Nepal | July 12, 2020

Investigation against Mahara should go on, opine lawyers

Himalayan News Service
Share Now:

Kathmandu, October 2

Legal experts say police cannot stop their investigation into the allegation of rape against Krishna Bahadur Mahara, who resigned as speaker yesterday, just because the accuser Roshani Shahi, a staffer at the Parliament Secretariat, retracted her statement.

Senior Advocate Satish Krishna Kharel said police had to complete preliminary investigation in the case after which they could decide either to close the case or carry on further investigation into the case.

Kharel said existing laws were enough to deal with challenges posed by Shahi’s retraction.

“Police launched investigation into a rape case in Kathmandu recently even when the victim had not lodged an FIR. In the case handled by Durbar Marg police post, the victim lodged an FIR three months after the incident,” said Kharel.

He said police investigation needed to determine whether the rape happened or whether Shahi did all this to blackmail Mahara.

If Mahara is innocent as he has claimed, he can get a clean chit only after police investigation finds no corroborative evidence against him. Asked if Shahi could face action for retracting her statement, Kharel said, “There are precedents where accusers have been punished by the court for retracting their statements in the court, but this case has not reached the court yet.”

He said Shahi’s refusal to lodge an FIR and to undergo physical examination posed challenge in gathering the most effective evidence, but there were other tools such as forensic examination, examining call details and tracing of Mahara’s location on Sunday night that police could rely on to complete the investigation and reach a conclusion.

Victims often retract their statements or turn hostile in the court due to fear of reprisal, coercion or inducements, said Kharel.

Criminal lawyer Gopal Krishna Ghimire said police could easily gather other evidences by interviewing security personnel deployed for the security of Mahara on Sunday night when Shahi claimed she was sexually assaulted to ascertain whether Mahara was at Shahi’s residence around that time.

Rajit Bhakta Pradhananga, who specialises in criminology, said there was no option for the police but to complete the probe which they had already started. “If Shahi does not come to the court, it could weaken the case, but the case must reach a conclusion,” he added. He said anybody can lodge FIR on behalf of Shahi.

Pradhananga said persons who Roshani Shahi told that she was raped by Mahara on Sunday night could face punishment if they did not inform police. There are media reports about Shahi ‘informing some people about the incident who did not inform the police about the same.’

As per Section 96 of the new penal code, if a person comes to know that a crime has happened or there is a possibility of the commission of a crime, but does not inform authorities concerned or gives false information about the crime, then such a person can face jail term not exceeding two years or a fine not exceeding Rs 20,000.


A version of this article appears in print on October 03, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Tarai districts at risk of floods after heavy rainfall in hilly region

RAUTAHAT: Tarai districts are at a high risk of floods as water level has risen alarmingly after incessant rainfall in hilly and Chure region in recent days. Locals residing on the banks of Bagmati and Lalbakiya rivers in Rautahat and Sarlahi districts have been living in terror of floods as Read More...

NHRC chief draws flak for condemning Mohna Ansari

KATHMANDU, JULY 10 National Human Rights Commission Chairman Anup Raj Sharma has drawn flak for issuing a press release condemning NHRC member Mohna Ansari for criticising Samajwadi Party-Nepal’s decision to expel Sarita Giri from both the party and the House of Representatives. Sharma h Read More...

Commission on the investigation of Enforced Disappeared Persons

Conflict victims lament govt’s apathy in their joint submission

KATHMANDU, JULY 10 Various victim groups of Nepal have made a joint submission to the 37th Session of the Working Group on Universal Periodic Review of the United Nations Human Rights Council, drawing its attention to the Government of Nepal’s persistent failure to deliver truth, justice, repar Read More...

Gaindakot, Nawalparasi

East-West Highway obstructed as flood sweeps diversion in Nawalpur

KATHMANDU: The East-West Highway has been obstructed since a diversion was washed away by a flash flood at Gaindakot section in Nawalparasi (East) district. It has been learnt that the vehicular movement along the highway came to halt after the flooded rivulet in Thumsi swept away the culvert o Read More...

Nepal Communist Party (NCP) standing committee meet put off for a week

KATHMANDU, JULY 10 The ruling Nepal Communist Party (NCP) has postponed its Standing Committee meeting for a week. NCP Spokesperson Narayan Kaji Shrestha wrote on his Twitter handle that the party took the decision to postpone its Standing Committee meeting to enable the party’s rank and fil Read More...

‘Regulate particular content, media, not entire industry’

KATHMANDU, JULY 10 Freedom Forum, a civil society organisation, issued a press release condemning cable operators’ decision to halt broadcast of Indian news channels, except Doordarshan, over misleading and defamatory content about Nepal. Freedom Forum said service providers and media carrie Read More...

Jada and Will Smith reveal marriage trouble on Facebook show

LOS ANGELES: With their marriage under social-media scrutiny, Jada Pinkett Smith and Will Smith reaffirmed their commitment to each other as Pinkett Smith admitted to having a relationship with musician August Alsina when she and Smith were separated. In a one-on-one conversation Friday on Pinke Read More...

Amazon says email to employees banning TikTok was a mistake

Roughly five hours after an internal email went out Friday to Amazon employees telling them to delete the popular video app TikTok from their phones, the online retailing giant appeared to backtrack, calling the ban a mistake. “This morning’s email to some of our employees was sent in error," Read More...