to wattle and daub construction. Meanwhile, if the inundation is 1 metre in depth, most of the houses that belong to economically deprived people would lose regular functionality. However, no efforts have been made to improve the conventional low-cost housing system to morph as a cost-effective housing solution that could sustain at least moderate floods.

The scene is tumultuous as no governing mechanism and capacity building have penetrated most of such settlements, and housing construction lacks any form of technicality. Thus, they just dip the bamboo for around a foot. That would be easily ejected by the eroding flood.

Nepal is categorised as the 30th most hazard-prone country in terms of flood hazards by the United Nations Development Programme, and the intertwining impacts of climate change related phenomenon together with the vulnerable settlements may lead to losses beyond imagination if immediate actions are not deployed.

From awareness to easy access to information related to flood occurrence, efforts could shift the paradigm effectively by lowering the damage and slicing the impacts of the losses. The first effort that could be instrumental is capacity building in informal and slum and squatter settlements by hands-on trainings for improved construction. Thereafter, some tech-savvy simulations and models could be developed to optimise the construction system.

Furthermore, river channel management and protection work may play a vital role in protecting communities but may be uneconomic as Nepal has a number of such notorious rivers and greater number of economically deprived communities across the river banks.

Flood hazard mapping and map-based settlement planning and development may also provide a rational basis for resettlement of vulnerable communities; however, river channel shifting is quite frequent and may alter the hazard maps. So, river management and development of flood resilient construction systems may be a wiser solution.

The vicious impacts of flooding range from visible damage to societal challenges. And, housing is undoubtedly the most important aspect of human life to stay safe despite the natural challenges. Lessons of historical and recent floods are valuable assets together with the scientific research findings as they germinate avant garde solutions for effectively managing flood hazards and its multi-faceted challenges.

The cyclic phenomenon of reconstructing the same houses every year will not alter the paradigm, rather pragmatic solutions based on thorough understanding of the benign steps is a must. Unlike most of the natural hazards, floods are better managed if checked on time. Flood disasters are well-known in Nepal but saving lives and property is unheard of. The status quo in construction systems and state-of-the art knowledge seemingly forget the impacts and countermeasures of flooding, especially in buildings. The resolution right before the monsoon of 2020 should be to protect the lives and property in informal and slum and squatter settlements as when floods strike, the perils of the poor multiply.

Gautam is researcher in multi-hazards impacts on structures and infrastructure

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Coronavirus vaccine: Russia ahead on track, who is next?

KATHMANDU: Over 150 vaccines are being developed and tested around the world to stop the COVID-19 pandemic, of which 28 are in human clinical trials, according to the World Health Organization. Meanwhile, Russia has become the first country in the world to grant regulatory approval to a COVID-19 Read More...

Nepal COVID-19 Update: 484 new cases, 64 recoveries, eight deaths reported Wednesday

KATHMANDU: Nepal’s Health Ministry, in its regular press briefing, shared the latest updates on coronavirus contagion from across the country, and government’s response to the health crisis. As of today, 473,179 tests through Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) method have been carried out wh Read More...

Nepal sees highest Covid-19 death toll in a single day; eight deaths reported Wednesday

KATHMANDU: Nepal has logged eight more Covid-19 related fatalities in the last 24 hours. This is the highest single day death-toll from the coronavirus infection recorded so far. Spokesperson at Ministry of Health and Population, Dr Jageshwar Gautam, informed public about the eight cases of fatal Read More...

Worldwide coronavirus cases cross 20.41 million, death toll over 742,000

At least 20,414,289 people have been reported to be infected by the novel coronavirus globally and 742,207 people have died, a Reuters tally showed.  Infections have been reported in more than 210 countries and territories since the first cases were identified in China in December 2019.  Read More...

Pandemic and State: How is state accountable?

COVID-19 Global Lens The COVID-19 pandemic presents the world with a huge challenge: everyone and every area is affected, and the response has to be both quick and consorted. This pandemic may be primarily a health crisis for some states, but COVID-19 is also an education crisis, an employment an Read More...

Kathmandu valley's coronavirus cases hit another record; 138 new infections reported today

KATHMANDU: Kathmandu valley, yet again, recorded the highest single-day Covid-19 cases on Wednesday with 109 new cases in Kathmandu district, 21 in Lalitpur, and eight in Bhaktapur. A total of 138 new infections were reported today from inside the valley. With today’s additions, active case Read More...

Dhading district

One week prohibitory order issued in Dhading to contain COVID-19 spread

DHADING: A prohibitory order has been decreed in Dhading's headquarters Dhadingbesi and its peripheral areas with the increase in COVID-19 transmission, since Wednesday. In an attempt to curb further potential spread of the highly contagious infection, the District Administration Office took a de Read More...

Bollywood actor Sanjay Dutt diagnosed with lung cancer

KATHMANDU: Bollywood actor Sanjay Dutt, who was rushed to hospital in Mumbai after complaining of chest discomfort and breathlessness, has been diagnosed with lung cancer. The news was confirmed by Bollywood's trade analyst and film industry insider Komal Nahta on August 11 night, according to I Read More...