Nepal | May 27, 2020

Nepal’s tall buildings: Fire safety concerns

Ananta R. Baidya
Share Now:

Ensuring “Public Safety for All” in tall buildings is quite complex. In addition to structural safety (safety from dynamic forces such as earthquakes and wind), non-structural safety from fires must be fully considered and designed meeting all safety requirements                                   

Building engulfed in flames. Illustration: Ratna Sagar Shrestha/THT

Recent fires in high rise buildings raise important public safety concerns about fire safety in Nepal’s tall buildings and other structures. Challenges persist. Potential for disastrous consequences from fires hasn’t appeared in the mindset of Nepal’s infrastructure developers. In reality, Nepal has just begrudgingly started to accept and half-heartedly addresses the dangers from natural or man-made disasters after experiencing the after-effects of the massive 2015 Gorkha-Nepal Earthquake.

These fire incidents should serve as an awakening call for all – professionals, regulators and the public. Professionals, regulators and the public, educated about the issue of fire safety for all in buildings, will save lives.

Loss of life and the destruction to property by man-made fire disasters or natural disasters such as earthquakes, floods, high winds, etc. can be diminished by judicious decisions that are based on the state of the science and as reflected through evolving building codes.

Fire safety considerations involve consideration of numerous issues. Tall buildings are associated with their own special risks. The level of fire risk in smaller buildings depends on their fire load and includes their use and materials of construction. The risk to the number of people using that building facility must be considered.

Ensuring fire safety involves addressing many concept. Some of them include monitored alarm systems, fire sprinkler types and their design, fire exits, fire doors, smoke seal, anchorage of fire suppression piping and systems against earthquake forces, and others.

Issues such as smoke protection and fire protection, non-toxic fire suppressant systems, structural fire protection and impact on structural design must be addressed.

“Public Safety for All including People with Disabilities and the Elderly (PSFA) “, if a priority, must address the  inadequacy of fire-fighting resources in Nepal.The tragic aftermath from the 2015 Gorkha-Nepal Earthquake stands as testimony to the lack of attention paid to fire-fighting resources.

The Patan Fire House is completely destroyed. The condition of Juddha Barun Yantra building in Kathmandu is pathetic. The conditions at the fire stations, infrastructure development and inadequate oversights and community building design practices manifest these inadequacies. Antiquated systems cannot meet the needs of today’s Kathmandu Valley.

An anticipated consequence during the 2015 earthquake were fires in building originating from the storage of “natural gas” cylinders in homes. Luckily, such news did not dominate the airwaves. The best practice in Nepal of shutting off the valves of the gas cylinders were claimed to be the reason for lack of fire during the past earthquake.

Still, the fire dangers prevail. The experience of the fire at Paltan Ghar in 2012 cannot be forgotten. Nepal has not shown that it has taken the risk from fires very seriously.

Quality control of materials used in the construction of tall buildings in Nepal remains an issue. Do products that are used in Nepal, starting from the simple nuts and bolts to materials such as cladding, utility lines, connection, and partitions have the appropriate fire rating for the types of construction and the use of the structure?

Reports indicate that the West London Grenfell Tower and Hawaii’s Marco Polo Condominium buildings were not fitted with sprinklers. Modern codes require functioning fire sprinklers in tall buildings and public buildings holding large number of occupants such as malls and theaters (large gathering places), offices, schools, hotels, apartments etc. Such facilities are inspected annually and the fire suppression systems, such as fire sprinklers, certified.

In addition, modern codes require an emergency backup system of water in tanks in tall buildings. The backup system is required in addition to the pressurized public water system in modern cities.

In Nepal, tall buildings are required to have water tank as the primary source of water to fight fires. How they are inspected, their adequacy, location, etc remains an unresolved question.

Fire hydrants initially installed in Kathmandu in the early 1900s are now a rarity and pressurized public water system is still to come into operation. The old is gone and non-functional. A question should be asked. “Does the much anticipated Melamchi water supply system have fire hydrant installation provisions”. Ensuring “Public Safety for All” in tall buildings is quite complex.

In additional to structural safety (safety from dynamic forces such as earthquakes and wind), non-structural safety from fires must be fully considered and designed meeting safety requirements enforced.

Hawaii has decided to change laws and require all old buildings over 10 story to be retrofitted with fire sprinkler systems after the recent Marco Polo Condominium Fire.

The reach height of modern fire trucks is limited to 75 feet. The 10 story criteria makes sense as the building height will be around 75 feet. These considerations, if adopted in Nepal’s tall building design and construction, will save lives.

Baidya is a California based licensed engineer

A version of this article appears in print on August 03, 2017 of The Himalayan Times.

Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

Gharial crocodiles, Chitwan National Park

Ghariyal journeys 1,062 km to Hoogli

Chitwan, May 25 A gharial released in a river in Nepal has travelled over a thousand kilometres in the past two months. It was found in a river in India. According to Chitwan National Park Assistant Conservation Officer Bed Bahadur Khadka, a gharial with tagged number 687, which was released i Read More...

Inmates at risk of contracting coronavirus in Kathmandu valley

Kathmandu, May 25 About a month ago on April 22, two nurses working in the country’s largest prison at Sundhara tested positive for COVID -19 under the rapid diagnostic test. The test result sent a wave of panic among the 25,087 jailbirds, including 773 juveniles and additional 773 infants l Read More...

Armyworm severely affects maize production

Kathmandu, May 25 The American armyworm has severely affected maize farming across the country this year as compared to previous year, hitting farmers who have already had to bear the brunt of the coronavirus pandemic. According to Centre for Crop Development and Agro Bio-Diversity Conservatio Read More...

Budget expectations

The government is all set to announce the budget for next fiscal year on Thursday and people involved in different sectors have various expectations. Amid this, The Himalayan Times spoke to a few tourism entrepreneurs who were not satisfied with the government’s policies and programmes to learn ab Read More...

Over 10,000 Nepalis enter country from Jamunaha border point in four days

NEPALGUNJ: Over 10,000 Nepalis have entered the country from Jamunaha border point in Banke district amid nationwide lockdown imposed by the government to curb the spread of COVID-19. A large number of migrant workers returning from India have been gathering at the border point with the easing of Read More...

UN virus therapy trial pauses hydroxychloroquine testing

GENEVA: The World Health Organization said Monday that it will temporarily drop hydroxychloroquine — the anti-malarial drug US President Trump says he is taking — from its global study into experimental COVID-19 treatments, saying that its experts need to review all available evidence to date. Read More...

PMEP to be promoted as major source of employment next fiscal

Kathmandu, May 25 The government is preparing to promote the Prime Minister Employment Programme (PMEP) as the major source of employment for those who have lost or will lose their jobs due to the COVID-19 and for returnee migrant workers through the budget for the next fiscal year. The Minist Read More...

NRB directs BFIs to categorise banknotes based on quality

Kathmandu, May 25 Nepal Rastra Bank (NRB) has directed banks and financial institutions (BFIs) to categorise banknotes based on their quality — new, clean and useless. Issuing a nine-point circular on Sunday, the central bank directed BFIs to categorise banknotes accordingly and maintain the Read More...