Nepal | November 25, 2020

Spare all kinds of rods: They are ineffective

Dronashish Neupane
Share Now:

While cases of outright physical torture like beating with sticks, slapping, pulling the ears or making them stand for academic dishonesty or misbehaviour might have declined, emotional punishments like scolding, abusing and humiliating are still practised

Illustration: Ratna Sagar Shrestha/THT

A colleague recently shared an incident concerning her 11-year-old child, which as a teacher was as shocking for me to hear as it must surely have been to her as a parent when she first discovered it. Ironically, the child’s habit of spending too much time on her tab was conveyed to her class teacher by none other than the parent herself with the mistaken hope of bringing about a desired change in the child through the former’s help. What followed apparently was the child being called out the next day and getting slapped by the very teacher before her classmates! What is even more shocking is that the teacher is said to have kept slapping without saying anything to the child. This happened in the very first period of the day. Badly hurt, less by the slap and more by the humiliation, the child upon returning home cried herself to sleep. Apparently, the child now is highly fearful of the teacher.

Anyone who has undergone similar experience at school can imagine what she must have felt all day at school following the incident. What is equally shocking here, if not more, is that the child didn’t even know what she was being punished for. Voices of those citing the need for corporal punishment gets overwhelmingly drowned out these days, but every now and then incidents like these do come to the fore, and views along the lines of ‘sometimes you do need to use the rod’ are still heard in school staff rooms. Never having used such tactics ever in my life as a teacher, I am not aware of the fruits of it, if there’s any at all, but it is hard to imagine how a child would get back on track or show positive behavioural change through slaps, sticks, jibes and sarcasm.

In Nepal, the new Children’s Act, 2018 has criminalised corporal punishment of children, making it the first country in South Asia and 54th country in the world to do so. Section 66 (d) of the Act criminalises physical and mental torture or degrading treatment of children either at home, school or other places. While cases of outright physical torture like beating with sticks, slapping, pulling the ears or making them stand for academic dishonesty or misbehaviour might have declined, emotional punishments like scolding, abusing and humiliating are still practised, even in some so-called progressive schools, which have mushroomed in Nepal in recent times. And the reason why the practice continues despite the policy reform of 2018 may be attributed largely to schools lacking a clear policy on the issue as well as poorly trained and unprofessional teachers.

Not long ago, a 10th grader being bashed black and blue by the very principal of his school was reported in the media with no shortage of sympathisers for the latter in the wake of the incident. Even the kids in their early childhood are not spared on the back of a much flawed and self righteous maxim like ‘It’s important to nip the misconduct in the bud.’ It is not very hard to see why such punitive measures are the most favoured course of action for many teachers: school management and even parents give tacit support to the use of such tactics which are as ineffective and short-lived as they are detrimental to children’s learning.

Additionally, it is convenient for teachers to go for an impulsive shout or a sarcastic remark if not physical abuse because the other way takes time and patience. Logical consequences are aimed at helping children develop self control and provide them with an opportunity to learn from their mistakes as opposed to punishment, which aims but miserably fails at correcting the child through external control and fear.

The change in the policy regarding corporal punishment will achieve very little if the real actors on the ground, that is, the school administrations and teachers do not comply with it. As far as compliance is concerned, it should also not be simply taken as being cognizant of the changed policy only at a philosophical level or being permissive towards whatever the students do. Adequate level of training on a periodic basis about the logical consequences for various classroom scenarios needs to be imparted to bring about that paradigm shift in teachers, many of whom may themselves have grown up receiving corporal punishment. The experience of working with middle school students informs this writer that children of that age group require constant reminders and feedback for any of their undesired behaviour and that snapping and scolding barely works.

Teachers can start with setting consequences that are related to the action and delivered respectfully as it is a common practice to mete out totally irrelevant punishments like cutting out their recess or extra-curricular time for just about anything that they do wrong in the classroom. Cutting out the recess time can indeed be a logical consequence but only if the child has chosen to misbehave with others during that time. A teacher sitting down with the same child later and reminding him/her of the expected recess time behaviour could help the situation further. But do the teachers have time for it? If making students responsible for their actions and allowing them a supportive environment to learn from their mistakes are our goals, logical consequences are the teachers’ best bet.

Neupane is with Kathmandu University

A version of this article appears in print on May 21, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

National Examinations Board (NEB) Nepal

Grade XII exams begin today

KATHMANDU, NOVEMBER 23 National Examinations Board is all set to conduct the examination of Grade XII from tomorrow amidst the coronavirus crisis. Regular examination will be held until December 1. The NEB, after a long halt, had devised a new protocol allowing students to take the exam for Read More...

Burnley get first win with Wood strike against Palace

BURNLEY: Burnley secured their first win of the Premier League season as Chris Wood's eighth minute goal was enough to earn a 1-0 victory over Crystal Palace at Turf Moor on Monday. The result moves Burnley out of the bottom three up to 17th place, on five points from eight matches, wh Read More...

Demonstration in Gaur enters second week

RAUTAHAT, NOVEMBER 23 The sit-in and demonstration launched by local residents in front of Gaur Customs Office demanding that the border entry point, which has been closed for months, has completed its second week today. The sit-in-cum-demonstration had started from November 10 at the init Read More...


Those availing free PCR test to be disqualified from insurance

KATHMANDU, NOVEMBER 23 Kathmandu Metropolitan City Mayor Bidya Sundar Shakya had announced two days ago that the metropolis would conduct free PCR tests for coronavirus. While the mayor’s announcement is unlikely to be implemented anytime soon, it is learnt that people undergoing such free P Read More...

Border closure affecting marriages

NEPALGUNJ, NOVEMBER 23 Twenty-year-old Rina Ali Shaiyad’s marriage has been stalled for months now. Scheduled to tie the knot with a man across the border in April, her plan went awry owing to the lockdown enforced by the government in the face of the coronavirus pandemic. As uncertainty Read More...

Editorial: Rape is unreconcilable

The new provision in the ordinance will discourage village leaders from settling rape cases outside the court of law The council of ministers on Sunday took the decision to issue an ordinance by making amendments to three laws related to Criminal Code-2074, the Act related to Senior Citizens-2063 a Read More...

Respect farming: No food, no life

Focussing on the bottom-up approach in extension can somehow develop the feeling of ownership among farmers. The Nepali agriculture extension system is showing slow progress because there’s a lack of coordination between the different units working for the same sector “ What do you want to be i Read More...

Dying language

Some time ago the media lamented on the precarious fate of the Magaraa language in Province 1. With over 125 dialects and languages, it is hardly surprising that many of them will become extinct for lack of use for several reasons, including domination of the Nepali and English languages. The Mao Read More...