Nepal | July 05, 2020

Experts stress need for constitutional court

Himalayan News Service
Share Now:

Kathmandu, August 12

Experts today underscored the need for an independent constitutional court which interpreted the constitution independently and correctly.

They said the constitutional bench in the Supreme Court could not function as expected because of conflict of interest as the judges on the bench might also be represented in the Judicial Council which appoints and transfer judges.

According to the experts, the constitutional court is also necessary because various overlapping of interests might occur as the country has just embarked on a journey to federalism, and such issues should be addressed by independent and correct interpretation of the constitution.

“So if there’s no independent constitutional court, there might be crisis,” said Senior Advocate Purna Man Shakya, speaking at the ‘Conference on the Constitution of Nepal’ here today. “However, the constitutional court might not work if it is politicised or judges are not independent.”

Constitution expert Bhimarjun Acharya echoed Shakya, but said although there were many problems he was quite optimistic as Nepal’s judiciary was considered relatively better in South Asia. He said the constitution in Nepal had provisioned the simplest judiciary structure, which boosted people’s access to justice.

“Of course there are issues, but reforms in the appointment of the judges, educating the people and media and making the judges responsible could immediately solve such problems,” he said.

Advocate Menaka Guruswamy of India said judiciary in South Indian countries were heavily politicised. She suggested that having a constitutional court in each of these countries might bring some uniformity. The experts also said that since it was not realistic to find an independent judge at the time of appointment, there should be independence among the judges after appointment.

On the recent rejection of chief justice nominee Deepak Raj Joshee by the Parliamentary Hearing Committee, the experts said the judicial council should have carried out proper study beforehand whether a person was fit to hold the post.

They also said the rejection was made on subjective grounds and not based on facts, which set a negative precedent. Judges are now under constant fear that they might be rejected on subjective grounds, they added.


A version of this article appears in print on August 13, 2018 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Ministry develops guidelines for rehab centres

KATHMANDU, JULY 3 The Ministry of Women, Children and Senior Citizens has developed guidelines for operation of rehabilitation centres to ensure that vulnerable persons at the centres do not contract COVID-19. MoWCSC said the new guidelines would be effective until Nepal was declared coronavir Read More...

Nepali Congress Ram Chandra Paudel

Country pushed into crisis: Paudel

DAMAULI, JULY 3 Senior Nepali Congress leader Ramchandra Paudel said sudden prorogation of the Parliament was unfortunate for the nation. “At a time when the nation is fighting a deadly disease, the decision to prorogue the Parliament has pushed the country further into the crisis,” said t Read More...

Holding centre in Khotang

KHOTANG, JULY 3 A 10-bed holding centre has been established in Diktel, the district headquarters of Khotang, for returnees. According to Chief District Officer and District COVID-19 Crisis Management Centre coordinator Shaligram Sharma Poudel, Nepali Army personnel and Red Cross staff jointly Read More...

Visit Nepal 2020 mascot, yeti

Former Visit Nepal secretariat seeks more budget from Tourism Ministry

KATHMANDU, JULY 3 Even after the government has scrapped the secretariat of the Visit Nepal 2020 campaign, the secretariat has submitted more unpaid bills to the Ministry of Culture, Tourism and Civil Aviation (MoCTCA). Addressing a press meet today to unveil the ministry’s work progress dur Read More...

ADB country chief Kenichi Yokohama inspects Gautam Buddha International Airport in Lumbini

Tourism infrastructure development continues

KATHMANDU, JULY 3 Although the country is in a lockdown, infrastructure development activities under the Ministry of Culture, Tourism and Civil Aviation (MoCTCA) have continued. Organising a press meet today, Tourism Minister Yogesh Bhattarai unveiled the progress report of infrastructure deve Read More...

917 Nepalis rescued

KATHMANDU, JULY 3 The government which has been rescuing stranded Nepalis abroad repatriated 917 Nepali citizens and two dead bodies today through six different chartered flights. As per the Civil Aviation Authority of Nepal (CAAN) office based at Tribhuvan International Airport (TIA), Nepal A Read More...

Body of a girl found in Dhanusha's field; rape-murder suspected

JANAKPURDHAM: Police on Friday found the body of the girl who had gone missing since Wednesday in Janakpurdham Sub-Metropolitan City-21 of Dhanusha district. The deceased has been identified as 11-year-old Kanchan Panjiyar of Kurtha. When the girl, who had gone to herd a buffalo in the fie Read More...

Teenager dies by suicide after testing positive for coronavirus infection

DHANGADHI: A teenager has died by suicide after testing positive for the coronavirus infection in Sudurpaschim Province. The 18-year-old, staying at a quarantine facility in Lamagada Primary School in Khaptad Chhanna Rural Municipality-7 of Bajhang district, died by suicide on Friday. Accordin Read More...