Nepal | July 03, 2020

Former judges to scrutinise SC judgments

Say the structure of Judicial Council need to be changed

Ram Kumar Kamat
Share Now:

Kathmandu, August 15

Former Judges Forum-Nepal plans to scrutinise some of the recent judgments passed by the Supreme Court with the aim of identifying flaws in those judgments.

FJF-N has formed a five-member committee under Top Bahadur Singh to analyse some of the recent judgments of the apex court to inform the public as to how those judgments contradicted the jurisprudence established in past precedents of the apex court.

Member-Secretary of the committee Shambhu Bahadur Khadka told THT that the committee would start consulting stakeholders — judges, Judicial Council,  bar representatives, journalists and lawyers. “We’ll recommend the reasons for the erosion of public’s faith in the judiciary.”

Khadka said the suggestions of the committee would be submitted to the chief justice and if need be, also to the prime minister and political parties. He said the committee would also look into whether the parliamentary hearing of the justices was also a reason behind political influence on the judiciary.

A committee member, Rajendra Kumar Bhandari, said FJF-N took the initiative to suggest measures to enhance the image of the judiciary, as in recent months people felt that political influence was affecting the appointment of SC justices. “I can clearly see some discrepancies in some cases. One example is the Ncell case, which had already been  adjudicated by the full bench and yet it was  allowed to be revived in the court,” Bhandari said. He added that the FJF-N’s suggestions would help the judiciary to take corrective measures to enhance its image.

Former chief justice Ram Kumar Prasad Sah added that appointment of Supreme Court justices and its verdicts needed to be reviewed to enhance the image of the judiciary.

Sah said some of the judgments passed by the Supreme Court in recent years had contradicted the jurisprudence established in past judgments of the apex court and that needed to be reviewed. “People’s faith in judiciary can be enhanced only by sound judgments of the court. Some of the judgments have led to erosion of the people’s faith in the judiciary,” he said.

Sah added that in recent years, political influence had increased in the judiciary with political parties’ attempting to appoint their favourite candidates as the chief justice. “We notice that at the time of recommendation, dates of birth of the candidates are major criteria to ensure that certain candidate becomes eligible for the chief justice after certain years,” Sah said.

He added that this tendency would undermine the morale of judges who aspire to reach the highest post in the judiciary.

“The Judicial Council can resist politicians’ attempts to influence the judiciary, but I do not see that happening,” he added.

Former justice Krishna Jung Raymajhi said keeping the judiciary free from political influence could alone help enhance the image of judiciary. “We all know that justices are being appointed on the basis of their political leanings. There will be risk of political influence in judgment as long as judges are appointed on the basis of their political leanings,” he added.

He said the structure of the Judicial Council was faulty as three members of the body — Minister of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs, jurist appointed by the prime minister and Nepal Bar Association nominee — represent political ideology. He added that the current structure of the JC should be changed to make appointments more professional.


A version of this article appears in print on August 16, 2019 of The Himalayan Times.


Follow The Himalayan Times on Twitter and Facebook

Recommended Stories:

More from The Himalayan Times:

In Pictures: Protest against govt's ineffective response to COVID-19 crisis

Kathmandu, July 2 Youths hold placards while maintaining safe distance as they take part in a protest at Patan on Thursday demanding better and effective response from the government in handling COVID-19 outbreak. Read More...

Deepika Padukone champions #DobaraPoocho on importance of discussing mental health issues

KATHMANDU: Bollywood actor Deepika Padukone has urged to be a little more attentive towards their loved ones and repeatedly inquire about their life struggles and mental health issues, through a campaign #DobaraPoocho. Taking to her Instagram on June 30, 34-year-old actor posted a video about che Read More...

Bob Dylan makes chart history with Rough and Rowdy Ways

KATHMANDU: American singer-songwriter Bob Dylan has made a chart history with his 39th studio album Rough and Rowdy Ways — the critically-acclaimed full-length debuted at No 2 on the Billboard 200 chart, amassing three million streams and the equivalent of 53,000 album units in the United States. Read More...

British musicians call for govt to help live music industry

KATHMANDU: Some 1,500 British musicians including Sir Paul McCartney, Ed Sheeran and The Rolling Stones called for the British government on July 2 to support the live music business survive the novel coronavirus pandemic as the future for concerts, festivals and the people who work in them looks bl Read More...

Actor Samragyee RL Shah exposes sexual, mental and financial exploitation in the Nepali film industry

Actor says many others suffering in silence KATHMANDU : Nepali actor Samragyee RL Shah, who has opened up about harassment she claims to have faced in the Nepali movie industry via a series of videos on her Instagram account, has shared with The Himalayan Times graphic details what she has fa Read More...

Ray Fisher says director Joss Whedon was gross, abusive and unprofessional on Justice League set

KATHMANDU: American actor Ray Fisher has accused director Joss Whedon of gross, abusive and unprofessional behaviour on the set of the 2017 film Justice League. Taking to Twitter on July 1, Fisher who played the young superhero Cyborg in the DC Comics film wrote, "Joss Wheadon’s on-set treatme Read More...

City honour Liverpool - then hammer them 4-0

MANCHESTER: Manchester City generously applauded new champions Liverpool onto the field before their Premier League match on Thursday -- and promptly showed no mercy by thrashing them 4-0 at the Etihad stadium. With the title secured a week ago, there was little at stake for Juergen Klo Read More...

Real Madrid close on title as Ramos late show sinks Getafe

MADRID: Real Madrid captain Sergio Ramos kept his nerve to score a late penalty and secure a hard-fought 1-0 home win over Getafe on Thursday for a sixth consecutive La Liga victory to take his side one step closer to winning the title. Ramos coolly passed the ball into the net to brea Read More...