Nepal | August 12, 2020

State restructuring panel submits report to CA chair

Himalayan News Service
Share Now:

KATHMANDU: The Constituent Assembly Committee on State Restructuring and Distribution of State Power today submitted its concept paper and preliminary report to CA Chairman Subas Chandra Nembang.
Lokendra Bista, committee chairman, said his committee spent 13 months and seven days to prepare the concept paper and preliminary report, which has carved out 14 federal units based on ethnic/community identity. The committee passed the proposal of carving out 14 federal units on Wednesday. It also passed the proposal of autonomous region, special region and protected region for 23 minorities subject to further addition of other communities as well.
CA Chairman Nembang said it was encouraging that the SRDSP submitted its document on time set by the eighth amendment to the CA works schedule. He thanked all for giving their inputs for state restructuring. Nembang also urged all the political parties to focus their attention on drafting the new constitution on time.
Meanwhile, the Nepali Congress and the Madhesi Janaadhikar Forum lodged their objections to the proposal of 14 federal units passed by the committee on a majority basis.
NC CA member Narahari Acharya, who is also a member of the SRDSP, said there were "legal" and "political" flaws while endorsing the 14 federal units. NC had asked the committee to present both the models – 14 and six federal units – to the full CA House to generate public debate on their relevance.
In its different opinion registered with the CA secretariat, NC stated that the list of 23 minority communities for the autonomous region was a publicity stunt and it was passed by a majority of vote without doing adequate groundwork.
It said having already guaranteed the proportional inclusiveness on the basis of ethnic/community and gender it was not necessary to give the ethnic community the "political pre-emptive right to rule," which will undermine the universal values of democracy. The NC CA members also opposed the concept of right to self-determination, which, they said, was defined by the Article 169 of the UN ILO in a different context. The right to self-determination is irrelevant in Nepal’s context, NC CA members said.
Likewise, MJF co-president JP Gupta objected to the committee’s decision to divide the entire Tarai-Madhes into two separate federal units, creating Narayani region as a buffer zone between the Mithila and Tharuwan states. Gupta said southern part of Chitwan district is historically a Tharu dominated region and it should have been included either in Mithila or in Tharuhat states. He said ethnicity was taken as basis of carving federal units in the Hills/Mountains while language was made a basis of doing the same in the Tarai-Madhes.
He said the Madhesi parties would have given a second thought to the proposal of 14 federal units, had the major parties agreed to shift the federal capital from Kathmandu to Chitwan, which lies in the middle of the country.
Gupta threatened to launch an agitation in the Madhes if the full CA House did not consider the hegemony of major parties in the CA. "We will wait till the CA takes its final decision on federalism. Then we will go to the people," he said.
Anil Kumar Jha, CA member of the Sadbhavana Party, argued that the entire Tarai-Madhes region should be carved out into a single federal unit as agreed upon with the government on February 28, 2008.


A version of this article appears in print on January 22, 2010 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Ganges River flows with history and prophecy for India

ALONG THE GANGES: More than 2,000 years ago, a powerful king built a fort on the banks of India’s holiest river, on the fringes of what is now a vast industrial city. Today, little of the ancient construction remains, except for mounds of rubble that tannery workers pick through for bricks to b Read More...

Trump abruptly escorted from briefing after shooting near WH

WASHINGTON: President Donald Trump was abruptly escorted by a US Secret Service agent out of the White House briefing room as he was beginning a coronavirus briefing Monday afternoon. He returned minutes later, saying there had been a “shooting” outside the White House that was “under control. Read More...

Digitised interventions for social inclusion: Adapting to the unwelcomed crisis

Last year, two world-class wheelchair basketball coaches visited Nepal to conduct an intensive sports training aimed at raising the level of sports in the country. The training brought together more than 40 female and male wheelchair basketball players in Kathmandu - athletes and citizens living wit Read More...

World Food Programme to send 50,000 T of wheat flour to Lebanon: UN

DUBAI: A report by the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) released on Tuesday said the World Food Programme would be sending 50,000 tonnes of wheat flour to Beirut to stabilise Lebanon's wheat supply. A Reuters report on Friday revealed Lebanon's government held no Read More...

Balkhu jeep, leaving kathmandu

Public transportation sector most affected by lockdown: Transport Entrepreneurs

KATHMANDU: The plan to allow resumption of long-distance public transportation from August 17 across the country has again been cancelled. The Cabinet meeting held on Monday decided to resume flight operations from September 1 citing worsening situation due to surge in the number of COVID-19 case Read More...

Dortmund's Sancho to stay until 2023: club

BERLIN: Borussia Dortmund winger Jadon Sancho left with his team for a pre-season training camp in Switzerland on Monday with the German club saying the talented player would stay after a contract extension to 2023. Sancho has been the target of several top clubs with ongoing speculation of a Read More...

Kathmandu University, KU

Kathmandu University closed for 15 days from today

KATHMANDU: The Dhulikhel-based Kathmandu University (KU) has decided to shut down for the next 15 days starting today, owing to the growing risk of coronavirus infection. Issuing a notice on Monday, University registrar Prof Dr Subodh Sharma said all services (except most essential services Read More...