Nepal | September 22, 2020

Govt should have built Budhigandaki utilising own resources: Experts

Himalayan News Service
Share Now:

Decision to award the 1,200MW project to a Chinese company has essentially blocked the chances of benefit sharing with India

Janardan Sharma_Lv Zexiang_Budhigandaki Hydropower Project

Energy Minister Janardan Sharma and Lv Zexiang, president of CGGC Beijing, exchanging the MoU that was signed to develop Budhigandaki Hydropower Project, in Kathmandu, on Sunday, June 04, 2017. Photo: THT

Kathmandu, July 26

Amidst the rising controversy of the previous government’s last minute decision to award Budhigandaki Project to a Chinese company — China Gezhouba Group Corporation (CGGC) — experts have said that the country should have stuck to building the project through its own resources while sharing irrigation benefits with India.

“As the southern neighbour India could reap huge irrigation benefits from the project, the government should have held a dialogue with India regarding the irrigation benefits and flood control measures to be put in place during the development of the multipurpose project,” said former chief secretary Dwarikanath Dhungel.

Speaking in the meeting of the Public Accounts Committee of the Legislature-Parliament here today, Dhungel said
that around one-third of the storage of Budhigandaki project would remain as dead stock. Of around four billion cubic metres of total storage, only 2.5 billion cubic metres would be utilised for electricity generation, as per Dhungel.

“Nepal has only around 55,000 hectares of arable land in lower riparian Nawalparasi and Chitwan districts, where the water from the Budhigandaki project can be used for irrigation.” However, the storage project could cater to the irrigation demand for around 700,000 hectares of land in India and thus, sharing the irrigation benefits with India could have been crucial, according to Dhungel.

However, experts have said that the previous government’s decision to award the 1,200-megawatt Budhigandaki Project to the Chinese company has essentially blocked the chances of benefit sharing with India.

The previous government had signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with CGGC to award the engineering, procurement, construction and financing (EPCF) contract, violating the established principle of global bidding, alleged Ratna Sansar Shrestha, an energy expert. “We have witnessed completion of many projects like the Kaligandaki and
Bhotekoshi projects, among others, at a much lower cost than that estimated for Budhigandaki.”

Shrestha was also sceptical of the Chinese company developing the project. “Even if CGGC moves ahead to develop the project, it will likely inflate the cost of the project heavily,” he claimed, adding that Chinese companies are notorious for inflating the cost of the projects.

Earlier, a French Company — Tractebel Engineering (France) — had estimated it would cost around Rs 260 billion to build the project.

The government had already initiated land compensation distribution to the residents of project-affected area. Land price has been fixed at Rs 525,000 to Rs 835,000 per ropani and the government has to acquire around 57,000 ropanis of land for the project. However, the government has yet to fix the land price in semi-urban areas like Arughat, Khahare of Gorkha district. Land compensation of the project is expected to hover around Rs 90 billion.

As per the agreement with CGGC, the government has to bear the cost of land compensation of the project-affected area.

Shailendra Guragain, president of Independent Power Producers’ Association Nepal (IPPAN), said that the government had started feasibility study of the Budhigandaki project around 25 years ago, but it has yet to move forward towards construction.

As the country has garnered the experience of developing 456-megawatt Upper Tamakoshi utilising its own resources, Budhigandaki could also be developed with the same model, he said. “We have to initiate some storage projects like Budhigandaki at the earliest to cater to the energy demand of the future,” Guragain said.

Public Accounts Committee has taken the view from the experts on Budhigandaki deal before summoning the concerned government officials involved in the deal, according to Dor Prasad Upadhyay, chairman of PAC.

A version of this article appears in print on July 27, 2017 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Photo Gallery: Rohingya refugees receive relief in Kapan amid COVID-19 crisis

KATHMANDU, SEPTEMBER 21 Hiteri Foundation provided food relief packages to long-persecuted Rohingya Muslim refugees here in Kapan on Sunday, September 20. More than 175 families are taking shelter in Kapan after entering Nepal following a mass exodus from their native Myanamar. Also seen in pi Read More...

In Pictures: Lalitpur school provides internet facility to students sans access

Lalitpur, September 21 Teachers take online classes with internet facility provided by school at the empty classroom of Shree Rudrayanee Secondary School in Khokana, Lalitpur on Monday, September 21, 2020. The School has facilitated internet access to those students who cannot avail the same at h Read More...

A magnificent view of Kathmandu as captured from Swayambhu on Monday, May 9, 2016. Photo: RSS

674 more infections logged in Kathmandu valley, amounts to over 58pc of total new cases

KATHMANDU: Kathmandu valley on Monday logged 674 new cases of coronavirus infection. As per the Health Ministry's latest report, of the total cases, the capital recorded 538 cases while 62 new infections surfaced in Lalitpur. Meanwhile, the number of active infections have been increasing stea Read More...

Nepal COVID-19 Update: 1154 new cases, 1005 recoveries, 16 fatalities logged Monday

KATHMANDU: Nepal’s Health Ministry, in its regular press briefing, shared the latest updates on coronavirus contagion from across the country, and government’s response to the health crisis. Read Also: 674 more infections logged in Kathmandu valley, amounts to over 58pc of total new cases Read More...

Indian filmmaker Anurag Kashyap to pursue legal route against sexual misconduct allegations, actress Payal Ghosh to file FIR

KATHMANDU: Bollywood filmmaker Anurag Kashyap, who has been accused of sexual misconduct by budding actress Payal Ghosh, said he intends to pursue legal action while the actress has said she will file an FIR against him. Issuing a statement through his lawyer, Kashyap also said it was sad that a Read More...

Indian actress Richa Chadha initiates legal action after Payal Ghosh drags her name in #MeToo case against Anurag Kashyap

KATHMANDU: Bollywood actress Richa Chadha has revealed that she has initiated legal action against after her name was dragged in a defamatory in #MeToo case against filmmaker Anurag Kashyap by actress Payal Ghosh. In a video released to ABN Telugu, Ghosh claimed that Kashyap tried to harass her i Read More...

American actress Mindy Kaling finds Deepika Padukone, Sonam Kapoor talented, wants to work with them

KATHMANDU: Indian origin American actress Mindy Kaling wants to work with Bollywood actresses Deepika Padukone and Sonam Kapoor as she finds them talented. "I would love to work with Sonam Kapoor or Deepika Padukone. They're both so talented," Mindy was quoted as saying Read More...

Manchester City _Ilkay Gundogan

Man City's Gundogan tests positive for COVID-19

LONDON: Manchester City midfielder Ilkay Gundogan has tested positive for COVID-19, the Premier League club said on Monday, making him the third player in the squad to return a positive test in recent weeks. City winger Riyad Mahrez and defender Aymeric Laporte previously tested positive for the Read More...