Nepal | September 22, 2020

Making city livable: Public discourse a must

Devendra Nath Gongal
Share Now:

Ranipokhari, Dharahara and Khokana of the Valley have been in the news in recent times. As the country pushes its development agenda, some issues surrounding these three icons must be taken into consideration

Illustration: Ratna Sagar Shrestha/THT

In recent times, Ranipokhari, Dharahara and Khokana have been in the news and it will be fascinating to contemplate on the fundamentals of a city based on issues surrounding them.

Ranipokhari is one of the most exquisite water bodies representing the glorious past of the Valley’s physical culture which became the central component of the beautiful architectural ensemble with the later additions of Durbar School and Ghantaghar on opposite sides. This is a perfect example of unity in diversity with different architectural designs that added charm to Kathmandu city. Dharahara is the newest object among these three, which by virtue of its form and location broke the traditional spatial planning culture of the Kathmandu Valley.

Khokana, on the other hand, is a silent and sleepy medieval settlement, famous for mustard oil. Surrounded by agriculture land, Khokana is an example of settlement planning of the Valley, which represents the ethos and sanctity of community.

The atmosphere of the lanes and squares and the condition of the buildings and structures caught me with surprise during my first visit to Khokana back in 1977. A settlement just eight kilometres from Lalitpur was a century behind Kathmandu with sewage-littered lanes and grim-looking faces of the local women labouring in the hazardous environment. This was an example of the absurdity of the myth of trickling down of development from big to peripheral smaller urban centres.

Before the 2015 earthquake, however, better drains and traditional residential houses professionally conserved by the house owners themselves were observed. The initiative was supported by UNESCO. So, how these three different objects can be encapsulated in one common frame?

Although issues related to conservation, reconstruction and development became hot news in recent past they also sparked a public discourse as to what a good city should look like.

We could appreciate from this discourse the fact that a town or a city is a complex part of human development where “spirituality”, “power”, “livelihood” and “sanctity of family” function in their strongest avatar and in perfect balance.

Ranipokhari embodies the sublime part of humanity and is a symbol of urban cosmology. The “spirituality” of this complex with aesthetically juxtaposed elements of water, a temple and a bridge uphold the qualitative value of Kathmandu’s urbanscape. This ill-fated Ranipokhari after sacrificing her bigger territory multiple times is now confined within an iron fence.

At the same time, the indiscriminately erected buildings around her provide limited openings for the people to appreciate and enjoy this icon of Kathmandu. Furthermore, the Gorkha Earthquake and subsequent attempts of conservation brought more disputes than solutions, and she is lying like an abandoned mining pit for more than three years. The traditional strength of Valley’s communities in conservation, accumulated through many centuries, was not used. And if the present stalemate is a harbinger of any predicament, Ranipokhari is at risk of being used for some other commercial purposes, which will further push her sublimity into ridicule.

Dharahara embodies earthly “power” imperative for a sustainable settlement. The motive of the selection of its architectural motif is not known. Nevertheless, a person like Bhimsen Thapa must have had a desire to show an ambition and hold of power. Moreover, even after losing all the power, specific structures like Dharahara can retain their historical influences. And the result was: this imposing structure dominated the skyline of Kathmandu. The power circle elites very readily took the initiative to reconstruct it, although it has no architectural value as such. Ordinary Nepalis also supported its reconstruction as it has dominated their minds and hearts through its structure, unique among those available around, which generated certain ecstasy and pride in them. For this reason, the reconstruction process of Dharahara is progressing without any substantial hurdle.

Khokana, an ordinary agrarian settlement, secluded with simple and subsistence lifestyle is a far cry from the energetic, fast-moving ubiquitous changes around. And the “change” came with a big bang associated with a menace to its livelihood and cultural heritage in the form of multiple roads (fast track, tunnel road and outer ring road) which usurped substantial amount of farmland.

The way the government handled the fast track portfolio sparked a series of protests. Contrary to the principle and guidelines representing the urban “power” prescribed by the government itself—to come to a committed understanding from all stakeholders before the start of any urban projects through dialogue and interaction—the government hastily moved in heavy equipment on locals’ rice fields.

Events in Khokana became one of the most controversial and disturbing aspects of the development of Kathmandu in recent times. With 293 municipal bodies, the government is in a spree to launch urban development in the country. Authorities engaged in this endeavour need to use the didactic value of the events in Dharahara, Ranipokhari and Khokana.

Gongal is the past chairman of SAARC Association of Architects


A version of this article appears in print on November 13, 2018 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

In Pictures: Lalitpur school provides internet facility to students sans access

Lalitpur, September 21 Teachers take online classes with internet facility provided by school at the empty classroom of Shree Rudrayanee Secondary School in Khokana, Lalitpur on Monday, September 21, 2020. The School has facilitated internet access to those students who cannot avail the same at h Read More...

Nepal COVID-19 Update: 1154 new cases, 1005 recoveries, 16 fatalities logged Monday

KATHMANDU: Nepal’s Health Ministry, in its regular press briefing, shared the latest updates on coronavirus contagion from across the country, and government’s response to the health crisis. Read Also: 674 more infections logged in Kathmandu valley, amounts to over 58pc of total new cases Read More...

Indian filmmaker Anurag Kashyap to pursue legal route against sexual misconduct allegations, actress Payal Ghosh to file FIR

KATHMANDU: Bollywood filmmaker Anurag Kashyap, who has been accused of sexual misconduct by budding actress Payal Ghosh, said he intends to pursue legal action while the actress has said she will file an FIR against him. Issuing a statement through his lawyer, Kashyap also said it was sad that a Read More...

Indian actress Richa Chadha initiates legal action after Payal Ghosh drags her name in #MeToo case against Anurag Kashyap

KATHMANDU: Bollywood actress Richa Chadha has revealed that she has initiated legal action against after her name was dragged in a defamatory in #MeToo case against filmmaker Anurag Kashyap by actress Payal Ghosh. In a video released to ABN Telugu, Ghosh claimed that Kashyap tried to harass her i Read More...

American actress Mindy Kaling finds Deepika Padukone, Sonam Kapoor talented, wants to work with them

KATHMANDU: Indian origin American actress Mindy Kaling wants to work with Bollywood actresses Deepika Padukone and Sonam Kapoor as she finds them talented. "I would love to work with Sonam Kapoor or Deepika Padukone. They're both so talented," Mindy was quoted as saying Read More...

Manchester City _Ilkay Gundogan

Man City's Gundogan tests positive for COVID-19

LONDON: Manchester City midfielder Ilkay Gundogan has tested positive for COVID-19, the Premier League club said on Monday, making him the third player in the squad to return a positive test in recent weeks. City winger Riyad Mahrez and defender Aymeric Laporte previously tested positive for the Read More...

Djokovic to face Schwartzman in Italian Open final

ROME: Novak Djokovic was made to work hard by Casper Ruud in blustery conditions before the world number one got past the unseeded Norwegian 7-5 6-3 on Sunday to reach the Italian Open final. The Serbian had to save two set points in the first set before finding his groove to reach his 10th title Read More...

Leicester go top, Liverpool claim second win as goals fly in

LONDON: Champions Liverpool and Leicester City maintained their winning starts to the Premier League on Sunday as the second weekend of the new season produced a goal-rush. Sadio Mane scored twice just after the break to give Liverpool a 2-0 victory at Chelsea who played half the game with 10 men Read More...